Blog

How to file a complaint with the CCRB

The independent CCRB takes complaints about NYPD force, abuse of authority, discourtesy and offensive language. The ways to file, and what happens next.

Most New Yorkers go years without a serious interaction with a police officer. Some do not, and the city has a body whose job is to hear what they have to say. The Civilian Complaint Review Board, known as the CCRB, is an independent agency empowered to receive, investigate, mediate, hear, make findings and recommend action on complaints against New York City police officers. This is a how-to: what the board covers, who can file, the six ways to do it and what happens next.

It is general information about a public process, not legal advice. Anyone with a legal question about a particular incident should speak to a lawyer, and anyone in immediate danger should call 911.

What the CCRB can hear

The board's mandate is stated in four categories. It takes complaints alleging:

  1. The use of excessive or unnecessary force.
  2. Abuse of authority.
  3. Discourtesy.
  4. The use of offensive language.

Those four are the agency's jurisdiction. It is not the place for a complaint about a crime, for a dispute over a parking ticket or for a general complaint about city service; those go elsewhere, and an agency page on "agency jurisdiction" on the CCRB site spells out what is in and out. If your complaint is about something an officer did, or said, in one of those four ways, the board is the place. If it is about corruption by a city employee, the Department of Investigation takes those; see Who watches city officials: DOI, COIB and the CCRB.

The board is independent of the police department. The investigative staff is, in the board's words, composed entirely of civilian employees, and conducts investigations in an impartial fashion. The board's authority comes from the City Charter, Chapter 18-A, which the agency's page links.

Who can file

The CCRB's own page is generous about who may bring a complaint:

  • Anyone who witnesses or experiences alleged police misconduct.
  • Any age. You can file a complaint regardless of your age.
  • Any language. You can file in any language; the board says its staff speak over a dozen different languages and that it also uses the city's volunteer language bank and an outside translation service.
  • From jail. You can file a complaint if you are in jail.
  • Regardless of immigration status. The board says it takes complaints regardless of a person's immigration status and never asks complainants or witnesses about their immigration status.

There is also a practical reassurance on the same page: although it helps, you do not need to know the name or badge number of the officer who is the subject of your complaint.

The six ways to file

The agency lists several routes. Use whichever is most comfortable.

Online

The board has a complaint form on its website. It is the route many people use, and it works at any hour. The agency also notes that you can tag the CCRB on Instagram or Twitter in a photo or video of the incident, using the handle @ccrb_nyc.

By phone

Call the CCRB hotline at 1-800-341-2272, Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., and you will speak directly to an investigator. After 5 p.m. and on weekends you can leave a complaint on voicemail; the board says to be sure to include contact information and that an investigator will call back promptly. Free interpretation is available.

Through 311

You can call 311 at any time of the day or night, every day. From outside New York City the number is 1-212-NEW-YORK. This is the single easiest entry point if you do not have the board's number handy. For more on how the 311 line works, see what 311 can and cannot do.

In person

The board's office is at 100 Church Street, 10th Floor, New York, NY 10007, and is open from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. No appointment is necessary to file a complaint.

At a police precinct

You can file a complaint at any police precinct, or pick up a CCRB complaint form there and mail it. The agency says the form is pre-addressed and postage-paid.

By mail

Address a written complaint to the Civilian Complaint Review Board, 100 Church St., 10th Floor, New York, NY 10007.

What to include

The board does not require a particular format, but the more specific the account, the easier the investigation. A short checklist of what is useful:

  • When and where. The date, the approximate time and the location, including the street or the subway station.
  • Who was involved. A description of the officer or officers, a name or badge number if you have it, and the names of any witnesses. The board says you do not need the name or number, but a description helps.
  • What happened, in order. Write the sequence as it unfolded, in your own words and your own language.
  • Evidence. Photos, video, messages, medical records and the names of anyone who saw the incident. The agency's mission statement says it encourages all parties involved to come forward and present evidence.
  • How to reach you. A phone number and, if you can, an email address, since an investigator will need to follow up.

What happens after you file

The board's published mission describes the shape of the process. Its investigators investigate each allegation, in the board's words, thoroughly and impartially, and make objective determinations on the merits of each case. Where the investigative findings show misconduct occurred, the board recommends disciplinary actions that are fair and appropriate. The board forwards its findings to the police commissioner.

Two other features of the process are worth knowing.

Mediation. The board has pledged to offer civilians and officers the opportunity to mediate their complaints to promote understanding between officers and the communities they serve. That is a choice for the participants, and it is an alternative to a full investigation for certain complaints.

Status. The agency has a "Complaint Status" page on its site where you can check on a complaint once it has been filed.

Beyond that, the specifics of timing, outcomes and the disciplinary steps that follow a finding are set out in the agency's own pages, the City Charter and its agreements with the police department. The board's website lists a memorandum of understanding about its Administrative Prosecution Unit and another about the police department's disciplinary matrix. Because those rules change, the board's pages are the place to read the current version.

A note on rights and expectations

The board's page includes a "Know Your Rights" section and brochures in multiple languages. It is worth reading them before an incident, not after. They explain what a person can and cannot do during an encounter. This article does not repeat them, because they are the board's to state.

It is also fair to say what the CCRB is not. It is not a court. It does not award damages. It does not replace a lawsuit, or a criminal case, or a complaint to a district attorney. A person who has been seriously hurt or who is facing charges has legal questions that the board is not set up to answer, and a lawyer or a legal-aid organization is the right place for them. The board is the civilian channel for a particular kind of complaint, and its authority is to investigate and recommend.

If you saw it but it did not happen to you

A great many complaints start with a bystander. The board says anyone who witnesses alleged misconduct can file, which includes a neighbor who watched a stop from a stoop, a passenger on a subway platform or a person who recorded video from a window. A witness has an advantage the person at the center sometimes lacks: distance. The account is a description of what was seen, and a recording, if one exists, is exactly the kind of evidence the board says it wants all parties to bring forward.

Two practical habits help. First, write down what you saw as soon as you can, while the details are fresh: the location, the time, the number of officers and what each did. Second, keep any recording in its original form and do not edit it. The board's online form, phone hotline and office all accept a witness's account in the same way as a complainant's, and the same promise about immigration status applies to witnesses as to those directly affected.

The same logic applies to a person who is afraid to file. The board's pledge is to respect the rights of the civilians and officers involved, and the pages it publishes in multiple languages are meant to lower the barrier. Whether to file is a personal decision; the point is that the channel exists, is independent and is open to everyone.

Where the CCRB sits in the city

New York has several oversight bodies, and it helps to know which does what.

  • The CCRB handles complaints about police officers' conduct in the four categories above.
  • The Department of Investigation is one of the oldest law-enforcement agencies in the country, formed in the 1870s after the Tweed scandal, and investigates any agency, officer, elected official or employee.
  • The Conflicts of Interest Board administers the city's conflicts-of-interest, annual disclosure and lobbyist gift laws.
  • The police department itself is the largest municipal force in the country, with approximately 33,000 officers and 15,000 civilian employees; see The NYPD in the subway: transit districts for how it is organized and New York City Police Department for the agency.

The agency profile for the board is at Civilian Complaint Review Board, and the comparison of the three oversight bodies is in Who watches city officials: DOI, COIB and the CCRB. The board's own website, at nyc.gov/ccrb, has the online form, the list of jurisdiction and the answers to the questions people most often ask.

The short version

Call 1-800-341-2272 on a weekday, call 311 at any hour, file online, visit 100 Church Street or write. You do not need an officer's name. You do not need to be a citizen. You can write in your own language, at any age, and from jail if need be. The board will investigate, offer mediation where it applies and forward its findings to the police commissioner. The first step is the simplest: tell them what happened.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic