Blog
Lead in NYC water: what DEP says
A question-and-answer look at what DEP says about lead: lead-free at the source, plumbing as the risk, and the free test kit.
Few civic questions get asked in more kitchens than this one: is the water from my tap safe to drink? New Yorkers are proud of their water, and with reason, but the pride comes with a footnote that the city's own water department prints in plain type. The water is one thing. The pipes it travels through in the last few feet are another. What follows is a set of questions and answers, taken from what the Department of Environmental Protection, or DEP, says about the subject on its own pages.
Where does New York's water come from?
DEP says the city's drinking water comes from protected reservoirs upstate. The same page describes the water as delivered lead-free. The system that carries it to the five boroughs is among the oldest pieces of municipal infrastructure in the country, and the story starts with a date: Croton Aqueduct water reached the city on July 4, 1842, according to DEP's history of the city's drinking water, and the aqueduct was dedicated on October 14, 1842. It was a turning point for a city that had grown past its local water. The Croton Aqueduct brings water, 1842 tells the story.
The reservoir-to-tap chain is run by DEP, the agency responsible for the city's water and sewer systems and for environmental regulation. Department of Environmental Protection is the record of the department.
If the water is lead-free, why is there a question?
Because water that leaves the reservoirs lead-free can pick something up on the way. DEP's own wording is careful: the water is delivered lead-free, and some older one-to-four-family homes may have private lead plumbing. The phrase "private plumbing" is the key. The city owns and operates the mains under the street. What happens inside a building, in its pipes, solder and fixtures, is part of the building. DEP's explanation is that water can absorb lead from solder, fixtures and pipes found in the plumbing of some buildings or homes, even though the water was lead-free on delivery.
That is a distinction between the public system and the private one, and it matters for the next question.
Which buildings are most likely to have lead plumbing?
DEP's wording points to older one-to-four-family homes, and that is the group to think about first. The reason is age: plumbing materials change over time, and a house with its original pipes and old solder is different from one that has been replumbed. DEP does not say that every old home has lead plumbing; it says that some may. The only way to know about a particular home is to test.
A note on who is affected. Census QuickFacts counts 3,334,088 households in the city, with an owner-occupied rate of 32.8 percent. That means roughly two-thirds of households rent. For a renter, the building's plumbing is the landlord's, and for the owner of a small house, the plumbing is the owner's. In both cases the question to ask is the same, and the answer comes from a test.
How do I find out whether my water has lead in it?
DEP offers a free lead test kit. The ways to request one are to call 311 or to use the form on DEP's website. A few practical points from the department's instructions:
- One kit at a time. DEP provides a single kit per household at this stage, and a landlord who wants to test several apartments submits a separate request for each one.
- What is in the kit. Bottles, instructions in several languages and a prepaid return label for the sample.
- How to take the sample. The instructions say not to use the water for six hours or more before sampling, and then to run the cold tap for a minute or two before filling the bottle. The sample comes from a kitchen or bathroom sink, with the aerator left in place.
- When you get results. DEP mails results, and the instructions say to expect them within about 30 days of the sample being tested.
That is the whole procedure, and it is free. For a household that has never tested, it is the single most useful thing the department offers. using 311 effectively explains how to place the call.
What should I do while I wait for results?
DEP's frequently asked questions on lead in household plumbing say that if you have lead plumbing you can run the tap until the water turns noticeably colder before you drink it. The idea is that water that has been sitting in the pipes picks up more than water that is flowing fresh from the main. That is the department's advice; it is not a substitute for the test.
For specific medical questions, particularly about children and pregnancy, the right source is a clinician or the city's Health Department, not a blog post. The Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, which calls itself the nation's oldest municipal public health agency, runs the city's public health programs. Department of Health and Mental Hygiene describes it, and how the public hospital system works explains how the city's public health and hospital agencies divide the work.
Does the city replace lead pipes?
DEP has programs for replacing lead service lines, and the department has made announcements about expanded replacement efforts. Because the details of eligibility and scheduling change, the department's current pages are the place to check, and 311 can direct you. The principle behind the programs is the one above: the problem is in the last stretch of pipe, so the remedy is in the last stretch of pipe.
What else is DEP doing with the water system right now?
Two items from DEP's site are relevant to ordinary customers. First, the department says it is upgrading more than 600,000 automated meter reading devices, which means the equipment that records how much water a household uses is being replaced across the city. Second, DEP says that customers who sign up for autopay and ebilling receive a $50 credit. Neither has anything to do with lead, but both are part of the department's relationship with the people who get its bills. What DEP's meter upgrade means explains the meter program.
Why the answer is not "everything is fine" or "everything is dangerous"
A fair reading of DEP's position is that two statements are true at once. The water as it leaves the city's reservoirs and distribution system is lead-free. And lead can enter water from some buildings' own plumbing. The responsible response to both is the one DEP offers: a free test, run the tap when you have lead plumbing, and replace what can be replaced.
It is easy to hear one half of the message and miss the other. A person who hears only "lead-free" may not bother to test an old house. A person who hears only "lead plumbing" may stop drinking tap water without ever finding out whether their own pipes are affected. The test resolves the uncertainty for the household that takes it.
What should a renter ask the landlord?
Because most of the city rents, the practical conversation is often with a building's owner or manager. A few questions are reasonable to put to them, in writing if you can:
- Has the building's water ever been tested for lead, and are the results available?
- Is the building a one-to-four-family house, the category DEP singles out for possible private lead plumbing?
- Has the plumbing been replaced, wholly or in part, and when?
- If the household asks for a test kit, will the landlord cooperate with the sampling?
None of these is a demand, and a landlord may not know the answers. They are a starting point, and the free kit from DEP works whether or not the landlord has tested. If a landlord wants kits for several apartments, DEP's rule that each apartment needs its own request is worth knowing, since it explains why a single request does not cover a building. For problems that go beyond the water itself, 311 is the front door, and the housing agency, HPD, handles building safety and affordability programs; How the HPD housing lottery works and the guide to Renting in New York City: rent stabilization and the Rent Guidelines Board cover the rest of the landlord-tenant landscape.
A record worth keeping
Whatever the result, keep it. A test result is a dated piece of paper, and it is the kind of thing that matters when a household moves, when a child is born, or when a building changes hands. Write down the date you took the sample, the sink you took it from and the date results arrived. If you test again after any plumbing work, the comparison is the useful part.
The larger point is the one DEP's wording makes on its own. The city's water has a good reputation, and the department backs it with a statement that the water is delivered lead-free. The same department tells you that the last few feet are the building's responsibility. A New Yorker who holds both facts at once, and takes the free test, is better informed than one who relies on either alone.
Where this fits among the city's utilities
Water is one of several services that a household sets up and pays for. The Department of Finance collects property tax and parking-ticket payments, DEP handles water and sewer bills, and Con Edison supplies electricity, gas and steam. A newcomer's checklist of utilities is in Setting up electric, gas and water service in New York City, and utility disruptions: what the city's hazard guide lists covers the other utilities' disruptions.
If you are a renter and you want to test, the sequence is simple: ask for a kit through 311, follow the sampling instructions and keep the results. If you own a small older house, the same applies. For anything about the building's plumbing itself, the person to talk to is the owner or a licensed plumber, and the Department of Buildings handles permits for plumbing work. DEP's own pages, at nyc.gov/site/dep, carry the current instructions, forms and any changes to the test-kit program.