Blog

Churches and chapels of Lower Manhattan

Trinity Church and St. Paul's Chapel in the Financial District, and Most Precious Blood Church on Baxter Street, home of the San Gennaro statue.

Lower Manhattan is where the money lives, and it is also where New York keeps some of its oldest places of worship. The two facts are connected. A parish chartered by an English king in 1697 ended up sitting on some of the most valuable land in the country, and the congregations that came after built their churches near the docks and the markets where their members lived and worked. A morning on foot between Wall Street and Baxter Street covers three centuries of the city's religious life, from an Anglican parish at the head of Wall Street to an Italian-American church a few blocks from Canal.

This is a walk through three of those places: Trinity Church, St. Paul's Chapel, and Most Precious Blood Church. It is not a complete survey. The island has many more houses of worship, and each neighborhood has its own. But these three share a stretch of the map and a quality: each is a working congregation that also happens to be a landmark.

Trinity Church, where Wall Street begins

Trinity Church stands at the head of Wall Street, facing down the canyon toward the river. The parish received its charter from King William III in 1697, which makes it one of the oldest in the country. The church building has been rebuilt more than once. The first church went up in 1698. The second was consecrated in 1790, with George Washington, then president and living in New York, in attendance. The building people see today dates to 1846 and is in the Gothic Revival style.

That 1846 church was, for a time, the tallest structure in the city, a fact that is hard to picture now with the towers of the Financial District crowding it on every side. Its spire is dwarfed. The effect is a church that looks like a model of itself, a medieval building shrunk to the scale of a Manhattan block, with glass towers hanging over it.

The churchyard is part of the experience. Old gravestones, some of them from the eighteenth century, stand in a patch of grass between the church and the street. Alexander Hamilton is buried there, and visitors come for his grave as much as for the building. The yard works as a small public park for the people who work nearby, and on a weekday lunch hour it fills with office workers eating from paper bags among the stones.

Trinity is still an active parish, with services and music, and the church is open to visitors at times set by the parish. Its own website lists the schedule, which varies, so check before a visit.

St. Paul's Chapel, the survivor

A few blocks north, on Broadway between Fulton and Vesey Streets, is St. Paul's Chapel. It was built in 1766 as a chapel for Trinity's growing congregation, and it is the oldest surviving church building in Manhattan. It survived the fire of 1776 that destroyed the first Trinity, which is part of why it is where it is in history. And it survived September 11, 2001, when the World Trade Center towers fell just across the street. The chapel's churchyard and building came through with very little damage, and in the weeks after the attacks it became a place of rest and relief for workers at the site. The story of that day and its memorials is in september 11, 2001 and the memorial.

St. Paul's holds a place in the city's civic memory for an earlier reason too. George Washington took the oath of office as the first president on April 30, 1789, at Federal Hall on Wall Street, and on the day of the inauguration Washington went on to a service at St. Paul's. The inauguration is covered in Washington's inauguration at Federal Hall, 1789. Washington was in New York because the city served as the national capital from 1785 to 1790, a period outlined in New York in the Revolution, 1765 to 1783 and the pieces around it.

Architecturally, the chapel is a modest, handsome eighteenth-century building: a Georgian church in stone, with a portico facing the churchyard on the Broadway side. It is a quieter place than Trinity and tends to feel more intimate. A visitor stepping in from Broadway leaves the noise of the street behind quickly.

Why the two belong together

Trinity and St. Paul's are best understood as one parish with two buildings. Trinity is the parish church. St. Paul's was originally a chapel, built because the congregation had grown and the city was moving north, away from the old Wall Street core. A chapel of ease, in the old Church of England phrase, is a smaller church built for the convenience of parishioners who live far from the main building. By the 1760s lower Manhattan's growth had made that necessary.

The same story, repeated, accounts for much of the city's early church map. As the city grew up the island, congregations followed their members, rebuilt on new sites, and left the old buildings behind. What is remarkable about these two is that the older of them is still standing, still in use, and still within sight of the first.

Most Precious Blood and the San Gennaro statue

The third stop is a different world, though not many blocks away. Little Italy is a small area north of Chinatown, within the city planning department's SoHo-Little Italy-Hudson Square district, and its heart is Mulberry Street. On Baxter Street stands the Most Precious Blood Church, and that church holds the statue of San Gennaro, the patron saint of Naples.

The statue ties the church to one of the city's best-known street events, the Feast of San Gennaro, which has been held since 1926. The feast runs for days along the streets of Little Italy, with the saint's statue at the center of the observance. The whole festival is a descendant of the Neapolitan devotion that immigrants brought with them, and the church on Baxter Street is where the statue is kept. The history of the feast is in The Feast of San Gennaro since 1926.

What the church shows is how an immigrant parish held its own faith and customs in a new place. The nineteenth- and early twentieth-century Italian migration to New York filled the tenements of the Lower East Side and the blocks around Mulberry Street, and the church was the place where the community prayed, married and buried its members. The neighborhood has shrunk and changed since then, with Chinatown pressing in from the south and the area's restaurants serving a mostly different clientele, but the church and the festival remain. For a sense of how neighborhoods were built by successive communities, see the communities that built the neighborhoods.

A short route

Together the three churches make a walk of about a mile and a half, and the subway connects all of them.

  1. Start at Trinity Church. Take the 4 or 5 to Wall Street, or the 2 or 3, which stop on the same Wall Street line. Walk the churchyard and look at the facade from the Broadway side.
  2. Walk north on Broadway to St. Paul's Chapel. The walk is under ten minutes. Fulton Street station, served by the 2, 3, 4, 5, A, C, J and Z, sits next to it.
  3. Continue north to Little Italy. From St. Paul's the walk to Baxter Street is a longer one; the 6 train at Canal Street, or the B, D, F and M at Broadway-Lafayette Street, shortens it. Most Precious Blood Church is on Baxter Street, in the heart of the area.
  4. End on Mulberry Street, where the Feast of San Gennaro takes over the street when it is held.

For a longer outing built on the same geography, The Financial District, where New York began and Washington Square and the Villages add more stops, and Chinatown eats: the Mott and Canal Street corridor covers the neighborhood next door.

Landmarks and respect

Many of Lower Manhattan's old buildings are protected under the city's landmarks law, administered by the Landmarks Preservation Commission, which was created in 1965 after the loss of Pennsylvania Station. That history is in The Landmarks Law and the loss of Penn Station. The protection extends to exteriors and, in some cases, to interiors, which is why these churches look much as they did generations ago even as everything around them changes.

A few reminders for visitors. These are active places of worship, so services take precedence over sightseeing, and some areas will be closed during them. Photography rules vary by church and by the day. Dress modestly and speak quietly, and take any posted rules seriously. Admission and hours change and are set by each parish, so each church's own site has the current schedule. For other no-cost ideas around the city, see Free things to do in New York City.

What the three have in common

On paper the three are quite different: an Anglican parish with a royal charter, its chapel on Broadway, and a Catholic church with an Italian saint. In practice they are three answers to the same question: what does a congregation do when the city around it changes beyond recognition? Trinity answered by staying put and letting the skyscrapers rise around it. St. Paul's answered by surviving, twice. Most Precious Blood answered by keeping a statue, a feast and a community going on a street that is now much smaller than it was.

Lower Manhattan is more than offices. Behind the glass there are churchyards and old stones, and a few doors still open every week on people who have been coming for generations.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic