Blog
Five boroughs, five counties, five district attorneys
Each borough is also a state county with its own elected district attorney; how that fits state courts, OATH hearings and the Department of Correction.
New York City has one mayor, one Council, one police department and one fire department. For prosecuting a crime, it has five of something: five district attorneys, one for each borough. The reason is a feature of the city's legal map that surprises newcomers and long-time residents alike. Every borough is also a county of New York State, and in New York a district attorney is a county official.
The correspondence is exact. Under the geography the Department of City Planning uses, each of the five boroughs is coextensive with a county:
| Borough | County |
|---|---|
| Manhattan | New York County |
| Brooklyn | Kings County |
| Queens | Queens County |
| The Bronx | Bronx County |
| Staten Island | Richmond County |
This explains a lot of local vocabulary. A court calendar that refers to "Kings County" is talking about Brooklyn. A notice from "New York County" is about Manhattan, even though the whole city is New York City. And a person called for jury service in Queens is called by the county of Queens.
How the city came to have five counties
The five boroughs came together on January 1, 1898, when consolidation created the five-borough city, after the charter of Greater New York became law on May 4, 1897. The counties pre-dated the consolidation and survived it. The Bronx was the last piece of the map to fall into place: it was part of New York County until it became its own county on January 1, 1914.
So the city is a single municipal government laid over five state-defined counties. The city's departments, such as the police and fire departments, are citywide. But the county, a creature of state law, remains the unit for several functions, notably the election of district attorneys, the organization of courts and the summoning of jurors.
The five district attorneys
New York's County Law provides for an elected district attorney in each county, serving a four-year term. In the city that means five separate offices, each with its own staff and its own website:
- Manhattan: manhattanda.org
- Brooklyn: brooklynda.org
- Queens: queensda.org
- The Bronx: bronxda.nyc.gov
- Staten Island: the Richmond County district attorney's office; 311 can direct you to it.
A district attorney prosecutes violations of state law that occur in the county. So a robbery, an assault or a fraud in Brooklyn is prosecuted by Brooklyn's district attorney, and the same offense in Queens by Queens's. The offices decide whom to charge, how to present a case, and how to handle plea negotiations, and they operate independently of one another. Each has its own policies and priorities. Two offices can handle similar cases differently, and that difference is part of what the five-county structure means in practice.
The mayor does not appoint district attorneys, and the district attorneys do not report to the mayor. Voters in each county elect their own, which makes the five offices quite different from the city's agencies. The mayor appoints heads of departments such as the Police Commissioner and the Fire Commissioner, as Charter section 6 provides, and those appointees run citywide organizations. A district attorney is elected by the voters of a single borough and answers to them.
Following a case through the system
A hypothetical shows how the layers fit. Say a car is stolen in Queens and the police make an arrest. This is a labeled example, not a description of any real case.
- The arrest. The New York City Police Department, which has 78 patrol precincts and is one citywide organization, makes the arrest. It does not matter which borough's precinct handles it: the NYPD is a single department with about 33,000 officers and 15,000 civilian employees.
- The charge. Because the theft occurred in Queens, the Queens district attorney decides whether to prosecute and on what charges.
- The court. The case is heard in a New York State court sitting in Queens County. The New York State Unified Court System runs the state trial courts in the city and the jury system. These are state courts, not city agencies.
- Custody. If the defendant is held while awaiting trial, or sentenced to a year or less, the city's Department of Correction has custody. The department's job is the custody of people awaiting trial or sentenced to a year or less.
- The jury. If the case goes to trial, jurors come from the county, summoned by that county's Commissioner of Jurors through the court system's jury process. Jury duty in New York City: questions and answers explains how jury service works.
Because the county is the unit for juries, a person who lives in one borough serves on a jury summoned by that county's Commissioner of Jurors. The example shows that the city and the county each handle part of the process. The arrest and the jail are city functions, and the charge and the trial are county and state ones.
Where OATH fits
Not every violation ends up in the criminal courts. The Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings, OATH, is the city's central administrative law court. Its Hearings Division handles summonses from more than 25 enforcement agencies, including the Departments of Buildings, Sanitation, Environmental Protection, Consumer and Worker Protection, Health and the Taxi and Limousine Commission. Its Trials Division handles referrals such as employee discipline and cases from the Conflicts of Interest Board.
The distinction is worth drawing. A parking ticket or a summons for a sanitation violation is a civil or administrative matter, handled through agencies and hearings, not prosecuted by a district attorney. A crime under state law, such as assault or larceny, is a criminal matter in the state courts. How to pay or dispute a parking ticket in New York City covers the parking side, where disputes go through the Department of Finance.
Boroughs, borough presidents and community boards
The county structure sits beside another layer of borough-level government. Each borough elects a borough president. The 1989 charter changes, described in 1989: the year the Board of Estimate ended, ended the borough presidents' seats on the Board of Estimate, but the offices remain. Below the borough level, the Department of City Planning counts 59 community districts, the broad official geography the city uses for local planning and services.
These layers do not map neatly onto one another. The borough and the county coincide, but the 51 Council districts, the 59 community districts and the police precincts each divide the city in their own way. A resident might live in one borough, one county, one Council district, one community district and one police precinct, each with a different set of officials. The Council districts follow population; the Council is explained in The New York City Council.
Why it matters to residents
The five-county structure has several practical consequences.
- Who to contact. If you are a witness or a crime victim, the district attorney's office for the county where the crime occurred handles the case, and each office has its own contact information and victim services. The offices' websites are the place to look.
- Elections. District attorney is an elected office on ballots in each county, so a resident of Brooklyn votes for Brooklyn's district attorney and not for Queens's. The Board of Elections runs the city's elections, and How voting works in New York City: poll sites, ranked choice and ballot measures explains how to register and vote.
- Jury duty. A summons comes from the county where you live. The state's NYJUROR.GOV site handles jury service, and the state courts never ask for credit card or bank numbers by phone or email, a warning that matters because of jury-duty scams. See scams and fraud: parking texts and juror calls.
- Population differences. The five counties differ greatly in size. In the July 2025 estimate, Brooklyn had 2,653,963 residents, Queens 2,358,182, Manhattan 1,664,862, the Bronx 1,406,332 and Staten Island 501,290. Brooklyn's population was more than five times Staten Island's (2,653,963 divided by 501,290 is about 5.3). A prosecutor's office serving Brooklyn is dealing with a very different caseload than one serving Staten Island, and the five offices vary in size accordingly.
The five counties by the numbers
The Department of City Planning's population estimates, based on the 2020 Census and the Census Bureau's estimate for July 1, 2025, show how unevenly the five counties are sized, and how they have moved since the Census:
| County (borough) | 2020 Census | July 2025 estimate | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kings (Brooklyn) | 2,736,074 | 2,653,963 | down 3.0 percent |
| Queens | 2,405,464 | 2,358,182 | down 2.0 percent |
| New York (Manhattan) | 1,694,251 | 1,664,862 | down 1.7 percent |
| Bronx | 1,472,654 | 1,406,332 | down 4.5 percent |
| Richmond (Staten Island) | 495,747 | 501,290 | up 1.1 percent |
The citywide total was 8,804,190 in 2020 and 8,584,629 in the 2025 estimate. The Bronx's decline in the estimate is the steepest, and Staten Island's the only increase. These are estimates and percentages are rounded, and they are not caseload figures: nothing in a population table tells you how many cases a district attorney's office handles. But the size gap explains why the five offices are organized differently, and why a city-level rule is often applied by five separate county offices.
Seeing the structure on the ground
The county idea has a physical form in the borough's civic districts: courthouses and government buildings in each borough's center. St. George in Staten Island, with its ferry terminal and the borough's civic buildings nearby, is described in St. George, and Jamaica in Queens, a transit hub in the southeast of that borough, is covered in Jamaica. Manhattan's civic center around City Hall is the home of the city's own government, and the stories of that district are told in Tweed and the birth of the Department of Investigation.
For an overview of how the five boroughs differ, the five boroughs and their counties is the starting point, and The five boroughs and their counties describes the county-level offices.