Blog
The Great Fire of 1835
On December 16 and 17, 1835 a fire destroyed the Merchants' Exchange and about 13 acres of lower Manhattan. What burned, why, and what the area is now.
It was bitterly cold, which is the first fact every account of the Great Fire leaves you with. On the night of December 16, 1835, a fire broke out in a warehouse in the heart of the merchants' district, below Wall Street, and the city could not put it out. The water in the pipes and the cisterns froze. The East River was ice. The wind blew hard, and the buildings, packed tight and stuffed with dry goods, burned the way a pile of kindling does. By the time the fire ran out of things to burn, on December 17, it had destroyed the Merchants' Exchange and about 13 acres of lower Manhattan, according to the National Park Service's landmark documentation and the Museum of the City of New York's records.
It was the worst fire in the city's history up to that time, and it came at the moment when New York had just become the country's leading commercial center. The district that burned was the working heart of that commerce: the counting houses, the warehouses and the exchange itself. To understand why it mattered, and what it changed, you have to start with what stood there.
The city on the eve of the fire
New York in 1835 was a boom town in a hurry. The Erie Canal, which opened in 1825, had given the harbor a continental hinterland, and the decade that followed was one of enormous growth. The Erie Canal and the Wedding of the Waters tells how that connection was made. The wharves along the East River were stacked with goods, and the streets behind them were lined with brick and stone buildings used for storage and trade. The Merchants' Exchange, on Wall Street, was the grandest of them, a building where brokers and merchants met to do business, and it was where much of the city's commerce, insurance and shipping news came together.
Lower Manhattan was dense. Buildings stood shoulder to shoulder, many of them with wooden interiors, wooden roofs and wooden shutters. A fire that took hold in one of them could pass to the next in minutes. The firefighting force was a volunteer system: companies of men who pulled engines by hand to the scene, and who, for all their courage and the pride they took in the work, were hampered by the same limit that the whole city faced, which was water. In a city of a few hundred thousand people, with no municipal water system worth the name, firefighters depended on cisterns, wells and the rivers.
The night of December 16
The fire began on the evening of December 16 in a warehouse near the foot of Wall Street. The cold had already created a crisis. The temperatures were far below freezing, the hydrants and cisterns froze solid, and the water that the volunteer companies hoped to pump could not be had. Firemen reached for the river, but the East River was clogged with ice, and the crews had to chop holes through it to reach water, only for the hoses to freeze again.
Wind drove the flames toward the Merchants' Exchange and the surrounding blocks. The firefighters' main tactic became not putting the fire out but stopping it from spreading, and the usual way to do that in those days was to blow up or pull down the buildings in the fire's path, creating a gap with nothing left to burn. Gunpowder was brought in for the purpose. Marines from the Brooklyn Navy Yard are reported among those who helped bring the powder across. The blasts brought down the buildings and, by the next day, the flames were running out of fuel.
By December 17, the fire was under control. The damage was staggering. About 13 acres lay in ruins, the Exchange among them. The number of buildings destroyed is commonly given as close to 700, a figure repeated in the historical literature, though accounts vary and the exact count is not something to lean on. Property losses ran to many millions of dollars, which for the time was an immense sum.
The financial fallout
The fire's economic effects were as important as its physical ones. Many of the city's fire insurance companies went under, because the number of claims was more than their reserves could pay. Businesses were wiped out, and the credit that had been extended to them was left hanging. The fire hit a financial system that was, in the mid-1830s, already running hot, and it was one of the shocks that preceded the Panic of 1837.
Yet the city recovered, and quickly. Merchants rebuilt on the same blocks, using brick and stone and, in the better buildings, iron and granite. The new buildings were more substantial than the ones they replaced, and in time the district took on the stone-and-granite look that older parts of the Financial District still carry. The fire acted as a kind of forced renewal, clearing the old wooden fabric and letting a new commercial core go up in its place.
What the fire taught the city
There were two lessons, and the city took both to heart, though not at once.
The first was about water. A city that cannot pump water when it needs it cannot defend itself against fire, and the freezing of 1835 made the point with painful clarity. The city had already been looking at bringing in a reliable supply from outside, and the fire turned a long-running debate into an emergency. The result was the Croton Aqueduct, which delivered upstate water to the city beginning on July 4, 1842, according to the Department of Environmental Protection's history, with a formal dedication on October 14 of that year. The story is told in The Croton Aqueduct brings water, 1842. The aqueduct is the most direct line one can draw from the Great Fire to something that still affects New Yorkers: the water system that the city relies on today began as an answer to this disaster.
The second lesson was about firefighting itself. The volunteer companies had done what they could, but the organization of fire protection in a city that size had become unsustainable. The professional department came later: the FDNY dates its history to 1865, when the city replaced its volunteer companies with a paid force. It is now the largest fire department in the country, with more than 17,000 employees. The fire of 1835 is one of the events that pushed the city in that direction, though it took three decades to get there.
The district today
If you walk the burned area now, you will not find a ruin. You will find the Financial District, the same ground at the southern tip of Manhattan, which is dense with buildings of many eras. The burned blocks lay east of Broad Street and south of Wall, and the streets that cross them, Pearl, Water, Front, South and the short lanes between, still have their old, narrow, crooked pattern from the Dutch and English periods. The district's history is told in The Financial District, where New York began, and the neighborhood's present shape in Financial District.
You can reach the area on the 2, 3, 4 or 5 at Wall St, on the J or Z at Broad St, on the 4 or 5 at Bowling Green, or on a number of other lines at Fulton St; the Staten Island Ferry's Whitehall Terminal is also near. A walk east from Broad Street along Wall to the water covers much of the burned ground in ten minutes.
What survives from before the fire is very little, which is the point. A few buildings that survived the blaze can be found by people who go looking, and the Landmarks Preservation Commission, created in 1965, has designated historic districts and individual landmarks in the area. The commission is described in Landmarks Preservation Commission, and its site lists the designations. What you mainly see is the rebuilt district, the buildings put up in the years right after the fire and in the decades that followed.
Reading the fire today
Historians like to point out that the Great Fire is not remembered as widely as it might be, partly because the city has had so many other disasters, a few of them much worse in terms of lives. The Triangle Shirtwaist fire of 1911 killed 146 garment workers, and the 1863 Draft Riots killed on the order of 100 to 120 people, according to the Municipal Archives. The 1835 fire is notable for how little it killed. Contemporary reports say few people died, and the loss was overwhelmingly one of property. In that sense it was a very specific kind of disaster, the kind that destroys a business district rather than a neighborhood of homes, and the recovery was correspondingly a business recovery.
For that reason, it is a useful event to study. It shows how a commercial city absorbs a shock: with insurance failures, a credit freeze, a quick rebuilding, and a slow lesson that changes how the city organizes itself. It also shows how the places we pass every day have layers underneath. The Wall Street area of 2026, with its skyscrapers and its stock-exchange crowds, sits on ground that burned flat in the winter of 1835 and was rebuilt in months.
A timeline
- 1825: the Erie Canal opens and trade surges.
- December 16, 1835: fire begins in a lower Manhattan warehouse; the cold freezes the city's water.
- December 17, 1835: the Merchants' Exchange and about 13 acres are destroyed.
- July 4, 1842: Croton water reaches the city.
- 1865: the paid fire department replaces the volunteers.
- 1965: the Landmarks Law creates the commission that protects the surviving historic buildings.