Blog
How restaurant letter grades work
New York's restaurant letter grades turn health inspection points into an A, B or C. The score ranges, the inspection cycle, Grade Pending cards and the lookup.
A restaurant in New York City has to hang a letter in its window. Since 2010, the city has required restaurants to post a letter grade that corresponds to the score the restaurant received on a sanitary inspection. The letter is an A, a B or a C, and the rule is that it must be posted where people passing by can easily see it. A diner reads it before opening the door.
The system is one of the city's public faces for the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, which the department's own page calls the nation's oldest municipal public health agency. It has an annual budget of $2.5 billion and more than 7,000 employees, and among the services it lists are restaurant letter grades, dog licenses and birth certificates. This article is about the first of those: how the grades are produced and what they mean.
The scores behind the letters
The grade starts with a score. At the end of an inspection, the inspector adds up points for every condition that violates city or state food safety rules, and the total is the restaurant's inspection score. The direction is the opposite of a school test. A lower score is better, because points are penalties.
The department's page sets the thresholds:
| Inspection score | Grade |
|---|---|
| 0 to 13 points | A |
| 14 to 27 points | B |
| 28 or more points | C |
Say an inspector finds conditions that add up to 12 points. The restaurant earns an A. If the same inspection had added up to 13, it would still be an A, but one more point, 14, moves the grade to a B. At 27 points it is still a B, and 28 or more is a C. The boundaries fall on those exact numbers, so a single violation can be the difference between letters.
How often restaurants are inspected
The Health Department's inspection page says that every restaurant in the city is scheduled for an unannounced inspection at least once a year. During the inspection an inspector checks for compliance with city and state food safety regulations and marks points for any condition that violates them. The inspections are unannounced, so a restaurant cannot prepare a special visit. The department also publishes materials that tell operators how to identify a health inspector and how an inspection is conducted, and a Business Owner's Bill of Rights that explains what an operator can expect.
Operators who want to improve can ask for help in advance. The department offers consultative inspections for new food service establishments, and a body of training and guidance, including a document titled "Practicing A-Grade Food Safety." Operators can also submit confidential feedback about inspections to the department through its customer survey page.
What happens after a score
The grade does not always come directly from the first inspection. The department's cycle works in steps. A restaurant that scores 0 to 13 points on an initial inspection earns an A. A restaurant that scores more points is inspected again, and the re-inspection determines the grade.
If the re-inspection produces a B or a C, the restaurant is issued a grade card and a Grade Pending card, and it can post either one until it has a chance to be heard at the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings, the city's central administrative law court. OATH hears summonses from more than 25 enforcement agencies, including the Health Department, and handles them through its Hearings Division. The Health Tribunal at OATH is where a restaurant answers a summons and settles violations, online or at a hearing.
So a "Grade Pending" card does not mean the restaurant is in trouble beyond the points it received. It means a final grade has not yet been issued because the hearing process has not run its course. The department's page on settling violations explains the process for the owner. Department of Health and Mental Hygiene has the department's record, and the Hearings Division is described on the OATH site.
What a diner sees
The grade card is meant to be seen from the sidewalk. The department's rule is that cards must be posted where people passing by can easily see them. A diner walking past a restaurant can read the letter before entering, and can look up the underlying results.
The department publishes restaurant inspection results on its website, searchable by restaurant. The grade is a summary, and the results behind it list the violations that were found on an inspection. A diner who wants to know why a restaurant has a B can look up the inspection and read the conditions that counted.
Mobile food vendors are included: the Health Department's page on mobile food vending has its own section on letter grades, so carts and trucks that hold a permit are part of the same system. the halal cart story and Street vending and DCWP licenses discuss how cart vending is licensed.
If a grade card is lost
Operators who lose a card have a procedure. If a letter grade card is lost, stolen, damaged or not issued by OATH, the restaurant should report it as soon as possible to the Bureau of Food Safety and Community Sanitation, at (212) 676-1600 or by email at [email protected]. To get a replacement, the operator must send a notarized replacement form to the bureau by mail, email or fax, and the department sends the new card by certified mail to the establishment. The bureau's address is 125 Worth Street, in Manhattan.
What the grade does and does not say
A letter grade is a snapshot of a particular inspection. It says how many points of violations an inspector found on a given day against a published rule set. It does not rank restaurants against each other or say anything about taste, price or service, and this article does not rank anyone. A restaurant with an A on one inspection can score differently on the next, and a B restaurant has the chance to be inspected again.
The system's rules also say something about how the city regulates a vast number of small businesses. Every restaurant is inspected at least annually, the standard is published, the result is posted on the door, and the full record is online. That combination of regular inspection, public posting and an administrative court for disputes is the template. The city's other regulated businesses, from food vendors to the more than 45,000 businesses in over 45 industries licensed by the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, have their own versions. how to get a city business license and Starting a business and getting a license in New York City explain how licensing works for a new business.
Questions that come up
Is every restaurant graded? The rule applies to restaurants that the department inspects, and every restaurant in the city is scheduled for an unannounced inspection at least once a year. Mobile food vending units that hold permits have their own letter-grade section on the department's site.
Does a higher number mean a better grade? No. The score counts points for violations, so 0 is the best possible result and larger numbers are worse. An A is 0 to 13, a B is 14 to 27 and a C is 28 or more.
What is OATH? The Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings is the city's central administrative law court. Its Hearings Division handles summonses from more than 25 enforcement agencies, including the Department of Buildings, the Department of Sanitation, the Department of Environmental Protection, the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, the Health Department and the Taxi and Limousine Commission. Its Trials Division handles referrals such as employee discipline and cases from the Conflicts of Interest Board. A restaurant's hearing on health violations is one of many kinds of case it hears.
Who regulates what? The Health Department runs restaurant inspections, grades and food vending permits. The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection licenses businesses in more than 45 industries and issues general vendor licenses for non-food goods. The line between the two matters for vendors, and the halal cart story in the halal cart story explains why a food cart answers to the Health Department rather than to the consumer protection department.
Where do I go if I have a complaint? The city's 311 line takes requests and complaints, and the portal at portal.311.nyc.gov handles them online. From outside the city the number is (212) 639-9675.
Why a public grade
The grade card is an example of a regulatory idea: instead of keeping inspection results inside a file, make them visible at the point of decision. A diner deciding whether to eat at a restaurant sees the letter, and a restaurant has a reason to care about the score. The city's version has run since 2010, and it has a plain structure of published thresholds, unannounced inspections, a re-inspection step and a hearing for disputes.
The same logic runs through other parts of the city's regulatory system, where a public record or a posted notice does some of the enforcement work. Who watches city officials: DOI, COIB and the CCRB looks at the city's oversight bodies from a different angle, and Birth certificates, dog licenses and the Health Department covers the department's other public services.
A short guide for diners
- Read the card before you go in. It is posted for that reason.
- Look up the inspection. The Health Department's results page lists the violations behind a grade.
- Understand Grade Pending. It means the final grade is waiting on a hearing, not that the restaurant failed.
- Report problems. The city's 311 line takes calls about city services, and using 311 effectively explains how to use it.
The Health Department's official page on the program is Letter Grading for Restaurants, and the department's record in this directory is Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. For an overview of the city's other public-facing health functions, see Birth certificates, dog licenses and the Health Department.