Blog

Charter section 1138: how term limits count

A question-and-answer guide to the City Charter's term-limit section: two full consecutive terms, and how a resigned or removed mayor is counted.

Charter section 1138 sits deep in a document that most New Yorkers have never read, and yet it decides who is allowed to run for the three biggest offices on the ballot. It is the term-limits section. What follows takes it a question at a time, the way a city-hall explainer would, because that is how people actually ask about it: usually on the morning after someone announces a run.

What does section 1138 say, in plain English?

It limits how long a person can hold certain elected city offices in a row. The rule, as the City Council's own bill history for the 2002 legislation describes it, is two full consecutive terms. A person who has served two full consecutive terms in an office cannot be elected to a third consecutive term in that same office.

The section covers the citywide offices, mayor, public advocate and comptroller, and the members of the City Council. The offices are described in the Charter's early chapters: a mayor, a public advocate and a comptroller are elected citywide, and the Council is made up of the public advocate and fifty-one other members, according to Chapter 2. The mayor's term, under the Charter, runs four years and begins on January 1 after the election.

Two words in the rule do the heavy lifting, and both are easy to skip over: "full" and "consecutive."

What does "consecutive" mean here?

It means the limit applies to terms served back to back. A person who serves two terms, steps out of the office for a full term, and then runs again is not covered by the bar in the same way as a person who tries to run for a third term right after a second. The limit is a limit on running in the cycle that would extend an unbroken run, not a lifetime ban. That is why New Yorkers sometimes see a former mayor or council member returning to the ballot after a gap, and why the question "is he allowed to run?" so often turns on the calendar, not on the person.

The word also matters across offices. The limit is written office by office. Someone who has served two terms as comptroller is not barred from running for mayor under the same rule, and a public advocate can run for another office without the term count carrying over. That is how an official's career in the city can move from one citywide post to another over decades.

What does "full" mean, and why is it there?

This is the part that makes the section more than a counting exercise. The Charter treats a mayor who resigns or is removed before finishing a term as having served a full term for purposes of section 1138. The provision closes a loophole. Without it, someone could leave the office a few days early, in a way that left the term technically incomplete, and then argue that the term did not count against the limit.

The rule runs the other direction as well, and this is the part that surprises people. A mayor who leaves early does not get a break from the term count. The clause says that a mayor who resigns or is removed before a full term is deemed to have held a full term. In other words, an early departure does not reset the clock in the person's favor; it spends the term. The Council's bill history for the 2002 local law describes the limit the same way, as two full consecutive terms, and the Charter text for the mayoral provisions contains the clause on the resigned or removed mayor.

Consider a hypothetical, labeled as one. Say a mayor wins election, serves two years, and resigns to take another office. The clause says that person has held a full term. Say that person later runs again after sitting out a cycle: the first stint counts as one full term already. The calendar math is built to be simple and hard to game.

Where did the rule come from?

Term limits came to New York by voter initiative in the 1990s, not by the Council's own decision. In 1993, voters approved a two-term limit for the city's elected officials, and the Charter was changed to reflect it. The limit took effect for the offices in the following elections, and the Council has revisited the question since, which is where the section's history gets interesting.

In 2008, the Council passed a bill that extended the limit to three terms for the officials then in office, a move that drew heavy public criticism and a legal challenge. In 2010, voters were asked to restore the two-term limit in a referendum and did so, and the Charter has carried that rule ever since. The back-and-forth is one of the best examples of the way the Charter functions as a living document: the people have a direct say in it, the Council has an indirect say, and each side has at times claimed the other overstepped.

The 2002 bill history is relevant because it is where the Council's own description of the limit as two full consecutive terms is on the record. That language is the one the city's legal community cites when it explains what the section means.

Does the limit apply to Council members, too?

Yes. Council members are covered by the same two-full-consecutive-terms rule, with the added wrinkle that their term lengths are not always four years. Under section 25 of the Charter, members elected in 2001 and every twentieth year after serve two-year terms rather than four-year ones. That is tied to the redistricting that follows each census, and it is explained in Why some Council terms last two years. How "full" works when a term is two years rather than four is a question for the Charter's text and the Council's counsel, but the principle is the same: the limit counts terms, and a term, however long, is a term.

The practical effect is that Council seats turn over on a predictable schedule, which is the point of the limit. Open seats attract crowded fields of candidates, and the voters get a new choice in a seat that would otherwise have an incumbent.

What about the mayor's powers?

The limit is a limit on how long a mayor serves; it does not change what a mayor does. The Charter makes the mayor the head of the city's executive branch, with the power to appoint the heads of administrations and departments and all commissioners under section 6, and deputy mayors under section 7. A strong-mayor structure paired with a two-term limit means the city's executive agenda has a natural eight-year horizon. The office and its staff are described in The Mayor's Office, and the overall design of the Charter is explained in The strong-mayor charter in plain English and How New York City government works.

As of 2026, the mayor is the 112th in the city's list, sworn in on January 1, 2026. The city itself notes the numbering is subject to a records miscount, which the mayor's inaugural address acknowledged in saying "either your 111th or 112th." The number is a footnote to the term-limits story, but it is a reminder of how much history the office carries.

Who can change the rule?

Voters, through the ballot, and the Council, through legislation, within the limits the Charter and state law set. The most recent round of Charter changes came before voters on November 3, 2026, when five amendments from the Commission on Government Efficiency were on the ballot; they dealt with revocable consents, contractor paperwork, street-safety projects, city-owned property and building permits, and the rainy-day reserve. None of the five concerned term limits, and press reports say voters approved all five in unofficial results. The ballot items are summarized in Five charter questions on the November 2026 ballot.

The mechanism matters because it shows that the Charter is not frozen. A rule that came from voters in 1993 and was reaffirmed by voters in 2010 can be changed again only by a process that the voters ultimately control, even when the Council takes the first step.

How do I find the text?

The Charter's official text is published through the city's code library, and mirror copies of its chapters are widely available online. The mayoral and Council provisions cited here are in Chapters 1 and 2. The Council's legislative database carries the 2002 bill history, which is the best short summary of how the Council itself describes the limit. A reader who wants a primary source should start with the Charter and the Council's legislation page, and for the city's ballot measures the Board of Elections and NYC Votes publish plain-language summaries.

What the section means for a voter

The limit shapes the ballot more than it shapes any single decision. It makes certain seats come open on a schedule, it forces parties and candidates to plan for succession, and it gives challengers a reason to wait. It also invites a question every few years about whether eight years is the right length of time. That debate is a political one, and the record shows serious arguments on each side: supporters say limits prevent entrenchment and open the field; critics say they take experience out of government and shift power to unelected staff. Section 1138 itself settles neither argument. It simply says that, when two full consecutive terms have been served, the voters will have to choose someone else.

Related city government

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic