Blog
When New York freezes: the coldest months
Central Park normals for December through March, with January's 27.9 and February's 29.5 average lows, and how those match the city's 29.8 inches of snow.
New York winters have a reputation that is half right. The city is cold, but not Minneapolis cold; it is snowy, but not Buffalo snowy; it is gray, damp and windy in a way that makes a 35-degree day feel colder than the thermometer says. The reputation is better tested against numbers, and the numbers exist. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration publishes climate normals for the Central Park weather station, averaged over the thirty years from 1991 to 2020, and they tell the story of the cold season plainly.
This is an explainer built on those normals, with the arithmetic shown. All figures are NOAA NCEI 1991-2020 normals for Central Park, in degrees Fahrenheit and inches.
The four coldest months
Winter in the normals runs from December through March. Here is the record for those four months.
| Month | Normal high | Normal low | Precipitation | Snowfall |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| December | 44.3 | 33.8 | 4.38 | 4.9 |
| January | 39.5 | 27.9 | 3.64 | 8.8 |
| February | 42.2 | 29.5 | 3.19 | 10.1 |
| March | 49.9 | 35.8 | 4.29 | 5.0 |
Two things stand out immediately. The coldest month by temperature is January, with a normal low of 27.9 and a high of 39.5. And the snowiest month is not January but February, with 10.1 inches against January's 8.8. The reason is the interplay of cold and moisture: February is a little warmer than January but arrives with the storms that come up the coast in late winter, and a bit of warmth is not a problem if the storm is wet and the temperature at the surface is near freezing.
The freezing line
Water freezes at 32 degrees, and the normals show which months cross it.
- January: the normal low is 27.9, which is 4.1 degrees below freezing. The normal high of 39.5 is 7.5 degrees above. On a typical January day the temperature rises above freezing in the afternoon and falls below it at night.
- February: the normal low is 29.5, 2.5 degrees below freezing, and the high is 42.2.
- December: the normal low is 33.8, 1.8 degrees above freezing; the normal high is 44.3.
- March: the normal low is 35.8, 3.8 degrees above freezing; the high is 49.9.
So only January and February have normal lows below freezing. December and March straddle the line: their typical nights sit just above it, which is why they are the months when the same storm can bring rain to one part of the city and snow to another, and why the weather forecasters' language about a "rain-snow line" is a December and March conversation as much as a January one.
This is also why the freeze-thaw cycle defines the New York winter. In January, a typical day runs from the high 20s to the high 30s, so water in cracks freezes and melts again, and the streets pay for it. The potholes that the city's 311 line receives complaints about each spring are a product of that cycle.
The daily average
The normals give highs and lows, and the average of the two gives a rough sense of the day's temperature.
- January: (39.5 + 27.9) / 2 = 33.7
- February: (42.2 + 29.5) / 2 = 35.85, about 35.9
- December: (44.3 + 33.8) / 2 = 39.05, about 39.1
- March: (49.9 + 35.8) / 2 = 42.85, about 42.9
Notice that the coldest average is January's 33.7, still above 32. The city's winter, in the middle of the coldest month, averages slightly warmer than freezing. That is the key to its character: it is a winter of near-freezing days, not deep freezes, and the snow that falls often melts or turns to slush within days.
For comparison, the annual mean temperature is 55.8 degrees, and July's normal high is 84.9 with a low of 70.1. The gap between January's normal low and July's normal low is 42.2 degrees: 70.1 minus 27.9.
Snow: where the 29.8 inches comes from
The annual snowfall normal for Central Park is 29.8 inches. Where does it fall? The monthly normals answer.
| Month | Snowfall | Share of the annual total |
|---|---|---|
| October | 0.1 | under 1% |
| November | 0.5 | about 2% |
| December | 4.9 | about 16% |
| January | 8.8 | about 30% |
| February | 10.1 | about 34% |
| March | 5.0 | about 17% |
| April | 0.4 | about 1% |
The months add up: 0.1 plus 0.5 plus 4.9 plus 8.8 plus 10.1 plus 5.0 plus 0.4 is 29.8 inches. January and February together supply 18.9 inches, or about 63 percent of the year's snow. Add December and March and the four months supply 28.8 inches, nearly 97 percent. From May through September, the normal snowfall is zero.
What this means in practice is that the city's snow season is short and concentrated. A New Yorker who has lived through a few winters will have seen one or two real storms and a lot of flurries. Normals are averages, and individual winters swing widely; a winter can come in far below or above the normal. But as a planning baseline, the table is accurate.
Precipitation: the other half
Snow is only part of winter's precipitation. December's normal precipitation is 4.38 inches, January's 3.64, February's 3.19 and March's 4.29. Add them up and the four winter months bring 15.5 inches of the year's 49.52 inches. Notice that February, the snowiest month, is the driest in total precipitation of the four. That is because a given amount of liquid water falls as many inches of snow: snow takes up more space than rain, so a month can produce more snow in inches while delivering less total water.
December and March are the wetter months of the winter set, and with temperatures just above freezing, much of their precipitation falls as rain. That is why a winter day in New York can mean a cold rain rather than snow, and why a wet, raw day in March can feel worse than a dry one in January.
The edges of the season
The cold months do not start and stop on a switch. The shoulder months on either side show how the season ramps up and winds down.
| Month | Normal high | Normal low | Precipitation | Snowfall |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| October | 64.5 | 51.4 | 4.38 | 0.1 |
| November | 54.0 | 42.0 | 3.58 | 0.5 |
| April | 61.8 | 45.5 | 4.09 | 0.4 |
| May | 71.4 | 55.0 | 3.96 | 0 |
From October to November the normal high falls 10.5 degrees, from 64.5 to 54.0, and from November to December it falls another 9.7, to 44.3. That is the steepest descent of the year, and it explains why the first truly cold week always feels sudden. The same pattern runs in reverse in spring: from March's 49.9 to April's 61.8 is a rise of 11.9 degrees, and April to May adds another 9.6.
Snow can fall in both shoulder months, but the amounts are tiny: half an inch in November and four-tenths of an inch in April. A snowy April day is a surprise, which is why it makes the news, and it is also why gardeners and farmers at the city's markets treat the last frost as a date to watch, not a date to assume. The frost line, for planning purposes, is a matter of lows: April's normal low of 45.5 is comfortably above freezing, but a single cold night can still dip below it.
A heating-season example
The normals also help explain a household's winter. Take a hypothetical apartment dweller who thinks about the cold season in degrees below a comfortable indoor temperature. Say the target is 68 degrees. January's normal daily average of 33.7 sits 34.3 degrees below that target, February's 35.9 sits 32.1 below, December's 39.1 sits 28.9 below and March's 42.9 sits 25.1 below. The deficit is largest in January and shrinks by about a quarter by March. This is an illustration of the arithmetic, not a forecast of anyone's bill, but it shows why the middle of winter is when heat problems become emergencies, and why complaints about missing heat concentrate in the deepest part of the season. The city's housing agencies take those complaints through 311.
How the city handles it
The numbers drive the city's winter operations. The Department of Sanitation clears snow from about 19,000 lane-miles of street, and it has 705 salt spreaders among its 2,000-plus collection trucks and 450 mechanical brooms; How the Sanitation Department fights snow describes the work. The Department of Transportation suspends alternate side parking for snow and emergencies, as snow and the alternate side rules explains. And NYC Emergency Management lists winter weather among the hazards residents should prepare for, along with the extreme cold that can accompany it; a winter weather checklist is the practical guide.
The National Weather Service office for New York, known by the identifier OKX, issues the forecasts and warnings; The National Weather Service office for New York explains how that office and the city's alert system, Notify NYC, work together.
What to wear
Planning around the normals is straightforward. In January and February, with highs around 40 and lows around 28 to 30, layers matter: a warm coat, a hat, gloves and shoes that can handle slush. December and March call for a coat but fewer layers. The wind, which is a feature of the city's open avenues and waterfront, makes everything feel colder, so a scarf is not a luxury. What to pack for New York's seasons has the full seasonal picture.
The seasonal arc
Winter is one part of an annual cycle that the normals describe month by month. New York's climate, month by month and How much it snows in Central Park cover the rest of the year, and July versus January in Central Park sets the two extremes side by side. The big picture: the city's coldest month averages a little above freezing, its snow comes in a four-month window and its coldest nights fall in January and February. Those facts, small as they seem, shape the habits of everyone who lives here, from the way people dress to the way the city allocates its crews.
A final observation about averages: they describe the middle, not the edges. Any particular winter can hold a week of severe cold or a spell of spring-like weather in February. The normals are a baseline for expectation, and the forecast, the alert and the 311 line are for the days when the baseline fails.