Blog
The 1811 Commissioners' Plan and the grid
The 1811 plan that laid a rectangular grid over Manhattan from 14th to 155th Street, John Randel Jr.'s survey and why the avenues and streets look as they do.
Most cities grew by accident, adding streets as houses went up and paths turned into roads. Manhattan north of 14th Street did the opposite. In 1811, before there was much there to speak of, a state commission drew a rectangular grid across the island, and the city has been filling it in ever since. A walker who knows the rule can find any address in minutes: streets run east and west, numbered from south to north, and avenues run north and south, numbered from east to west. It is the simplest street plan of any big American city, and it was a deliberate decision.
The plan is called the Commissioners' Plan of 1811. It covered Manhattan from 14th Street to 155th Street, and it was surveyed by John Randel Jr. Its effects are everywhere in the city: in the shape of the blocks, in the way people give directions and in the character of the avenues. The Museum of the City of New York, which mounted an exhibition on its history, calls it "the greatest grid," and the name suits it.
Why a grid
By the early nineteenth century, New York was growing fast. The population was moving north from the old settlement at the southern tip, and landowners were laying out streets in whatever direction suited them. The result was a patchwork of local grids that did not match, and a city government worried about the confusion. The state legislature appointed a commission in 1807 to plan the island's future streets, and the commissioners reported in 1811.
Their reasoning was practical. A rectangular plan was easy to survey, easy to sell and easy to build on. Lots would be regular, and so would the blocks. A speculator could buy a plot knowing exactly what shape it would be. Straight streets were simple to lay down, and rectangular houses fit on rectangular lots. The commissioners were less interested in beauty than in what would make real estate marketable, and that decision shaped the city's land economy for generations.
What the plan laid out
The Commissioners' Plan covered the island north of 14th Street, up to 155th Street. Within that area it set out the following.
- Streets. The plan set 155 numbered cross streets, running east to west, across the width of the island.
- Avenues. It laid out twelve numbered avenues running north to south, beginning with First Avenue on the East River side and running to Twelfth Avenue on the Hudson side. Several of the avenues' names and extra avenues were added later: Lexington, Madison and Park fill the space between Third and Fifth, and Avenues A through D appear along the East River where the island is wide enough.
- Blocks. Blocks were narrow in the north-south direction and long in the east-west direction. The commonly cited figure is about 200 feet from street to street, with avenue blocks several hundred feet long. Between Third and Sixth Avenues, in the middle of the island, the blocks were laid out at a longer length than elsewhere.
- Lots. The standard lot was a narrow rectangle, 25 feet wide, which is why the city's rowhouses and tenements are so often narrow and deep.
The old street pattern below 14th Street was left as it was. That is why the Village, the Financial District and the Lower East Side do not fit the grid: they were already built up and had their own streets. See Washington Square and the Villages for a walk where the old and new patterns collide.
The exceptions
Broadway is the great exception. It was an existing road, an old route running diagonally the length of the island, and the plan could not erase it. It cuts across the grid on a long angle, and the places where it crosses avenues, such as Herald Square, Times Square, Columbus Circle and Union Square, became open spaces with a distinct character. The plan also did not include Central Park. The park was authorized in 1853 and construction began in 1858, which is why the grid is interrupted between 59th and 110th Streets; see How Central Park was made, 1853 to 1858.
John Randel Jr. and the survey
The surveyor of the plan was John Randel Jr., who began the work as a young man. It was his job to measure the island, mark the lines of the future streets and prepare the maps. He spent years walking the ground, setting markers at the intersections, and the work took him across hills, swamps and farms, including some where owners objected to strangers with surveying instruments.
Scholars have debated how much of the plan's design belongs to Randel and how much to the three commissioners who signed it. Accounts differ: some credit Randel with the design as the commission's secretary, surveyor and chief engineer; others point out that the plan was the commissioners' and Randel carried it out. The safe statement is that the commissioners approved the plan and Randel surveyed and mapped it. He continued to survey the island for several years after 1811 and set marble monuments at intersections to mark the lines, a record of a city that did not yet exist.
What the grid did to the land
The commissioners made a choice that angered some people and shaped the city. They laid the grid over the island without regard to its natural features. Hills were to be leveled and valleys filled. Streams were to be buried. The rocky ridges of Manhattan, which the Lenape had called a hilly island, were treated as obstacles; see Before 1609: the Lenape and Lenapehoking for what was there before. Over the nineteenth century, the city graded, blasted and filled to bring the ground in line with the plan.
A few survivors remain: the high ground in Upper Manhattan, which the grid could not entirely flatten, the rock outcrops in Central Park, left because the park's designers kept them. But the effect on most of the island was to turn a varied landscape into a flat, orderly field for building.
What the grid does to a walker
The grid has practical rules that make Manhattan easy to navigate.
- Numbers go up as you go north. Street numbers rise from south to north, and avenue numbers rise from east to west.
- Twenty blocks make a mile. A standard rule of thumb is that twenty north-south blocks equal about a mile. Say you are walking from 14th Street to 59th Street: that is 45 blocks, or about two and a quarter miles. The arithmetic is approximate, but it is dependable.
- Crosstown blocks are longer. East-west blocks, between avenues, are much longer than north-south ones, which is why walking across town takes more time than walking up it.
- Addresses encode a location. On an avenue, the building number tells you which cross street you are near, and a short formula can turn it into a street. The details vary by avenue.
The numbered streets also determine the layout of street signs and parking rules; see How alternate side parking and street cleaning rules work in New York for how those work. The grid's regularity makes it easy to understand, but it also makes Manhattan feel uniform to people used to winding streets.
The grid and the sun
The grid is not oriented to the compass. Its streets run at an angle to true east and west, tilted about 29 degrees from the lines of latitude, because the plan followed the island's axis. The tilt has a visible result twice a year, in late May and mid-July, when the setting sun lines up with the cross streets and floods them with light. The phenomenon is popularly called Manhattanhenge, and on those evenings crowds gather on east-west streets such as 14th, 23rd, 34th and 42nd to watch.
Critics and defenders
The plan has had critics since it was drawn. They argued that its uniform blocks produced monotony, that it ignored the land and that its narrow lots led to crowded tenements. A grid with only 200-foot blocks and 25-foot lots, in a city with a growing, poor immigrant population, produced dense housing with little light. The 1916 zoning rules, discussed in the 1916 zoning resolution, were an attempt to manage some of the consequences, by controlling building height and bulk.
Defenders say the plan did exactly what it was meant to do. It made land easy to buy and sell, it made construction predictable, and it made the city easy to navigate. It also left room for the avenues to carry traffic and, later, for subway lines to run beneath them in straight lines. The grid made the subway cheaper to build than a tangle of streets would have, and it made the long, straight avenues that define Manhattan's look.
Seeing the plan today
You can see the commissioners' work by walking.
- Stand at the foot of the grid. At 14th Street, the Village's tangle meets the grid; walk north across 14th Street and the streets straighten.
- Walk a long avenue. Fifth Avenue or Sixth Avenue gives a straight line of sight for dozens of blocks.
- Find the exceptions. Broadway's diagonal and the open spaces at its crossings are the most obvious.
- Look at Midtown. The dense blocks between 34th and 59th Streets, covered in Midtown from 34th Street to 59th, are the grid at its most built up. The same plan covers the Upper West Side; see Upper West Side.
The plan's lines are the city's, and the original surveyed monuments are mostly gone. But the rectangular blocks and numbered streets they marked still organize the daily life of a city of 8.5 million people. For the larger picture of the boroughs, see the five boroughs and their counties.