Blog
How FOIL works for city records
How to file a FOIL request with New York City agencies: the OpenRecords portal, records access officers, what to ask for, and the 25-cent copy fee.
City government produces paper and data on an enormous scale: inspection reports, budget documents, contracts, meeting minutes, emails, permits. Most of it belongs, in principle, to the public, and New York's Freedom of Information Law, known as FOIL, is the tool for getting it. The process is more ordinary than people expect. You write down what you want, send it to the right place and wait. This piece walks through the steps, in order, for city agencies.
It is general information and not legal advice. The city's own pages, linked below, have the current instructions.
Step 1: check whether it is already posted
The first rule of FOIL is that you may not need it. Agencies post a great deal on their own websites. The Office of Management and Budget publishes the city's budget documents, the Council posts legislation and hearing schedules, and the Comptroller posts audits and reports. The Department of Buildings and other agencies publish data through the city's open data efforts. A search of the agency's site, and of the city's data portal, can turn up what you want in minutes, without a request and without a wait.
Before you file, look. If the record is online, download it. If it is not, you have confirmed that a request is the next step, and your search will help you describe what you want.
For budget material in particular, The FY2027 city budget in plain numbers and From February to June: how the budget is adopted explain where the documents live.
Step 2: find the right agency
FOIL requests are made to the agency that holds the record. In a government as large as New York City's, that choice matters. A record about a building permit sits with the Department of Buildings. A record about a street repair is with the Department of Transportation. A police record is with the NYPD. A record about a school belongs to the education department.
If you do not know which agency, 311 can help point you to the right one, and the city's agency list in what 311 can and cannot do shows who handles what. If your request goes to the wrong agency, the usual result is a redirect, not a rejection, but you will lose time.
Step 3: use the OpenRecords portal
The city's Citywide OpenRecords portal is the main route. It is an online system where a requester can submit a FOIL request to an agency, track its progress and receive documents. The city's Department of Citywide Administrative Services names the portal in its own instructions for FOIL requests.
The alternative is a request on paper or by email directly to the agency's Records Access Officer. Every agency has one, and the agency's website names the person or office and the address. For DCAS itself, the Records Access Officer is at 1 Centre Street, 19th Floor North.
The portal is easier for most people. It keeps your request in one place, sends notices when something changes. A mailed request works, but it is slower and harder to track.
Step 4: write the request
A good request is specific enough that an agency employee can find the record. A few principles:
- Describe the record, not the question. FOIL gives access to records that exist. It is not a way to ask an agency to answer questions or create new documents. "All inspection reports for 123 Example Street between January 2024 and December 2025" is a request. "Why was the building not inspected?" is a question, and the agency is not required to answer it under FOIL.
- Be specific about dates, places and subjects. A narrow request is easier to fulfill and is less likely to be delayed or denied as too broad.
- Name the record type. Reports, contracts, emails, memos, data files, meeting minutes: say what form you want.
- Give your contact details. The agency has to reach you. An email address is usually enough.
- State the format you prefer. Electronic copies by email or portal are the norm.
The hypothetical example above is invented to show the form. Replace the address and dates with your own.
Step 5: understand what happens next
When an agency receives a request, it is required by state law to respond within set deadlines. The first response is typically an acknowledgment that tells you the request was received, and it may give an estimated date by which the agency expects to answer. The deadlines and the exact rules are set by state law and the agency's own procedures, and the city's pages and the portal show the dates for your request.
Possible outcomes include:
- Granted. The agency sends you the records.
- Granted in part. Some records come with redactions. The law allows agencies to withhold certain categories of information, such as material that would invade personal privacy or interfere with an investigation.
- Denied. The agency says why and tells you how to appeal.
- More time needed. For large requests the agency may give a later date.
If you disagree with a denial, FOIL provides for an appeal to the agency. The denial letter explains where and how. Keep your reference number and any correspondence.
Step 6: costs
Inspecting records is generally free. Copies carry a fee. DCAS charges $0.25 per page for paper copies, which is the figure the department gives in its instructions. Fees for other agencies may be listed in their own FOIL pages, and the Records Access Officer can tell you.
A practical consequence: if you only want to read a record, you can ask to inspect it. If you want copies, a narrow request keeps the cost down.
Common mistakes
A few errors account for most failed requests.
- Asking too broadly. "All emails about the budget" can mean millions of messages. A request that names a sender, a subject and a date range is far more likely to be fulfilled quickly.
- Sending it to the wrong agency. If the record is held by another department, the request is redirected, which costs weeks.
- Skipping the portal's notices. The agency's acknowledgment, any request for clarification and any extension notice arrive through the portal or by email. A missed message can stall a request.
- Ignoring the appeal window. If a request is denied, the letter explains how to appeal and by when. Read it the day it arrives.
- Expecting an explanation. The agency provides records; it does not have to interpret them. If the documents are technical, a second step, such as a call to the agency's public information office, may help.
Records requests are also a place where plain courtesy pays off. The staff who process them are public employees working through a queue, and a request that is easy to understand is easy to fill.
Records the public already sees
It is worth noticing how much of the city's record is routinely public without any request. Council legislation and hearing schedules are posted, and the Council's calendar is online. The budget cycle, from the Preliminary Budget in February to the Executive Budget in May and the adopted budget at the end of June, produces a stream of published documents. The Independent Budget Office issues its own analyses. The Comptroller publishes reports on the city's finances, such as its comments on the fiscal year 2027 adopted budget, and the Department of Finance publishes property tax rates, which for tax year 2026 are 19.843 percent for Class 1, 12.439 percent for Class 2, 11.108 percent for Class 3 and 10.848 percent for Class 4. how property tax classes work explains those. The Department of Records and Information Services keeps the Municipal Archives, whose collection guides cover historical records; The blackout of July 1977 is one story that draws on them.
Why it matters
FOIL is one of the oldest tools of civic oversight. Journalists use it to investigate. Residents use it to check on the building next door. Researchers use it to analyze trends. The law is part of a larger framework of open government that includes public hearings, public meetings and the posting of data. The City Council's meetings and hearings are open to the public; Stated Meetings are held twice a month, at the Council Chambers in City Hall, and committee hearings are mostly at City Hall or 250 Broadway. Inside a Stated Meeting at City Hall describes one, and How a bill becomes a local law in New York City explains how legislation moves.
Together, public meetings, posted data and FOIL give residents three ways in. A meeting shows you the decision as it is made. A posted dataset shows you the result. A FOIL request gets you the documents behind both.
What FOIL does not do
A few limits are worth knowing.
- It does not create records. An agency is not required to compile a new report.
- It does not guarantee every record. Some records are exempt from disclosure under the law.
- It does not answer questions. It provides documents.
- It does not replace a complaint. If you are reporting a problem, 311 or a regulator is the route. If you are looking into wrongdoing, the Department of Investigation is the place; see Who watches city officials: DOI, COIB and the CCRB.
- It does not make a record instantly available. Allow time, and be patient with large or complex requests.
A worked example
Say a resident wants to know what the city spent on a street project near her home, an invented case for illustration. She starts by searching the Department of Transportation's website and the city's budget documents, and finds a capital budget line but not the contract. She decides to file a FOIL request through the OpenRecords portal to the agency. She writes: "A copy of the contract and any amendments for the reconstruction of the named street between two named cross streets, awarded between 2023 and 2025, including the amount paid to date." She gives her email address and prefers electronic copies.
The portal assigns a reference number and sends an acknowledgment. Some weeks later, the agency sends the contract and a payment summary, with one page redacted. The resident reads it, finds what she needs and keeps her correspondence. Had the agency denied the request, she would have used the appeal instructions in the letter.
Notice what she did: checked first, picked the right agency, wrote a narrow request, kept records. Those four habits solve most FOIL problems.
Getting help
The city's pages on FOIL requests list the agency Records Access Officers and the portal. Requesting public records with FOIL is a companion how-to, and Public records and open meetings describes the agencies and rules involved. For help finding which agency holds a record, 311 can point the way. The FOIL page at the Department of Citywide Administrative Services is the place to begin.