Blog

The Brooklyn Brewery and Williamsburg beer

Williamsburg brewed lager, lost it, and got it back: German brewhouses and refineries gave way to the L train, music halls and the Brooklyn Brewery.

Step off the L at Bedford Avenue on a Saturday afternoon and count the buildings doing a job they were not built for. The brick warehouse is a music venue. The old factory floor is a market. Down the block, a long industrial shed houses the Brooklyn Brewery, which the MTA's own neighborhood guide to Williamsburg lists alongside Artists & Fleas, the Music Hall of Williamsburg, the thrift shops and the City Reliquary museum as the things the area is known for.

Nobody planned that mix, and nobody drew it up at City Hall. It is what's left when a working waterfront loses its work and the buildings stay put. And beer is the oldest thread in it, because Williamsburg was brewing lager long before anyone called the place a lifestyle.

The lager blocks

The story starts with who got off the boat. Through the middle of the nineteenth century, German-speaking immigrants settled in big numbers across the East River from Manhattan, in Williamsburg and in the part of Brooklyn that became Bushwick. They arrived thirsty for lager, the cold-fermented style then pushing older ales out of American taverns, and they knew how to make it. A brewery needs water, grain, ice or cellars, and a way to move heavy barrels. The East River supplied the last of those, and rail lines and horse-drawn wagons covered the rest.

By the century's end the stretch of north Brooklyn running from Williamsburg into Bushwick was thick with breweries. Some were big operations with tall brick brewhouses, bottling halls and stables for the delivery horses. Others were small neighborhood outfits tied to a saloon. The owners also built the German social clubs, singing societies and beer gardens that gave the neighborhood its Saturday nights. Walk Bushwick's avenues today and the brewery buildings still standing are the record of those years.

Then came the squeeze. Consolidation thinned the field, and Prohibition, in force from 1920 until 1933, shut breweries outright or pushed them into making other products. The plants that reopened after repeal faced national brands that could ship by rail to every state. One by one the neighborhood breweries closed over the following decades. The last of the big Brooklyn plants went dark in the 1970s, and for a stretch the city, with all its taverns, brewed almost no beer of its own.

After the factories

The rest of Williamsburg's industry followed the brewers out. The waterfront had held sugar refining, metalworking and warehouses, and those jobs had employed much of the neighborhood. As manufacturing left the city, plants closed or sat half empty. Landlords with huge, cheap, unheated floors found tenants who could use them: artists first, wanting space and light, then musicians, wanting space and no neighbors.

The MTA's guide calls the result a former industrial area that became an artist haven in the 1990s and 2000s. The L carried them in. Bedford Avenue, the first Brooklyn stop past the East River tunnel, became the front door. From there the walk toward the water crosses blocks where old brewery and factory buildings were handed over to galleries, studios, venues, bars and shops.

Williamsburg never turned into a single thing. The southern blocks hold a long-established Hasidic community with its own shops and institutions. The northern blocks, toward Greenpoint, have another character again. The Williamsburg Bridge, which opened in 1903, helped set the mix early, since it let crowded Lower East Side tenement families cross the river to new housing. Its Brooklyn end is still the neighborhood's southern landmark.

Where the Brooklyn Brewery came in

The Brooklyn Brewery is a child of that era. It began in the late 1980s as a bet that New Yorkers would drink beer brewed in New York, and by the 1990s it had settled into a former industrial building in Williamsburg, where it still operates. The name now does a good deal of the borough's marketing. The tasting room is open to the public on a schedule the brewery publishes on its own website, so check those posted hours before you go rather than trusting anyone's memory of them.

The beer matters less than what the brewery stands for here. In a neighborhood whose nineteenth-century identity was brewing, a modern brewery in a repurposed factory is continuity, not novelty. It put beer back on blocks that had lost it, and the taprooms, bars and restaurants nearby grew up around that return. Planners have a phrase for this, adaptive reuse, and it means the new use moves into the old shell.

Reading the neighborhood from the L

You can read all of this from the sidewalk if you know where to look, and it costs one swipe of a MetroCard-era habit: get off the train and walk slowly.

  1. Start at Bedford Avenue (L). The station opens onto the shopping and nightlife strip. The blocks around it are mostly low and brick, laid out in the age of horse and wagon.
  2. Head north-west toward the waterfront. The industrial buildings get bigger. Look up at the rooflines and over at the loading doors; many of these were warehouses, and some of the doors are original.
  3. Hunt for brewery details. A brick brewhouse gives itself away by its height, its arched windows and its chimney stacks, and some still carry faded painted signs. They are easier to spot on the Bushwick side, along the avenues running away from the river.
  4. Finish at the water. The East River shore looks nothing like it did a century ago. The former sugar refinery site, which closed in 2004, is now parkland. The NYC Ferry's East River route stops at North Williamsburg, a quick way back to Manhattan or on to Dumbo.

The subway map fills in the rest. Williamsburg is served by the L at Bedford Avenue and Lorimer Street, the G at Metropolitan Avenue, and the J and M at Lorimer Street and Hewes Street. Each line brings you in from a different side, and each stop shows a different slice of the neighborhood's past. For fares and how to ride, see Riding the subway and buses: fares, OMNY and the weekly cap.

Music halls, markets and a very small museum

If the brewery is the oldest thread, the venues are the newest. The Music Hall of Williamsburg is the kind of mid-size room that survives only where plenty of people like going out to hear music. Artists & Fleas, a market for makers and vintage sellers, works out of space that once served industry. The City Reliquary, a small museum of New York objects and ephemera, shows what a neighborhood museum looks like when it is run on a modest scale. Put together, they are the shape Williamsburg's cultural economy took once the factories went quiet.

There is more on each in The Music Hall of Williamsburg and Brooklyn's live music, Artists & Fleas and Williamsburg's markets and The City Reliquary and Williamsburg's small museums. For the longer arc from factory district to arts district, see williamsburg: from factories to music halls, and for the train that made it possible, The L train through Williamsburg and Bushwick.

The bill, and who paid it

None of this came free, and any longtime renter on Bedford or Metropolitan will tell you so before you ask. When a district's industrial buildings become places for people with money to spend, rents on the apartments around them climb, and longtime residents and small manufacturers feel it first. Williamsburg's artists, who showed up when the place was cheap, were among the first priced out by what followed them. The pull between a neighborhood that made things and a neighborhood that sells you an evening is part of the story. It lands on the desks of the Landmarks Preservation Commission and the Department of City Planning whenever they decide which buildings to protect and what the zoning allows. The Commission is the largest municipal preservation agency in the country, and its work shapes which old brewery and factory buildings are kept as they are.

The zoning moved too. Large waterfront tracts once zoned for manufacturing were rezoned for housing and mixed uses, which opened the shoreline to residential towers and parks. Whether that was a gain depends on who you ask. Supporters point to the new parks and the added housing; critics point to displacement and lost industrial jobs. How the city's zoning rules work in general, and how a rezoning gets decided, is laid out in Planning, zoning and permits.

An afternoon, then

Give it an afternoon. Take the L, look at the buildings between Bedford Avenue and the river, and see what the neighborhood has made of them. If you want to go inside the brewery, check its posted visiting hours first. If you would rather have a different kind of afternoon, walk west to the waterfront and catch the ferry. If the beer history is the draw, ride on into Bushwick, where the larger brewery buildings stand along the avenues, and read the neighborhood from there. Williamsburg and Bushwick have the transit and ZIP code basics, and DUMBO covers the next stop along the waterfront.

Mind the irony while you're at it, because it is the whole story in one block. German brewers built the place to feed a crowded city's thirst, the end of manufacturing emptied it, artists who needed cheap space moved in, and now the brewers and the drinkers are back on the same blocks. It isn't the same neighborhood, and it isn't the same beer. But big brick buildings and people gathering around them is an old arrangement, and the L still runs straight through it.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic