Blog
Community gardens and urban farms
How empty lots in Loisaida became gardens in the 1970s, and how Harlem Grown and a Greenpoint rooftop farm carry the idea on, with their subway stops.
New York grows food on a surprising range of surfaces: a vacant lot between tenements, a schoolyard in East Harlem, the roof of a warehouse in Greenpoint. The three examples that follow come from different eras and different corners of the city, with different motives, but they share a pattern. In each case, people took land that nobody else was using and put soil on it.
The MTA's own neighborhood guides, which the transit agency publishes for visitors, point to all three. The guide to the Lower East Side and East Village describes the 1970s community-garden movement centered on Loisaida, with many gardens still open. The East Harlem guide names Harlem Grown, a youth-gardening nonprofit with 12 sites. And the Greenpoint guide points to 44 Eagle Street, topped by what it calls the nation's first green-roof commercial farm. Each one is reachable by subway, and each tells a different part of the story.
The 1970s: gardens from rubble
Loisaida is the Puerto Rican and Nuyorican name for the Lower East Side, a Spanglish rendering of the English words, and it is the name the neighborhood's residents gave the area as it filled with Puerto Rican families in the middle of the twentieth century. By the 1970s, the neighborhood was losing buildings to fire, abandonment and arson. Whole blocks had gaps where tenements once stood. The city, in the grip of the fiscal crisis of 1975 that saw it nearly lose the ability to pay its bills, had little money to clear or redevelop the lots, and they filled with rubble, weeds and dumped trash.
Residents began to clear them. They hauled out debris, brought in soil and planted vegetables, flowers and trees. Some of the first groups gave themselves names and later organized across the city; the Green Guerillas, who threw "seed bombs" over fences into locked lots, are the most famous. A garden on the Bowery at Houston Street, founded in the early 1970s, became one of the best-known examples. Over the years, the gardens became more than plots: they were gathering places with casitas, small wooden buildings in the Puerto Rican tradition, used for music, cooking and community meetings.
The gardens needed legal footing, and they did not always have it. Many sat on city-owned land held on informal arrangements. City Parks eventually took over a program, GreenThumb, that licenses community groups to garden on city land and supplies seeds, tools and technical help. In the late 1990s, a plan to sell off garden lots for development set off a fierce public fight, and it ended in an agreement in 2002 that preserved hundreds of the gardens. The result is that many of the places a visitor finds today are protected in a way they were not in the 1980s.
Getting there
The neighborhood gardens are spread through the East Village and Lower East Side, so you will find them by walking rather than by following a single address. A useful starting point is the F at 2nd Avenue, which serves both neighborhoods; the L at 1st Avenue and the 6 at Astor Place are close to the East Village side. The F, J, M and Z at Delancey Street-Essex Street are the best base for the southern part of the Lower East Side. Lower East Side lists the stations and ZIP codes, and The Lower East Side's community gardens goes deeper into the gardens themselves. The same area is covered from the neighborhood side in The East Village and Alphabet City.
Gardens in the city's system have posted hours, and many are open to the public only when a member is present. Check the garden's own posted sign or the GreenThumb listing before you go, and treat a closed gate as a closed gate.
The 2010s and 2020s: growing food for children
Harlem Grown was founded in 2011 by a volunteer in a Harlem school who noticed a neglected lot beside it. The nonprofit began by turning that lot into a garden, and over the following years added schoolyards, greenhouses and urban farms, with young people doing much of the planting and harvesting. The MTA's East Harlem guide counts 12 sites, and the number has varied over the years as sites opened and changed.
The idea is the same as in Loisaida, with a different emphasis. The 1970s gardens grew food and community for people whose neighborhood had been left behind. Harlem Grown uses growing to teach children where vegetables come from, and runs programs around cooking and nutrition. Much of what it produces goes back to the neighborhoods that surround it.
Getting there
East Harlem is served by the 6 train at 103rd, 110th and 116th Streets, and by the 4, 5 and 6 at 125th Street. Metro-North's Harlem-125th Street station sits in the same neighborhood. For the neighborhood context, see East Harlem and Harlem Grown and Harlem. Volunteering and visiting arrangements are set by the organization itself; check its site before showing up.
The rooftop: 44 Eagle Street
The third example sits on top of a building. At 44 Eagle Street in Greenpoint, a warehouse in a former industrial stretch near the East River is topped by what the MTA's guide calls the nation's first green-roof commercial farm. A green roof is a layer of soil and plants over the roof membrane; a commercial farm on a green roof sells what it grows. The result is a way to add growing space in a city where ground-level land is scarce and expensive.
Greenpoint is a neighborhood of low industrial buildings, and the roofs are flat. That makes it a natural place to try the idea. The G train serves Greenpoint Avenue and Nassau Avenue, and NYC Ferry's East River route stops at Greenpoint. The farm's visiting arrangements are the farm's own; the full profile is in 44 Eagle Street and Greenpoint's rooftop farm.
Three kinds of urban growing
The three examples are different tools for different jobs.
| Type | Where | Main aim | Land |
|---|---|---|---|
| Community garden | Lower East Side, East Village | Neighbors growing food and gathering | City-owned lots, licensed to groups |
| Youth farm and school garden | East Harlem | Teaching and feeding | Lots, schoolyards, greenhouses |
| Commercial rooftop farm | Greenpoint | Selling produce | A building's own roof |
A visitor might think of them as a ladder of scale, but they are really parallel. A garden asks nothing of the city except land and water. A nonprofit farm needs funding and volunteers. A commercial rooftop farm needs a building owner who is willing to carry the weight of soil on the roof and the costs of the system around it.
How the city makes room for them
The city plays a part at each level. NYC Parks runs the program that licenses gardens on its lots. The Department of Buildings regulates what can be built on a roof, which matters for green roofs and rooftop farms because soil is heavy; the department's page on building permits explains how it works, and the guide to permits on this site, How to get a building permit in New York City, gives the steps. The Department of City Planning sets the zoning that decides what can be built on a lot, and a lot that is zoned for housing has a different future than one that is a garden. A garden's survival often depends on whether the land under it is a park, a licensed lot or a parcel the city intends to build on.
You can see the tension if you look at what happened in the 1990s: the same vacant lots that residents had turned into gardens were attractive to developers once the neighborhood recovered. The 2002 agreement decided the question for hundreds of gardens, but the underlying choice, between building housing and keeping green space, comes up again whenever a lot is proposed for development.
A short timeline
- 1970s. Fires and abandonment leave gaps across the Lower East Side; residents clear lots and plant gardens. The city's 1975 fiscal crisis leaves little money to do anything else with the land.
- Late 1990s. A plan to auction garden lots for development sparks a public fight.
- 2002. An agreement preserves hundreds of gardens.
- 2011. Harlem Grown begins with one lot beside a Harlem school and grows into a network of sites.
- Today. Rooftop farming, including the Greenpoint rooftop at 44 Eagle Street, adds a commercial strand to what began as a neighborhood project.
What a visit is like
Gardens are small, and most are run by volunteers. A visitor who walks in when the gate is open is a guest in someone's yard. Ask before photographing people, keep to the paths and leave plants alone. If a garden posts a schedule or a contact, that is how it welcomes new members; many gardens depend on a few dozen regulars, and a neighborhood resident who wants to join is usually told to come to a workday. NYC Parks' GreenThumb program keeps a listing of gardens and the groups that run them, and it is the place to start if you want to join one rather than just look.
Seeing all three in a day
A Saturday is enough to see the three. Start in the Lower East Side or East Village, walking from the F at 2nd Avenue and looking for gardens behind fences; many have signs with hours. Take the 6 north, change as needed, and ride to East Harlem to see a Harlem Grown site; use the nonprofit's own listing for addresses and visiting times. Finish in Greenpoint, where the G stops at Greenpoint Avenue and Nassau Avenue and the ferry gives a second way home. A day like that crosses three different ideas about what a city is for: a place to live, a place to learn, and a place to grow food.
If you are visiting with children, Free things to do in New York City collects other low-cost outings, and the guide to the five boroughs, the five boroughs and their counties, helps you plan the geography.