Blog

The City Reliquary and Williamsburg's small museums

A storefront museum of New York odds and ends, and the artist-built Williamsburg of thrift shops, flea markets and music halls around it.

A reliquary is a box for relics. Medieval churches kept bone fragments in them; the City Reliquary keeps the other kind of relic, the sort a city sheds without noticing: bottle caps, souvenir spoons, subway tokens, pieces of buildings that came down. It sits in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, and the MTA's own visitor guide to the neighborhood names it as one of the places that tell you what the area has been. That is a notable thing for a transit agency to say about a museum small enough that you could cross its floor in a dozen steps.

The idea is older than any one storefront. New York has always had two museum cultures. One lives on Fifth Avenue, in marble, with a membership office and a coat check; the Met's own story is a long argument for that kind of institution. The other lives on a ground floor between a laundromat and a bar, run by people who collect because they cannot help it, and it asks you for a few dollars or nothing. Williamsburg is where the second kind took root in recent decades, and it is worth understanding why.

An industrial waterfront that artists inherited

Williamsburg faces Manhattan across the East River, south of Greenpoint and north of Bedford-Stuyvesant. For much of the twentieth century it was a working district of factories, warehouses and tenement-lined streets, joined to the Lower East Side by the Williamsburg Bridge, which opened in 1903 and sent a generation of Lower East Side families across the river looking for more room. Heavy industry thinned out in the decades after the Second World War, and the buildings it left behind were big, cheap and empty.

That is the recipe for an artist haven, and the MTA's guide says exactly that: a former industrial area that became an artist haven in the 1990s and 2000s. Painters and musicians took lofts in old factories. Bands rehearsed in buildings no one else wanted. The first restaurants and bars opened to feed them. The neighborhood a visitor sees today, with its restaurants, its brewery and its music hall, is the second and third wave of that process, and the long-running small institutions are what remains of the first.

The transit is part of the story. The L train, which runs under 14th Street and surfaces into Brooklyn, stops at Bedford Avenue and at Lorimer Street. Those two stops turned a trip that once meant a long walk or a bus into a short ride from Union Square. The J and M lines stop at Lorimer Street and Hewes Street, and the G stops at Metropolitan Avenue. NYC Ferry's East River route calls at North Williamsburg. A newcomer arriving by any of those gets the same first impression: a neighborhood that is dense, flat and walkable, with a commercial street that starts at the Bedford Avenue station and keeps going.

The Reliquary and what a small museum is for

A museum this small has to justify itself differently from a big one. It cannot offer a survey of everything; it offers a point of view. The City Reliquary's point of view is that the history of New York is also the history of its leftovers, and that the left-behind object (a ticket stub, a piece of a demolished facade, a souvenir sold at a world's fair) can tell a visitor something a wall label in a grand gallery will not.

Consider what such a collection can show. The city has held two world's fairs at Flushing Meadows, and a souvenir from one is a small, concrete thing you can hold up against the story told in The 1939 and 1964 World's Fairs compared. The subway opened on October 27, 1904 with a five-cent fare; a token from the long era of tokens is a way of feeling how the fare moved from that nickel to the $3 base fare of 2026. The same logic works for buildings that disappeared. The Landmarks Preservation Commission was created in 1965 after the loss of the original Pennsylvania Station, and the story of The Landmarks Law and the loss of Penn Station is usually told in big gestures; a salvaged fragment tells it in a small one.

The point is not that any particular object is rare. It is that a neighborhood museum lets a visitor see the city as a collector sees it, one specimen at a time, and leave looking at the sidewalk differently.

Walking the neighborhood around it

The easiest way to use a small museum is as the first stop on a walk, because it takes twenty minutes, not a day. Williamsburg rewards that treatment. From the Bedford Avenue L station the main commercial strip runs north, and the MTA's guide lists what the walk offers: restaurants, the Brooklyn Brewery, Artists & Fleas, the Music Hall of Williamsburg, thrift shops, and the City Reliquary.

Each of those is a different kind of small institution:

  • The thrift shops. The district has long been a place to buy and sell used clothes, and the habit fits the neighborhood's pattern of reuse: old buildings turned into studios, old goods turned into new outfits. They are the commercial cousins of the Reliquary, since both depend on the idea that a discarded thing still has a story. The shops change; the habit does not.
  • Artists & Fleas. The MTA names this market as one of the neighborhood's landmarks. It gathers independent makers and vintage sellers under one roof, which makes it the easiest way to see how a district of artists became a district with a retail identity. The story of Artists & Fleas and Williamsburg's markets belongs beside this one.
  • The Music Hall of Williamsburg. A rock venue rather than a museum, but it keeps a different sort of archive in its calendar. The Music Hall of Williamsburg and Brooklyn's live music takes up that thread.
  • Brooklyn Brewery. A large presence for a place that began as a neighborhood bet; the full account is in The Brooklyn Brewery and Williamsburg beer.

Taken together, these form a sort of distributed museum. No one planned it that way. It exists because a neighborhood with cheap space and a lot of people who make things ends up with many small places that show what they make, and visitors treat the whole strip as a gallery.

How a changing neighborhood keeps its own history

Every district that changes fast faces the same problem: the people who made it interesting are often the first to be priced out, and the record of what they did goes with them. Williamsburg is a textbook case. Between the artists' arrival in the 1990s and the restaurants, hotels and towers that followed, the neighborhood changed its character more than once, and the small museum became one of the few places where an earlier version of it was still on display.

A visitor should not expect the Reliquary or any similar place to be a neutral summary of that change. A collector's museum is selective by nature, built from donations, finds and enthusiasms. That selectivity is its charm. What it gives you is texture: the particular objects that made it into one person's or one community's version of New York.

Two things make it worth the visit even for a New Yorker who thinks they know the city. First, it works at a human scale; there is no audio tour, and the people at the desk are usually the people who care most. Second, it ties a hyper-local view to the city as a whole. A reliquary's contents can come from all five boroughs, so a trip to Williamsburg also becomes a trip to Coney Island, to the old Penn Station, to a Bronx stadium. Yankee Stadium: two ballparks compared and The Brooklyn Cyclones at Coney Island are two of the stories such a collection might touch.

What to look for, in order

A small museum is easy to rush and easy to waste. A few habits help.

  1. Start with the case nearest the door. Small collections usually put what the keepers think best explains the place up front. Read that label first and you will know the museum's argument.
  2. Look for the local object. Anything connected to a particular block, bridge, factory or ballpark is worth more of your time than a generic souvenir. The specific is what a small museum does better than a large one.
  3. Ask a question. The staff at a place like this are often volunteers or the collectors themselves. The answer to "where did this come from?" is frequently the best exhibit in the room.
  4. Leave something behind, if the shop asks for it. A donation box or a small purchase is how places like this stay open.

None of these takes more than a few minutes, which is the whole appeal. You can fit a museum into a lunch break, and a city that offers that is a city worth living in.

Getting there and making a morning of it

Plan on the L. From Manhattan, take it to Bedford Avenue and walk. From Bushwick, the L's stops at Jefferson Street and DeKalb Avenue connect the two neighborhoods; the trip is a useful reminder that the artist migration did not stop at Williamsburg but kept moving east and south, a story told in Bushwick. From the north, Greenpoint is a short walk or a G train away. If you arrive by ferry, North Williamsburg is the East River route's stop.

A reasonable half-day looks like this: arrive mid-morning, spend a short time in the museum, walk the strip, stop at the market if it is open, and eat somewhere along the way. Check the museum's current hours and admission before you go; small institutions keep their own schedules, and they change. The MTA fare for the ride is $3 as of 2026, and the system's tap-and-ride payment, with its seven-day cap, is explained in Riding the subway and buses: fares, OMNY and the weekly cap.

What you carry away from a place like this is a habit of attention. The Met will teach you about art. The Reliquary teaches you that the city itself is a collection, assembled by accident, and that the person next to you at the bus stop may be holding a piece of it. Williamsburg has the practical details of the area, and the walk from the station to the water is shorter than most people expect.

Why the small ones matter

Big museums are institutions. Small ones are acts of will. Each exists because somebody decided it should, and kept it open past the point where common sense said to stop. New York has hundreds of them, from a single-room gallery to a house museum, and they pay for themselves in ways a ledger does not capture: they give a block a reason to exist for visitors, they hold the things larger museums have no room for, and they make the argument, over and over, that a city's history is not the property of its big buildings.

Williamsburg did not invent that argument. It simply gave it a good address, a train line and an audience that arrived looking for something not yet polished. The City Reliquary is one of the places where that search ends, in a room full of small proofs that New York happened to people, one object at a time.

Related neighborhoods

Related guides

Latest on this topic