Blog
IDNYC and Paid Sick Leave: two Council laws
The municipal photo ID and paid sick time at firms with five or more employees: two Council laws, and how the Council passes laws like them.
When the City Council wants to show what a local legislature can actually do, it tends to reach for two examples. One fits in a wallet. The other turns up on a pay stub. IDNYC is a photo identification card for New Yorkers who can prove they live in the city, and Paid Sick Leave is a rule that lets part-time workers at companies with five or more employees take paid time off when they are ill. The Council's own legislation page cites both, and between them they show how a city, with no army and no state treasury, can change ordinary life for a very large number of people.
Neither is a grand constitutional matter. Both are the kind of law that municipal governments are built to write: a card issued by a city office, and a requirement placed on employers who do business inside city limits. Looking at them side by side is a good way to see how Council legislation works, what the city can and cannot do on its own, and where the questions of power between the Council, the mayor and Albany come up.
IDNYC: a card for residents
IDNYC is a municipal photo identification program. The Council's description is short: it is for New Yorkers who prove residence, and it gives them access to city services and benefits. Notice what that sentence leaves out. It does not say citizens. It does not say adults only, or people with a driver's license, or people with a passport. The test is residence in the city, and the card is built around that.
That design choice is the whole point. A great many New Yorkers have no driver's license, because they do not drive, and no passport, because they have never left the country or have not needed one. People who are older, younger, newly arrived or experiencing homelessness often have no photo identification at all, and the difficulty compounds: it is hard to get one document without another. A city ID that rests on proof of residence gives such residents a way in. The Council describes the card as a key to city services and benefits, and the city's own information pages list the places that accept it.
The thing to understand about a municipal ID is its limit. A city can decide what its own agencies will accept. It can encourage private businesses, museums, banks and libraries to honor the card. What it cannot do is make the card valid for things that belong to the state or federal governments. A New York City card is not a driver's license, not a passport and not a federal identification for flying. Questions about which documents are required for which purposes are answered by the agencies in charge of each. For the city's own services, using 311 effectively is the quickest way to find the right office, and 311 and city services covers the service line itself.
Paid Sick Leave: a rule for employers
The second law is a labor standard. As the Council's page describes it, part-time workers at companies with five or more employees can take paid time off when ill. Two details in that sentence carry most of the weight.
Part-time workers. Labor rules often cover full-time staff first. Sick leave that explicitly reaches part-time workers matters in a city where a lot of work is part-time: retail, restaurants, home care, delivery, security, child care. A worker with a 25-hour schedule is not an exception; in many industries they are the norm.
Five or more employees. The size threshold is a compromise. A law that bound every business, including a one-person shop, would be a heavy load on the smallest employers. A law with a threshold of five reaches the bulk of the city's workplaces while leaving the smallest outside its scope. Where the line sits is a policy choice, and this particular line has been the subject of debate as the law has been amended.
The history behind the rule is a real piece of New York political drama. The Council first passed an earned sick time bill in 2013 by a wide margin, and the mayor of that time vetoed it. The Council then overrode the veto, which takes a two-thirds vote, and the bill became law. After a new mayor took office in 2014, the Council passed amendments that expanded the original law, and the amended version took effect on April 1, 2014 for employers with five or more employees. Smaller employers in the five-to-nineteen range had a grace period before penalties applied.
That history is a practical lesson in how the Charter's checks work. The legislative branch passed a law. The executive vetoed it. The Council had the votes to override. All of this followed the steps laid out in How a bill becomes a local law in New York City: introduction, committee hearing, committee vote, full Council vote, the mayor's thirty days, and the two-thirds override.
What the city enforces and who to ask
The agency that enforces workplace rules like these is the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, which also licenses more than 45,000 businesses in over 45 industries, according to its own page. A worker with a question about paid sick time can start with the department's site, or call 311, and a business owner who wants to know how the rule applies to a workplace can do the same. The specifics, the number of hours that must be provided, the rate at which time accrues, the documentation an employer may ask for, are set out in the law and in the department's rules and guidance, which change from time to time. The department's own page is the place to read the current terms. This is general information, not legal advice, and a worker in a particular dispute should look to the department or a legal-aid office.
How the Council writes laws like these
The Council is the city's legislature: the public advocate and fifty-one members elected from districts. Under the Charter it legislates, negotiates the budget with the mayor, monitors agencies and decides land use. A bill like IDNYC or sick leave moves through the same stages as any other.
- Introduction. At a Stated Meeting, held twice a month in the Council Chambers at City Hall, a member introduces the bill, and it is referred to a committee.
- Committee hearing. The committee holds a public hearing. Advocates, agencies and the public testify. Affected employers, in the case of a labor bill, speak in opposition or ask for amendments, and the agency that would run the program describes what it would cost and how it would work.
- Committee vote, then the full Council. If the committee approves, the full Council votes at a Stated Meeting.
- The mayor. The mayor has thirty days to sign or veto. If the mayor does nothing, the bill becomes law after thirty days.
- Override. A veto can be overridden by a two-thirds vote of the Council.
The Stated Meeting is a subject in itself, covered in Inside a Stated Meeting at City Hall. The relationships between the branches, and the power of the mayor under the Charter, are in The strong-mayor charter in plain English.
Home rule and its limits
One more concept explains why some ideas become local laws and others become requests to Albany. The Council can also pass what are called "home rule" requests, asking the State Legislature to pass special laws for the city. The reason for the process is that a city's power comes from the state. Where the state has given the city the authority to act, the Council can legislate directly, as it does on municipal ID cards and workplace standards inside the city. Where the subject belongs to the state, the Council can pass a resolution and ask.
That is the limit on both laws. A city can issue its own card and define what its own agencies accept. It can set a floor for paid sick time for employers within its borders. It cannot rewrite the state's driver's license rules, and it cannot change federal law about identity or employment. Which tools the city has, and where it must go to Albany, is a recurring theme in the city's politics, whether the subject is rent, taxes, schools or elections.
Why two ordinary laws matter
It is easy to dismiss a card and a leave policy as small. They are the opposite. They reach very large numbers of people in their daily lives and they touch the ordinary parts of being a New Yorker: whether you can enter a building, whether you can stay home when you are sick without losing a day's pay. A legislature that takes up such matters is operating at street level.
They also reflect a particular view of what a city government is for. In the case of IDNYC, the city treats residence, not citizenship or documents, as the basis for access to local services, a choice that is closely connected to the city's immigrant communities, whose scale is described in Foreign-born New Yorkers by the numbers and in languages at home and in city alerts. In the case of paid sick leave, the city treats a worker's health as a public matter, not a private privilege that depends on one's employer.
Either view can be debated, and both have been. Business groups have argued over the costs of labor mandates, and supporters have argued over how far such laws should reach. The record of how the Council voted, who testified and what the agencies said is public. The official page for the Council's laws, at council.nyc.gov, is the place to start reading it.