Blog

Tottenville and the end of the Staten Island Railway

A ride to the south shore terminus of the Staten Island Railway, past Richmond Valley and Arthur Kill, and what waits at the end of the line, ZIP 10307.

Most subway lines in New York end in a neighborhood with a name everyone knows: Coney Island, Flushing, Pelham Bay Park. The Staten Island Railway ends in a place where, if you say the name to a New Yorker who lives north of the Narrows, you will often get a blank look. The place is Tottenville, and it is the end of the line in the plainest sense. Past it there is the Arthur Kill, a narrow tidal strait, and across the strait there is New Jersey. Tottenville is the southern tip of the city and, as locals will tell you, of the whole state of New York.

Riding to it is one of the better cheap trips in the region, because the ride runs the length of an island most visitors never see.

Starting at St. George

The ride starts where the free Staten Island Ferry lands. At the St. George terminal, ferry passengers walk off the boats and onto the Staten Island Railway platforms under the same roof, a short walk from the gates. The railway is operated by the MTA, which runs the city's subways and buses and the region's commuter railroads. It is the only rail line on the island.

The story of the terminal is told in St. George and the ferry terminal, and the ride's general character in The Staten Island Railway from St. George to Tottenville. This piece is about the other end, the stretch of the line below the island's middle, and what a traveler finds when the train runs out of track.

A ride from St. George to Tottenville takes the better part of an hour, a time that depends on the day and the schedule, and the MTA posts the timetable on its site. The train is a modern subway-style car, and the line runs on the surface and on embankments rather than underground. The windows look out on back yards, wooded patches, ballfields and, in places, glimpses of water. The landscape is suburban in a way that surprises people who think of the whole city as a canyon of towers.

The last stops

The stations near the southern end include Arthur Kill, Richmond Valley and Tottenville, in that order, with Tottenville the last. The names say where you are. Arthur Kill is named for the strait that separates Staten Island from New Jersey; kill is an old Dutch word for creek or channel, a relic of the language of the colony that once owned the harbor, and it survives in the names of waterways across the region. Richmond Valley takes its name from the county, since Staten Island is Richmond County. And Tottenville is named for a family that settled the area.

By the time the train reaches these stops, the density has dropped considerably. The stations are quiet, with small parking areas and short platforms, serving residential streets. The Tottenville station is a modest terminus, not a grand one, and it is a good bet that you will step off the train and find that you are one of only a few people in sight.

The ZIP code for Tottenville is 10307. That is the number on the mail, and it is also the way many New Yorkers place the neighborhood on a mental map, the same way they might speak of "10036" for Times Square. Remember that the city's planners treat neighborhood names as informal, and a ZIP is not a neighborhood. But 10307 is where the mail for the southern tip goes.

What the south shore looks like

Staten Island's south shore faces Raritan Bay, the large body of water that separates the island from the New Jersey shore near Perth Amboy. The shoreline here is lower, sandier and more open than the harbor edge on the North Shore, and the character of the places along it is different too: smaller houses, older frame buildings, and a more small-town feel than anywhere else in the five boroughs.

Tottenville has a long maritime history. It was once an oystering and shipbuilding town, a place whose economy depended on the water. The oyster beds are long gone, the victims of pollution and development, but the town's orientation to the water has not gone away. The streets run down toward the shore, and the older houses sit on small lots near the beach.

At the southern tip, near the end of the island, there is a historic site tied to the Revolution. On September 11, 1776, a few weeks after the Battle of Long Island, representatives of the Continental Congress met British Admiral Lord Howe at a stone house on this point to talk about ending the war. Benjamin Franklin, John Adams and Edward Rutledge were the American delegates. The talks failed, and the war went on for seven more years. The house still stands as a museum, and the surrounding land is a park. The wider context, the Battle of Long Island, the occupation and the city's war, is in New York in the Revolution, 1765 to 1783, and the battle in The Battle of Brooklyn, August 1776.

How the railway fits the island

The line is the island's backbone. It runs down the eastern side, parallel to the shore, from the ferry terminal at the north to the Arthur Kill at the south, and most of the island's densest neighborhoods sit within a short walk of a station. It is also what ties the island's north and south together: without it, a trip from Tottenville to the ferry would be a long drive or a series of bus transfers.

The railway has a long history that predates the city's consolidation, and, like many suburban lines, it was originally built and run by a private company. The MTA took over its operation in the 1970s. Since then it has been part of the same organization that runs the subways, though it is physically separate from them and the ferry is the link.

Fares on the line are set by the MTA, and the details of how they apply at the stations along the way are on its fare pages. The base subway and bus fare as of 2026 is $3, with tap-and-ride through a contactless card, a phone or an OMNY card. The weekly cap of $35 applies to subway and local bus rides, and a rider who takes the railway as part of a trip should check the MTA's site for the current terms on that line.

The island's other connections

The other way in or out of Tottenville is by road. The Outerbridge Crossing, a bridge over the Arthur Kill, lies close to the southern end of the island and connects it to New Jersey. It is a vehicle bridge and has no pedestrian role, but its presence tells you that the area faces New Jersey as much as it faces the rest of the city. Many residents of the south shore have family, work or shopping that cross the Arthur Kill, and the region's geography does not respect the line on the map that makes one side a New York borough and the other a New Jersey county. A related piece on that region is New Jersey across the Hudson.

The Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge, at the north end, is the main road link to Brooklyn; it opened on November 21, 1964, and its lower level opened on June 28, 1969. The story of that bridge is in The Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge opens in 1964. The two bridges, the Verrazzano and the Outerbridge, are the main car routes, and the railway and the ferry are the principal public-transit routes.

A day trip, step by step

Here is how to make the trip a pleasant half day, without a car.

  1. Take the ferry to St. George. The ferry is free and runs 24 hours a day, every day. From Lower Manhattan, ride the R or W to Whitehall St and walk to the terminal.
  2. Board the railway. The trains leave from the platforms inside the terminal. Check the MTA's schedule to see how often they run at the time you go.
  3. Ride to Tottenville. Sit on the water side if there is a choice. The ride is the main event.
  4. Walk the south shore. Head toward the water on foot, look at the Arthur Kill and the New Jersey shore, and find the park near the southern tip.
  5. Come back the same way. Train to St. George, and ferry to Manhattan, preferably at sunset.

The total cost depends on what the MTA charges for the railway portion that day. The boat is free.

Why go

Some trips are about the destination, and some are about what you learn on the way. A ride to Tottenville is the second kind. It shows you how big the five boroughs are, and how different from one another. It shows the city's edge, where houses give way to marsh and water. And it reminds you that the harbor is the city's real center, with the boroughs arranged around it like the parts of a wheel.

For the larger picture, a guide to what the borough offers in a day is in A day on Staten Island. And if you want the island's green side, the Greenbelt is covered in The Staten Island Greenbelt. But there is something to be said for simply going to the end of the line, getting off the train, and seeing what is there.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic