Blog

The Lower East Side's community gardens

How empty lots in Loisaida became the heart of the 1970s community-garden movement, and how to visit the gardens still open by the F, J, M, Z and L.

Walk east from Essex Street on almost any block of the Lower East Side or the East Village and sooner or later a chain-link fence or an iron gate breaks the wall of tenement fronts. Behind it you find raised beds, a fig tree wrapped for winter, a mural, a few folding chairs and, on warm afternoons, neighbors who know each other by first name. These are community gardens, and in this corner of Manhattan they are not decorations. They are what is left of one of the most consequential grassroots movements in the city's modern history.

The MTA's neighborhood guides name the Lower East Side and the East Village, the latter known by its Spanish-inflected nickname Loisaida, as the heart of the 1970s community-garden movement, and note that many of the gardens are still open. That sentence compresses a long story: of a city that nearly went bankrupt, of buildings that burned or were abandoned, and of residents who decided that a vacant lot was a piece of land waiting for somebody to use it.

Why there were so many empty lots

The Lower East Side was built for density. Its blocks of five- and six-story tenements, mostly put up in the nineteenth century, housed wave after wave of arrivals. The neighborhood was a first stop for Jewish and Italian immigrants, then for Chinese families on its southern edge (see Chinatown), and, from the middle of the twentieth century, for large numbers of Puerto Ricans. The name Loisaida is a respelling of "Lower East Side" as Puerto Rican residents said it, and it became the name of a community and a cultural movement.

By the 1970s the housing stock was old and many owners had stopped maintaining or paying taxes on it. The city's finances were collapsing at the same time. The fiscal crisis of 1975 led to the creation of the Municipal Assistance Corporation on June 10, 1975, and a Financial Control Board, and it forced deep cuts in city services. Fires, abandonment and demolition left gaps in the street wall, and the city took ownership of many lots through tax foreclosure. Rubble and trash gathered where buildings had stood. The July 1977 blackout and the looting that followed, covered in The blackout of July 1977, came into a neighborhood that already felt abandoned by its government.

Into those lots came residents with rakes, buckets and seeds. They hauled out debris, brought in soil, built fences and planted vegetables and flowers. They did it mostly without permission at first, and then increasingly under informal and formal arrangements with the city. The result, repeated block after block, is why the Lower East Side and East Village have more small gardens per square mile than almost anywhere else in the five boroughs.

What a community garden is, and is not

A community garden is not a public park, although many visitors treat it as one. It is usually a lot owned by the city and managed by a group of neighbors, who elect or appoint stewards, hold work days, grow food or flowers, and set the hours when the gate is open. Some gardens keep individual plots that members tend; others grow food communally. Many host events: a Saturday morning work party, a neighborhood potluck, a poetry reading, a children's art afternoon.

For a visitor that means a few practical rules. The gate may be open only on certain days or during certain hours, which are usually posted on the fence. Many gardens welcome visitors when a steward is present. Pick no flowers or produce unless invited, keep dogs out unless a sign says otherwise, and treat the place as someone's backyard, which is what it is. Some gardens post a regular open house or volunteer session; the sign on the gate tells you.

Two city agencies matter to the gardens' day-to-day life. NYC Parks supports gardens through programs for community groups, and the Department of Sanitation hauls the municipal waste that gardens do not compost themselves. Compost is a significant part of the story. Curbside composting and food-scrap drop-off exist in the city, and the way those systems work is laid out in How trash, recycling and composting work in New York City.

The East Village and Alphabet City

East of First Avenue the East Village's avenues drop their numbers and take letters: A, B, C and D. That grid gave the area the name Alphabet City, and it is where many of the neighborhood's gardens still sit, tucked between six-story walk-ups and newer apartment buildings. Tompkins Square Park, a few blocks from the F train at Second Avenue, anchors the area as a public park, and the community gardens fill in around it.

The East Village's subway access is good. The L runs under 14th Street with stops at First and Third Avenues, the F stops at Second Avenue, the 6 stops at Astor Place and the R and W stop at 8th Street-NYU. A walk from the L's First Avenue station south and east takes you into the heart of Alphabet City in a few minutes.

The East Village is where "Loisaida" belongs most naturally on a street sign. Along Avenue C you pass old tenements, community centers and the gardens, and the murals and neighborhood organizations recall the Puerto Rican community that shaped the area.

The Lower East Side below Houston Street

South of Houston Street the neighborhood tilts toward the southern tenement blocks and the corridor around Delancey and Essex. The subway here is served by the Delancey Street-Essex Street station (F, J, M, Z), Grand Street (B, D), East Broadway (F) and Second Avenue (F). Katz's Delicatessen, which says it has stood on the Lower East Side since 1888 and bills itself as the city's oldest deli, shows how much of the area's history is still visible at street level; the story of that landmark and the neighborhood's food is in Katz's Delicatessen and the Lower East Side deli.

In this part of the neighborhood the gardens are fewer and often smaller than in Alphabet City, and they appear between older buildings or beside housing developments. They are easy to miss from the street: look for gaps in the building line, painted fences, benches seen through the bars of a gate, and signs that give the garden's name and hours. For the whole neighborhood's profile, see Lower East Side.

A walk through the gardens

A simple route links the neighborhood's two halves:

  1. Start at Delancey Street-Essex Street (F, J, M, Z). Walk north on Essex or Orchard Street toward Houston Street, passing the shops and tenement fronts that preserve the area's older look.
  2. Cross Houston into the East Village and walk east along any of the numbered streets between Second Avenue and Avenue C, looking for gates in the fence line. Eighth, Ninth and Tenth Streets are good places to start, and the blocks between Avenues B and C reward slow walking.
  3. Turn north or south along Avenue C and Avenue B, where the garden entrances often face the avenue.
  4. Finish at Tompkins Square Park, and from there walk west to the 6 at Astor Place, or back to the F at Second Avenue.

The whole loop takes an hour or two at a stroll, depending on how many gates are open. If a garden is closed when you pass, do not climb the fence. Come back during the hours on the sign.

Why the gardens survive

Community gardens in this part of the city have survived by being useful, by being cared for, and by finding allies in city government. They also survive because the people who run them are persistent. Each garden has to keep up its membership, raise or save money for soil and tools, and keep following whatever agreements it has with the city, and the stewards who do that work are volunteers.

The gardens' lasting claim on the neighborhood is social as much as botanical. They give a dense neighborhood open air, trees, shade and a gathering place. In a part of the city where many residents live in small apartments, a garden is the nearest thing to a yard.

Other gardens in the five boroughs follow the same logic. Farther uptown, Harlem Grown, a youth-gardening nonprofit with twelve sites that the MTA's neighborhood guides highlight in East Harlem, grows food on formerly vacant lots with schoolchildren. That story is in East Harlem and Harlem Grown, and the wider network of gardens and urban farms is covered in community gardens and urban farms. Not every garden is on a lot left by the 1970s: Greenpoint's rooftop farm at 44 Eagle Street, which the MTA's guide calls the nation's first green-roof commercial farm, comes from a different tradition, told in 44 Eagle Street and Greenpoint's rooftop farm.

What to look for inside a gate

Once a gardener lets you in, a few features tell you how a garden works. Raised beds and plot markers show whether members tend individual plots or the garden is farmed in common. Compost bins and tool sheds mean there are regular work days. A bulletin board by the gate usually carries the hours, the steward's contact and the next event. Murals and benches show that the space is also a gathering place. None of these is required of a garden, but each is a clue to the habits of the people who keep it going.

Going in season

The gardens show their best from late spring through early fall, when beds are in flower and vegetables are ripening. Winter is quieter, and many gardens are closed or open only on special days, though some hold seasonal events. If you want to see a garden at its fullest, plan a visit for a warm weekend afternoon and check the posted hours. Seeing them in early spring, when volunteers are cleaning beds and turning compost, is often the best time to meet the people who run them.

If you live nearby and want to join a garden, go in person. Look for the posted contact on the gate, come to a work day, and ask the stewards how the membership works. Gardens are community-run, and nearly all of them need volunteers.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic