Guides
Requesting public records with FOIL
How to ask a New York City agency for records under the Freedom of Information Law: the OpenRecords portal, records access officers and how to word a request.
Government records belong to the public in the first place, and New York has a state law that says how to ask for them: the Freedom of Information Law, known everywhere as FOIL. It applies to city agencies as it does to state ones. Anyone can ask, for any reason, and the request does not have to explain why. This guide covers the practical side in New York City: where to send a request, what to put in it, what it may cost and what to do when you want more than the one agency can give.
Two ways to file
New York City runs a central system and also lets you go straight to an agency.
- The Citywide OpenRecords portal. This is the city's online system for FOIL requests, at a860-openrecords.nyc.gov. You create an account, pick the agency, describe the records and submit. The portal keeps the request in one place so you can follow it and read the answer. The Department of Citywide Administrative Services names it in its own FOIL instructions.
- The agency's Records Access Officer. Each agency has a records access officer, and a request can be sent to that person by mail or email. The agency's own website lists the contact for its officer. For the Department of Citywide Administrative Services (DCAS), the address for the officer's office is 1 Centre Street, 19th Floor North, in Manhattan.
If you are not sure which agency holds the records, the city's service line, 311, can help you find the right department; see using 311 effectively. Choosing the right agency at the start saves time.
What to put in a request
A FOIL request works best when it is specific. Include:
- A clear description of the records. Name the type of record, the subject, the people or places involved and the agency that holds them.
- A date range. "All inspection reports for 123 Example Street from January 2022 through December 2024" is better than "everything about the building." (The address in this example is made up.)
- The format you want. Say whether you prefer electronic copies or paper.
- Your contact details, so the agency can reach you with questions.
A request for existing records is what FOIL covers. An agency does not have to answer questions or create a new document, so write the request as a request for records, not as a question. "Please provide the complaint log for the Department of Buildings for this block" gets further than "why was my neighbor's permit approved?"
Many agencies already post records online. Before you file, look on the agency's website and on the city's open-data pages. Permit records, property tax information and many reports are public without a request. The Department of Finance has property tax bills and rates on its site, and the guide to How NYC property taxes work: classes, rates and the bill shows where.
What it costs
Copying fees are set by the agency. The DCAS instructions, for example, charge $0.25 per page for paper copies. The charge is by the page, so a short request costs little. If you are worried about a large request, ask the records access officer for an estimate before the work begins.
A worked example of copy costs
Say an agency answers with a 40-page report on paper, at $0.25 a page. The cost is 40 x $0.25 = $10.00. If the agency sends the report electronically instead, ask whether a per-page charge applies. The example is illustrative, and the rate in effect at an agency is the one posted on its own FOIL page.
What happens after you file
An agency must respond to a request, and it may give you the records, deny the request in whole or in part, or ask for more time or more information. A denial should come with a reason, and the letter explains how to appeal. The appeal goes to a different person at the agency, and its steps and deadlines are given on the denial notice and the agency's FOIL page, so read it as soon as it arrives and keep track of the dates.
Sometimes records are withheld for a stated reason, such as privacy or an ongoing investigation. If part of a document is withheld, ask whether the rest can be released with the sensitive details removed. You can also narrow a request that was too broad, which often speeds up an answer.
Reports and oversight bodies
Not every question needs a FOIL request. The city has watchdog agencies whose work is public:
- The Department of Investigation (DOI) investigates agencies, officers, elected officials and employees, and it publishes reports. It is one of the oldest law-enforcement agencies in the country, formed in the 1870s after the Tweed scandal. See Department of Investigation and city ethics bodies.
- The Comptroller audits agencies and publishes analyses, such as comments on the city budget, and runs a waste hotline at (212) NO-WASTE. See The City Comptroller.
- The Independent Budget Office publishes analyses of the city budget.
Reading a published audit or report is faster than waiting for a records request, and it sometimes answers the question outright.
Meetings and hearings
Records are one side of open government, and public meetings are the other. The City Council holds Stated Meetings twice a month at City Hall, in the Council Chambers, and its hearings are public; committees meet at least every other month except in July and August. The Council's calendar, agendas and bills are on its Legistar site. See The New York City Council. Attending a hearing or reading the transcript is often the quickest way to find out what an agency told the Council.
Tips from the process
- Start with the agency's own page. It may already post the record, or a form for the request.
- Keep a copy of every submission and the date you sent it.
- Be polite and specific. A clear request gets a clear answer.
- Be patient and follow up in writing. Use the portal's messages or the officer's email, so there is a record.
- Ask for help if stuck. The records access officer is the person assigned to answer requests, and 311 can point you to the right agency.
For the bigger picture of records and open meetings in the city, see Public records and open meetings. This guide is general information, not legal advice, and the agency's own instructions govern any particular request.