Blog
What congestion pricing costs a commuter
A labeled hypothetical driver, the $9 peak E-ZPass toll charged once a day, the tunnel crossing credit, and the 2028 and 2031 steps to $12 and $15.
Argue about congestion pricing at any length and the conversation drifts, within a minute, from principle to arithmetic. Nobody at the bar is debating the theory of road pricing. They want to know what it costs the guy who drives in from Queens, and what it costs him next year, and whether the credit at the tunnel is real. This is the arithmetic, done once, with the assumptions labeled so that you can swap in your own.
The program is the Central Business District Tolling Program, which began on January 5, 2025, and it charges vehicles that enter Manhattan streets south of and including 60th Street. The MTA, through its Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority, runs the tolls. The rules and rates below are the schedule as published by the MTA, and the figures are the ones in force as of 2026.
The rules in brief
- The zone. All Manhattan streets south of and including 60th Street. The FDR Drive, the West Side Highway (Route 9A) and the connections from the Hugh L. Carey Tunnel to West Street are excluded, which means a driver who stays on those roads is not charged for them.
- The peak toll for passenger cars with E-ZPass. $9.00 in the peak period, which runs 5 a.m. to 9 p.m. on weekdays and 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. on weekends. This is Phase 1, covering 2025 through 2027.
- The overnight rate. $2.25 for passenger cars, outside the peak period, according to the MTA's published rates.
- Once a day. A passenger vehicle that enters more than once between midnight and 11:59 p.m. is charged the toll in effect at its first entry. It is a daily charge, not a charge per crossing.
- Crossing credits. Drivers who enter through the Lincoln, Holland, Queens-Midtown or Hugh L. Carey tunnels can receive a credit of up to $3 for a passenger vehicle, during peak hours and with E-ZPass.
- Future rates. The schedule rises to $12.00 in 2028-2030 and to $15.00 from 2031.
- Without an E-ZPass account. Tolls by Mail rates run higher, by up to 50 percent according to the MTA.
For the legal and political background, and for whether the program's status has changed since this was written, the MTA's page on the Congestion Relief Zone is the authority; it says the MTA continues to collect tolls while the program's legal status is contested in court. Congestion pricing: the toll below 60th Street is the how-to, and The Congestion Relief Zone: boundary and exclusions covers the map.
A hypothetical driver
Say a commuter, a made-up one, drives from Queens to a job in Midtown five days a week, using the Queens-Midtown Tunnel and an E-ZPass account. The plate matches the account. The commuter works about 250 days a year. Arithmetic follows, with each assumption on the table.
The daily charge, no credit. The peak toll is $9.00. The commuter pays it once per day, no matter how many times the car enters the zone that day.
The daily charge, with the crossing credit. The Queens-Midtown Tunnel is one of the four tunnels that offer the credit, up to $3 for a passenger vehicle at peak with E-ZPass. If the full $3 applies, the net toll is $9.00 minus $3.00, or $6.00.
The annual figure.
| Case | Daily | Per year (250 days) |
|---|---|---|
| Peak toll, no credit | $9.00 | $2,250 |
| Peak toll, with full $3 credit | $6.00 | $1,500 |
The credit, in other words, is worth about $750 a year to this commuter ($3 times 250 days), a third of the gross toll. The credit is a tunnel-crossing credit, so the driver who enters over a bridge does not get it, and the commuter who takes the Queens-Midtown Tunnel off-peak gets none, since the credit applies at peak with E-ZPass.
What this leaves out. Gas, parking, tunnel and bridge tolls on the way, insurance and wear on the car are all separate from the congestion toll. The hypothetical covers only the congestion charge itself, and so it understates the true cost of the drive.
The step-ups
The $9.00 toll is the Phase 1 rate. The schedule says $12.00 for 2028 through 2030 and $15.00 from 2031. Apply the same 250-day year, with no credit, to see the progression:
| Years | Peak toll | Per year (250 days) |
|---|---|---|
| 2025-2027 | $9.00 | $2,250 |
| 2028-2030 | $12.00 | $3,000 |
| 2031 onward | $15.00 | $3,750 |
The step from $9 to $12 is a 33 percent increase (3 divided by 9 is 0.333), and the step from $12 to $15 is 25 percent (3 divided by 12 is 0.25). Over the whole period, the toll rises 67 percent, from $9 to $15 (6 divided by 9 is 0.667). The crossing credit's amount in the later phases is set by the MTA's schedule, so the table shows the gross toll only. A driver who plans a multi-year commute should look at the schedule at mta.info before assuming the credit stays the same.
The overnight driver
At the other end of the day the numbers look very different. The overnight rate for a passenger car is $2.25. A driver who enters the zone outside the peak period pays that instead of $9.00, and receives no crossing credit, since credits are not offered overnight. For someone whose job or errands run late, the schedule can make a real difference: 250 overnight entries come to $562.50 a year, against $2,250 at the peak rate.
That arithmetic is not a recommendation. It is the shape of the pricing: the toll is highest when the streets are most crowded, which is the point of the program.
The alternative, in fares
A driver weighing the toll will inevitably weigh the alternative, and the alternative is the subway or the commuter rail. A subway round trip costs $6 as of 2026, at $3 a ride. Ten rides a week, one round trip each working day, cost $30, which is under the $35 weekly cap, and over 50 weeks that comes to $1,500. A commuter who rides the subway to the same job pays, in fares, about what the driver in the example pays in net tolls after the full crossing credit. The driver also pays for the car, the gas and the parking.
The comparison is rough. The commuter who drives from a part of Queens with no good subway line has a real constraint that no table captures, and the average commute in the city is 40.3 minutes according to Census QuickFacts, long enough that convenience matters. The point of the comparison is only that the toll, set against the fare, is not an abstraction. the weekly fare cap math covers the fare side in detail, and Tap and ride: how OMNY works explains how the tap system works.
Taxis, for-hire vehicles and trucks
Taxis and for-hire vehicles are charged a surcharge per trip into the zone, and the MTA's taxi and FHV page lists the amounts. The surcharge is set separately from the passenger-car toll, and the MTA's page is the place to read the current amounts. The Taxi and Limousine Commission, created in 1971, licenses medallion cabs and for-hire vehicles, with over 200,000 licensees and about 1,000,000 trips a day, and taxis and for-hire cars: who regulates them explains how the two systems are regulated.
Where the money goes
The program began on January 5, 2025, the first of its kind in the nation, and the MTA's own materials describe it as a program meant to deliver cleaner air and less congestion. Where the money goes is a question for the MTA's budget documents, and the arguments for and against the program, which have been intense, are best read from the agencies' own pages and the public record. The MetroCard's retirement and the 2026 fares covers the fare changes that took effect the following year, and Metropolitan Transportation Authority is the record of the agency.
Questions drivers ask
Does the toll apply every day? The peak period covers 5 a.m. to 9 p.m. on weekdays and 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. on weekends, so a Saturday trip at 10 a.m. is charged at the peak rate in the schedule above, and a trip at 10 p.m. falls in the overnight period.
What if I enter twice? The once-a-day rule means the first entry sets the toll for the whole day, from midnight to 11:59 p.m. A driver who goes in for a morning meeting and returns for an evening event pays one toll, not two.
What if I stay on the FDR Drive or the West Side Highway? Those roads, along with the connections from the Hugh L. Carey Tunnel to West Street, are excluded from the zone, so a trip that stays on them is not charged. A driver who leaves them for a street south of 60th Street has entered the zone.
Does a bigger vehicle pay more? The MTA publishes separate rates for motorcycles, trucks and buses, and its schedule lists them by vehicle class. The figures above are for passenger cars only.
How to work out your own number
A short checklist for anyone doing the sum:
- Count the days you actually drive into the zone, not the days you work.
- Decide your crossing. If you enter by the Lincoln, Holland, Queens-Midtown or Hugh L. Carey tunnel at peak with E-ZPass, you may qualify for the credit.
- Remember it is once a day. A second entry the same day does not add a second toll.
- Check the plate on your E-ZPass account, since a mismatch sends you to Tolls by Mail rates.
- Plan for the step-ups, $12.00 in 2028 and $15.00 in 2031.
- Check the MTA's page for any change in the program's status or rates.
The MTA's schedule is at mta.info/agency/bridges-and-tunnels/congestion-relief-zone, and it is the document to trust over any summary, including this one.