Blog
The Erie Canal and the Wedding of the Waters
How a ditch across upstate New York made the harbor city the country's great port, and the October 26, 1825 ceremony where Lake Erie met the Atlantic.
On October 26, 1825, a man in a good coat stood on a boat off Sandy Hook, lifted a keg, and poured water into the Atlantic Ocean. The water had come all the way from Lake Erie. Governor DeWitt Clinton had been waiting years for that moment, and a good part of the city's later fortune is traceable to it. New Yorkers called the ceremony the Wedding of the Waters. It was a piece of civic theater, and it was also an announcement: the harbor at the mouth of the Hudson had just been connected, by water, to the interior of the continent.
The canal itself was never in the five boroughs. It runs across upstate New York from the Hudson at Albany to Lake Erie at Buffalo. But no project did more to turn a modest seaport into the place that the rest of the country had to pass through, and the physical traces of that bargain are still around the waterfront, in the street names, the banks and the very notion that Wall Street is where American money is counted.
A ditch, and a city that did not believe in it
New York in 1817 was already the biggest town in the country, but it was not yet the dominant one. Philadelphia still had its banks and its prestige, Boston had its ships, Baltimore had its flour mills. What New York had, and what the others did not, was a harbor that stayed open in winter and a river, the Hudson, that was navigable far to the north. The problem was the mountains. West of Albany, the Appalachians and the Finger Lakes country lay between the Hudson and the Great Lakes, and anything hauled across them went by wagon, at ruinous cost.
The idea of a canal across the state had been floated for years. The usual objection was that it was too big a job for a young state with little money and few engineers. Critics called the plan "Clinton's Big Ditch." Clinton, a former mayor of the city and by then governor, backed it anyway, and ground was broken on July 4, 1817, at Rome, in central New York. The state financed the canal itself, with bonds, rather than waiting for private investors who were never going to come.
The finished waterway ran roughly 363 miles. It was cut about 40 feet wide at the surface and 4 feet deep, a modest channel by later standards, with a towpath along one bank where mules and horses pulled the boats. It climbed and dropped through a system of locks, 83 of them in the original design, to make up the difference in elevation between the Hudson and the lake. The cost was somewhere near $7 million, which was a staggering sum at the time, and the state's debt looked frightening for a few years. The tolls that came in after opening made the worry look foolish.
October 26, 1825
The opening was staged as a procession. A boat named the Seneca Chief left Buffalo carrying Clinton and other officials, with kegs of Lake Erie water aboard. To tell the city that the voyage had begun, a line of cannon was posted along the route, each one firing when it heard the one before it, so that the sound passed from Buffalo down the length of the canal and the Hudson to New York in a matter of hours. People remembered the trick for decades afterward, partly because it worked and partly because there was no faster way to send news.
The boats reached Albany, then went down the Hudson, towed by a steamboat, and came into the harbor. Ships and boats crowded the water. On October 26, out beyond the Narrows, Clinton poured the Lake Erie water into the sea. The Library of Congress gives that date, and it is the date the city has kept. The wedding image, the lake married to the ocean, was a typical piece of early-nineteenth-century oratory, and nobody in the crowd seems to have worried that it was a little silly. The mayor and the Common Council turned out, a great parade went up Broadway, and a celebration ran through the evening.
The scale of the ceremony tells you what the city thought it had done. This was not a local improvement. New York had put itself between the farm country of the Great Lakes and the ports of Europe, and it was daring everyone else to compete.
What the canal changed
Before the canal, moving a ton of freight from Buffalo to the Hudson cost an enormous amount and took weeks. After it, the price dropped sharply and the trip was predictable. Wheat, flour, lumber and potash came east. Manufactured goods, tools and settlers went west. Towns that had been villages, Rochester, Syracuse, Utica, Buffalo itself, grew into real cities along the canal's route because they sat on it.
For New York City, the effect was to lock in the lead. Merchants who could count on cargo in both directions built bigger warehouses, brought in more ships, and set up more banks and insurance firms to finance the traffic. The export crops arrived through the harbor. So did the immigrants, and the harbor handled the arriving people in the same year-round way it handled the arriving freight. The old rivalry with Philadelphia and Boston came to an end in practice, though the argument over which city really was first went on in the newspapers for years.
The effect shows up in the places where lower Manhattan is physically oriented toward the water. The Financial District, at the southern tip of the island, is where newcomers landed for about 300 years, and its streets still take their shape from the old waterfront and the counting-houses that lined it. The story of that district runs through The Financial District, where New York began, and a good deal of what the district became in the nineteenth century was paid for by the canal trade.
The grid, the canal and the money
The canal also fits a pattern in how the city thought about itself in those years. The street grid that covers most of Manhattan north of 14th Street was adopted in 1811, a plan drawn for a city that did not yet exist and that assumed it would grow. The grid and the canal are two halves of one bet: that New York would become much larger, and that the investment in laying out land for it and in connecting it to the interior would pay off. Read The 1811 Commissioners' Plan and the grid for the other half of that bet. By the 1830s, both had been proven right.
What the canal did not do
A fair account has to say what the canal did not accomplish. It was not the end of the city's troubles. It did not prevent the Great Fire of 1835, which burned the old business district on December 16 and 17 and wiped out the Merchants' Exchange and about 13 acres of lower Manhattan; the commercial boom that the canal fed was part of what made so much of that district so densely packed and so flammable. The city's response to that disaster is told in The Great Fire of 1835.
Nor did it solve the problem that a bigger city has more people to feed and more water to drink. The same city that was pouring Lake Erie water into the harbor was also, in those years, running short of clean water at home. Wells in the crowded lower island were polluted, and the city turned to an upstate reservoir system to fix it. That story, the Croton Aqueduct, opened in 1842, is in The Croton Aqueduct brings water, 1842. The two projects belong together: one brought commerce down from the lakes, the other brought drinking water down from the hills, and both depended on the idea that a city could reach a long way into the countryside for what it needed.
And the canal did not last at the center of the economy. Railroads arrived within a couple of decades and took away much of the freight business. The waterway was enlarged and rebuilt more than once, and in the twentieth century it was folded into the larger state Barge Canal system. The state's canal corporation still runs it today, mostly for recreation and some local freight, and the Canals Corporation's history pages are the place to read the engineering details.
Where to find the canal in the city
There is no lock to visit in the five boroughs. The place to stand, if you want to feel what the Wedding of the Waters was about, is on the harbor edge. Brooklyn Bridge Park, in the neighborhood called DUMBO at the foot of the Brooklyn Bridge, looks out over the same water that Clinton's flotilla crossed. The park is 85 acres, and on a clear day you can see the harbor traffic, the Statue of Liberty and the Staten Island Ferry running back and forth. The walk through that district is described in Brooklyn Bridge Park and the DUMBO waterfront.
At the other end of the harbor, the Staten Island Ferry runs for free every day between St. George and Whitehall Terminal in Lower Manhattan, around the clock, and puts you on the water at the Narrows' edge, which is about where Clinton stood. The ferry is operated by the Department of Transportation, whose page lists the schedule. It is a cheap way, in fact the cheapest, to see the water that the canal was built to reach.
If you want a map of what the canal meant, think of it as a long pipe. At one end is Lake Erie, at the other the Atlantic, and in the middle is a city that took a toll on everything passing through. New York has spent two centuries since then trying to describe itself in a way that does not sound like a toll booth, and has mostly failed. The honest version is that the canal made the city, a good deal of what it later became rested on that October morning, and the Wedding of the Waters was the first time New Yorkers had to admit it.
A short timeline
- July 4, 1817: construction begins at Rome, New York.
- 1825: the canal is complete from the Hudson at Albany to Lake Erie at Buffalo.
- October 26, 1825: Governor Clinton pours Lake Erie water into the Atlantic.
- 1835: the Great Fire destroys the lower Manhattan business district.
- 1842: the Croton Aqueduct brings upstate water to the city.