Blog
The Time Out Market and the Empire Stores
A walk through DUMBO to the food hall in the old Empire Stores beside Brooklyn Bridge Park and Jane's Carousel, and how the warehouse was reused.
Come out of the High Street station on the A or C and the first thing you notice is not a building but a bridge. The Brooklyn Bridge goes up overhead in a long granite-and-steel arc, and then the street drops toward the water. This is DUMBO, the neighborhood whose name is shorthand for "Down Under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass," and the walk to the Empire Stores and the food hall inside them is one of the best short walks in Brooklyn. It is a story about brick, water and the habit New Yorkers have of finding new work for old buildings.
Getting to the neighborhood
DUMBO sits on the East River in Brooklyn, beside the 85-acre Brooklyn Bridge Park. It is served by several routes, and you can come in whichever way suits the day.
- Subway. York St (F), High St (A, C) and Clark St (2, 3) are the stations the MTA's neighborhood guide lists. The F at York Street drops you closest to the cobblestone streets under the bridges; High Street puts you beside the Brooklyn Bridge approach; Clark Street is a walk down Brooklyn Heights' hill.
- Ferry. NYC Ferry's East River route stops at Dumbo, which makes a boat from Manhattan the most scenic way in. Ferries: the Staten Island Ferry and NYC Ferry explains the ferry system, and NYC Ferry routes: East River, Astoria and Rockaway covers the routes.
- On foot. Walking over the Brooklyn Bridge from Manhattan, which opened on May 24, 1883, brings you down into the neighborhood. See The Brooklyn Bridge opens, 1883.
The neighborhood's ZIP code is 11201, shared with parts of Downtown Brooklyn and Brooklyn Heights, a reminder that ZIP codes and neighborhoods do not line up neatly. Myth: your ZIP code is your neighborhood explains why.
What the building is
The Empire Stores are a long waterfront building of the kind the East River's industrial edge was built from: brick, heavy, practical and made to hold goods. Warehouses like it lined the shore for as long as Brooklyn was a port, and for many decades their purpose was to move cargo from ships to the city. When that economy moved away, these buildings were left standing, with their thick walls and high ceilings and a view of Manhattan that no warehouse had been built to enjoy.
The reuse is the story. The Empire Stores became a place for food, shops and offices, and the Time Out Market, a food hall, now occupies part of the building. The neighborhood guide lists "the Time Out Market food hall in the old Empire Stores building" among the places DUMBO is known for, alongside St. Ann's Warehouse and the park. The pattern of keeping the old shell and giving it a new use is the city's version of recycling. It is also a pattern the Landmarks Preservation Commission knows well. The commission, created in 1965, protects individual landmarks and historic districts across the five boroughs. Landmarks Preservation Commission describes its work, and The Landmarks Law and the loss of Penn Station explains how the law came about after the loss of the original Pennsylvania Station.
The food hall as an idea
A food hall is a simple concept: one big room, many counters, shared tables. It descends from the covered markets of European cities and, in New York, from a long line of public markets. The city's local markets listings sort food halls alongside farmers markets, holiday markets and night markets, and the borough has plenty of each. Grand Army Plaza and its farmers market covers a farmers market, and The Queens Night Market at Flushing Meadows covers a night market.
What a food hall offers a visitor is choice without commitment. A group of people who cannot agree on dinner can each get what they want and sit together. What it offers the neighborhood is traffic: a reason to cross the bridge or take the ferry. The hall's own website lists current vendors, hours and events. Those change often enough that a blog post is the wrong place to look for them.
The waterfront outside the door
The best reason to come to the Empire Stores is not inside the building. It is the park beside it. Brooklyn Bridge Park covers 85 acres along the East River, and the neighborhood guide places the food hall beside it and Jane's Carousel. The carousel is a restored ride housed in a glass pavilion at the water's edge, with the Manhattan Bridge behind it. The skyline of Lower Manhattan sits directly across the river, and on a clear afternoon it looks like a model of itself.
If you only have an hour, here is a route that works.
- Begin at York Street or High Street. Walk toward the water on the cobblestones.
- Look up. The Manhattan Bridge's arch, framed by the street, is one of the most photographed views in the borough.
- Walk to the Empire Stores. The building runs along the waterfront, beside the park.
- Eat. The food hall is the obvious stop, though the hall's own site should be checked for what is open.
- Walk the park. Follow the paths toward the carousel and the river.
- Leave by ferry. The Dumbo landing connects to other stops on the East River route.
Brooklyn Bridge Park and the DUMBO waterfront gives a longer route through the park itself, and DUMBO has the neighborhood profile.
DUMBO's other anchors
The Empire Stores are one of several places that make the neighborhood what it is. The neighborhood guide names St. Ann's Warehouse, a performing-arts venue, and the park. All of them are within a few minutes' walk of each other, which is part of why DUMBO works as a half-day outing. If you are building an itinerary around the borough, the Brooklyn Museum, covered in The Brooklyn Museum, and the stretch of Fort Greene, in Fort Greene and Clinton Hill, are a short ride away.
For the bigger picture of waterfront reuse in Brooklyn, Sunset Park and Industry City describes another industrial waterfront that has taken on new tenants, and 44 Eagle Street and Greenpoint's rooftop farm shows a different kind of reuse in Greenpoint, where a rooftop is a farm. Taken together, they say a lot about the borough's attitude: the old stuff is not demolished first and asked questions later.
A note on crowds and timing
The neighborhood is one of the most visited in Brooklyn, which means weekend afternoons and summer evenings are busy. If you want the cobblestones and the view with some space around you, go on a weekday morning. If you want the full energy of the place, go on a warm Saturday. The weather matters here more than in most places, because so much of the pleasure is outdoors. How hot is a New York July? and New York's climate, month by month can help you choose a month. In the cold months, the food hall is a good place to warm up before you walk the waterfront.
Why the walk is worth it
DUMBO is a neighborhood that shows the city doing something it is good at: taking a place built for one purpose, giving it a second, and keeping what was best about the first. The Empire Stores were built to hold goods, and they now hold dinner. The street under the bridge was a working street, and now it is a place to walk. The carousel and the park, built on land that was once piers, give the neighborhood a front yard. None of it is complicated. All of it is worth an afternoon.
Take the F or the ferry, start at the water, and leave yourself time to walk back across the Brooklyn Bridge as the day winds down, when the lights come on over the East River.
Questions people ask before they go
Is it a place for a quick bite or a long meal? Both. A food hall suits either, because you can order one thing and leave or build a meal across several counters. The hall's own site lists the vendors and hours, and they change.
Is it good in bad weather? It is one of the better indoor choices in the neighborhood. The waterfront park is the main draw, so a rainy day trims the outdoor half of the trip, but the building gives you somewhere to wait out a shower. a rainy day in the museums has other wet-weather ideas.
Can I get there without climbing stairs and hills? The streets of DUMBO run down toward the water, so the walk from the subway to the park is downhill and the walk back is up. Allow for that if anyone in your group tires easily.
What else is nearby? Brooklyn Heights is a short walk from the Clark Street station on the 2 and 3, and the brownstone blocks there are among the most admired in the borough. Downtown Brooklyn is just inland. And the Brooklyn Bridge itself is a destination, with a pedestrian path that rewards a slow walk in either direction.
The Empire Stores and the idea of adaptive reuse
Architects and planners have a term for what happened at the Empire Stores: adaptive reuse. It means keeping a building and changing its job. The argument for it is practical and a little sentimental. A solid old shell is cheaper to keep than to replace, and it carries a sense of place that a new building has to earn. New York is full of examples, from converted loft buildings in SoHo to former factories in Williamsburg and Long Island City. williamsburg: from factories to music halls and Long Island City's waterfront and MoMA PS1 tell two of those stories.
The counterargument is that reuse can price out the people and businesses that used the buildings before. That tension runs through every waterfront neighborhood in the city, and it is a fair question to ask on any walk like this one: who is the building for now, and who was it for before? The best answer a visitor can give is to look closely, learn the history, and spend money in a way that supports the neighborhood's long-term life. DUMBO has a lot of history under its paving stones. It is worth reading the plaques.