Blog

How Central Park was made, 1853 to 1858

From the 1853 land purchase between 59th and 106th Streets to the 1858 Greensward Plan and the Lake that opened first, how a swampy rock became 840 acres.

In the early 1850s the land that Central Park occupies was not a place anyone would have called picturesque. It was rock outcrops and swamp, scattered shanties, pig farms and a few streets' worth of settlement, well north of the built-up city, which ended somewhere around 42nd Street. The great park that New Yorkers now take for granted was in 1853 a proposal to buy several hundred acres of unpromising ground, and a good deal of that ground was occupied.

How it went from a purchase to a masterpiece in five years is one of the great stories of American civic building, and it has the usual ingredients: a booming city, a campaign by writers and merchants, a design competition, a pair of designers who disagreed with their bosses, and a good many people who were pushed out along the way.

The case for a park

New York in the 1840s and 1850s was growing at an astonishing rate. Immigration was heavy, the population was climbing, and the built-up part of Manhattan was marching north, block by block, along the grid that the commissioners had laid out in 1811. The plan for that grid, which covered the island north of 14th Street up to 155th Street, famously left little room for open space. The story is in The 1811 Commissioners' Plan and the grid. The city had a few small squares and a growing sense that something was missing.

The people who made the case for a large park argued from several angles. Newspaper editors and poets pointed to the parks of London and Paris and asked why America's biggest city had nothing comparable. Wealthy New Yorkers wanted a place to take a carriage ride. Public-health reformers wanted somewhere for crowded workers to breathe. And real-estate interests, not to put too fine a point on it, expected that a park would raise the value of the land around it. Each of these motives helped, and none of them alone would have been enough.

The 1853 purchase

In 1853 the state approved the funds to buy land for a park, from 59th to 106th Streets, between Fifth and Eighth Avenues, according to the Central Park Conservancy's history. The city acquired it through eminent domain, which meant buying out or evicting everyone who lived on it. That is the dark side of the story, and it should not be left out. The land held several communities. One was Seneca Village, a settlement in the area of the West 80s that was home to a mix of residents, many of them Black New Yorkers who owned their land, as well as Irish and German immigrants. Other residents lived in squatter settlements and small farms. All were removed to make room for the park.

The cost of the land was considerable. The park's total price, including the land and the construction, was $14 million, according to the Conservancy. That was an enormous figure in the 1850s, and the park was criticized as an extravagance by some who thought the money would be better spent elsewhere. The argument over park spending has been a feature of city politics ever since.

The land ran from 59th Street to 106th Street at first. A few years later the northern boundary was pushed up to 110th Street, and that is why the park today runs from 59th to 110th Street. The park today covers 840.01 acres in NYC Parks' record, while other sources, among them the National Park Service and the Conservancy, give 843 acres, a small difference that comes down to how it is measured.

The competition and the Greensward Plan

The city was not sure what to do with the land once it had it. A commission was set up, and in 1857 it held a design competition. Thirty-three entries came in. The winner, chosen on April 28, 1858, was a plan titled "Greensward," submitted by Frederick Law Olmsted and Calvert Vaux.

Olmsted was a writer, a farmer and a journalist who had been working as the park's superintendent, and Vaux was an English-born architect. Their plan was the product of an unusual partnership, one man with a gift for landscape and a broad social vision, the other a trained architect with a flair for structures. They proposed a park that looked natural but was in fact entirely designed: hills and meadows, a lake, woods, rock outcrops, winding paths, and a series of formal elements, such as the Mall and the terrace by the Lake, set among the informal landscape.

The plan had several clever features. The most important was that the cross-town traffic that the city needed was carried by four sunken roads, the transverse roads, which cut across the park below the level of the landscape. That meant that carriages and, later, cars could cross without disturbing the park's calm. The paths were separated by type, so that pedestrians, riders and carriages did not collide. The plan used the land's existing features, the rock outcrops and the low ground, and drained and reshaped the rest.

1858: construction begins, and the Lake opens first

Construction began in 1858, immediately after the competition, and went on for about fifteen years. It was a huge undertaking. Thousands of workers, many of them recent immigrants, spent years moving earth, blasting rock, building walls and bridges, planting trees and laying drainage. Gunpowder was used in great quantities to clear the rock, and the amount of earth moved was staggering. The park was not a patch of nature left alone but a landscape created by labor.

The first part to open to the public was the Lake. In the winter of 1858, according to the Conservancy, it was open for skating, and crowds turned out for it. The detail is telling: a park that was still a construction site was already being used. People came to skate on the first sheet of ice before most of the rest of it had been built, a sign of how hungry the city was for open space.

Over the next several years, other parts of the park opened in stages. The Mall, the long, formal promenade lined with elms, was among the early works, and the Bethesda Terrace, with its fountain and its ornate stonework, was built later in the 1860s. The park was essentially complete, in its major features, by the early 1870s. The 15 years of construction that the Conservancy cites run from the beginning of work in 1858 to the early 1870s.

What the designers meant it to be

Olmsted and Vaux believed in the park as a democratic space. Their idea was that a large, beautiful, free public park would be good for the whole city: rich and poor, native and immigrant. It was supposed to offer a respite from the grid and the noise, and it was supposed to bring people of different classes into the same space. That ideal was only partly achieved, and the park's early years were shaped by rules that restricted certain activities, but the vision of a park for everyone shaped how the place was used over time.

It was also, quite consciously, a work of art. Olmsted and Vaux wanted visitors to feel as if they were walking through countryside, with views that changed as they moved. The sight lines, the placement of trees and the shapes of the paths were carefully composed. Many visitors take the park for nature, and the compliment is, in a sense, what the designers were after. Almost nothing in it is natural, and almost everything in it was planned.

Using the park today

Central Park is by far the most famous park in New York and one of the most visited places in the country. It is open to anyone, free of charge. A visitor can walk or ride a bicycle through it, row a boat on the Lake, ice skate in winter, picnic on the Great Lawn, visit the zoo, or simply sit on a bench. The park's own site and NYC Parks list the current hours and the programs. Information about the park's wide range of visitor offerings is in Free things to do in New York City.

The subway stations on the park's edges make access easy. On the west side, the B and C trains run under Central Park West, with stops at 81st Street-Museum of Natural History and others. On the east side, the 6 stops at 68th, 77th and 86th Streets, and the Second Avenue Q stops farther east. At the northern end, the 2 and 3 stop at 116th Street in Harlem. The park's numbers are in Central Park by the numbers, and its seasons in A year of seasons in Central Park's normals. Its extent, along the whole of the park's length, is taken up in Central Park from 59th Street to 110th.

A short timeline

  • 1853: the state approves funds to buy land from 59th to 106th Streets between Fifth and Eighth Avenues.
  • 1857: a design competition is held.
  • April 28, 1858: the Greensward Plan by Olmsted and Vaux is chosen.
  • 1858: construction begins, and the Lake is the first section open to the public.
  • Early 1870s: the park is substantially complete, after about 15 years and a cost of $14 million.
  • Today: 840.01 acres in NYC Parks' record.

Why it still matters

The Central Park story is also a story about what a city can decide to do. The people who pushed for the park in 1853 were asking the city to spend a great deal of money on something it did not yet need, on land it did not yet use, for people who were not yet there. They were right. The park is now surrounded by some of the most valuable land in the world, and no one seriously wants to give it up. The conservation of the park since then, through periods of neglect and restoration, is a longer story, but the founding decision was the crucial one.

And it left a legacy beyond the park itself. Olmsted and Vaux went on to design Prospect Park in Brooklyn, which is 526.25 acres and is the subject of Prospect Park and Grand Army Plaza, along with many others across the country. The idea that a great city should have large, well-designed parks as a matter of course, not as a luxury, comes in large part from what they did in Manhattan in the 1850s.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic