Blog

The subway's opening day, October 27, 1904

On October 27, 1904, the IRT opened 28 stations from City Hall to 145th Street at a five-cent fare. How that line connects to the stations riders use today.

On October 27, 1904, more than 100,000 New Yorkers gathered at 28 street corners in Manhattan, walked down the stairs and boarded electric trains. The Interborough Rapid Transit Company, a private firm, had finished a line that ran from City Hall to 145th Street and Broadway, and the city's subway had begun. The fare was five cents. The pitch was speed: City Hall to Harlem in 15 minutes.

That is the version of the story the MTA tells, and the numbers in it are worth unpacking, because the line built that year is still in use. Most of its stations are still open, and a rider today can ride a train through the route that those first passengers took.

What opened that day

The first line was 9.1 miles long. It began at City Hall, where the IRT built a showpiece station, and ran north along the east side of Manhattan to Union Square and 42nd Street, then west to Times Square and north along Broadway to 145th Street. When the New York Transit Museum marked the anniversary in 2022, it displayed historic photographs at the stations that survive on that first line: Brooklyn Bridge-City Hall, Canal St, Spring St, Bleecker St, Union Square, 23rd St, 33rd St, 42nd St-Times Sq, 50th St, 59th St, 66th St, 72nd St, 86th St, 96th St, 103rd St, 137th St and 145th St.

Many of those stations are still stops today. Using the station dataset the MTA publishes, the downtown stretch is now the Lexington Avenue line: Canal St, Spring St and Bleecker St are served by the 6. Times Sq-42 St is served by the 1, 2 and 3. On the west side, the 1 stops at 59 St-Columbus Circle, 66 St-Lincoln Center and 72 St. And at the northern end, 137 St-City College and 145 St are on the 1, with 145 St also served by the A, B, C and D.

The route has been rearranged since 1904. Lines were added and the original line was split into separate services, which is why the downtown part is the 6 and the Broadway part is the 1. But the stations kept their places on the map, and the geography of that first line is still the spine of Manhattan's subway map.

Fifteen minutes to Harlem

The slogan, "City Hall to Harlem in 15 minutes," was a boast about the new technology. The subway ran on its own electrified tracks, below the traffic on the streets, and its speed was part of the pitch.

The MTA's account says that on the first day more than 100,000 people rode. The IRT's president, August Belmont Jr., celebrated in a private car with Tiffany glass panels.

The first station, and what happened to it

City Hall Station was the IRT's showpiece, and it was one of the first 28 stations to open. It survives in a way that no other 1904 station does. The station has been out of passenger service since 1945, but it is still used as a turning loop for the 6 train, and it is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Today's trains do not stop there for riders; they circle through the loop to reverse direction. The New York Transit Museum has offered tours and a virtual walk-through of the old station, according to the MTA's account.

The station is a reminder that a transit system accumulates its own archaeology. Stations close, platforms are lengthened, tunnels are reused. The City Hall loop is the oldest piece of that record that is still in daily use.

A nickel, and then a dime

Early passengers paid a nickel. The MTA's history notes that the first fare increase did not come until 1948, when the fare went to ten cents. Since 1904 there have been only a few ways to pay: first a paper ticket, then in the 1940s a dime dropped in the box, then tokens, then the MetroCard, and now a tap with OMNY.

Today's fare is $3 for most riders on subways and local buses, as of 2026, according to the MTA's fare page. A comparison with the nickel is a trap if taken literally, because five cents in 1904 bought a different amount of goods than five cents buys now. The arithmetic itself is simple: $3 is 60 times five cents. The way people pay has changed too: a rider now taps a contactless card, phone or OMNY card, and the weekly cap of $35 means the system stops charging after a certain number of rides in seven days. Riding the subway and buses: fares, OMNY and the weekly cap explains the details, and The MetroCard's retirement and the 2026 fares covers the change that ended MetroCard sales on January 1, 2026.

The system that grew from it

The MTA's anniversary account says that the subway has grown from those first stations to what is now the largest 24-hour subway system in the world, with 472 stations, over 800 track miles and over 6,000 subway cars. Those figures come from an October 2022 article, so they describe the system as of then. The first line, extended by 1907 to 225th Street, was the start of a network that spread across all of Manhattan and into the Bronx, Brooklyn and Queens.

The subway opened six years after the five boroughs were joined into a single city on January 1, 1898, and it became one of the systems that made the union a daily reality. 1898: the five boroughs consolidate covers the consolidation.

Stations outside the first line followed as the network grew. The station at 191st Street in Washington Heights, for example, did not open until 1911, because the area was lightly settled when the line passed through in 1904, as explained in The deepest stations: 190th and 191st Streets. Between 1900 and 1920, the population of Manhattan north of 155th Street grew from about 8,000 to 110,000, driven in part by the expanding transit system.

The numbers, set side by side

The figures from the first day make a useful table, if the arithmetic is done carefully.

  • Length and stations. A 9.1-mile line with 28 stations averages about one station for every third of a mile, since 27 gaps span 9.1 miles. That is a close spacing, which is why a local subway ride feels like a series of short hops.
  • Speed. The slogan promised City Hall to Harlem in 15 minutes. Taken at face value, 9.1 miles in 15 minutes is an average of about 36 miles per hour, stops included. Actual running times on any route change with the service pattern, and the MTA's trip planner gives the current time for a given trip.
  • Crowds. More than 100,000 people were reported at 28 corners. If the crowd had been spread evenly, that would be about 3,600 people at each station on opening day.
  • Growth. Twenty-eight stations then, and 472 stations as of the MTA's 2022 article, is a system roughly seventeen times as large by station count. Track miles went from the original line's 9.1 to over 800.
  • Fare. Five cents then, $3 now as of 2026, and a 60-fold increase in the nominal price over 122 years.

None of these numbers explains why people rode. For that, the useful figure is the one from northern Manhattan: the population north of 155th Street went from about 8,000 in 1900 to 110,000 in 1920, in a period when the subway reached it. A new line changes where a city can grow, and the first one did that at once.

Who ran it

The IRT was a privately owned company, with August Belmont Jr. as its president. Today the Metropolitan Transportation Authority runs the subway, and the agency tells the system's history through its MTA Away guides and the New York Transit Museum. The agency's record is in Metropolitan Transportation Authority.

The first line's later chapters

The line did not stay as it opened. The MTA's account says that by 1907 the line had been extended to 225th Street, and the area around 191st Street, still thinly settled, got its station in 1911. That station, now one of the deepest in the system, is described in The deepest stations: 190th and 191st Streets. Each extension pulled development north behind it, which is the pattern the whole network repeated as it spread into the other boroughs. The city's transit history and its growth are two views of the same story.

The old City Hall station, meanwhile, closed to passengers in 1945, forty-one years after it opened. The loop that the 6 still uses to turn around is the quietest reminder of the system's start.

Taking the first line today

A rider who wants to retrace the route of 1904 can do it on a morning, using today's lines.

  1. Start downtown. Take the 6 from Brooklyn Bridge-City Hall, the stop nearest the old City Hall station. The 6 uses the old City Hall station as its turning loop, though the station is not open for boarding.
  2. Ride north on the 6. The line follows Lafayette Street and Park Avenue, with stops at Spring St, Bleecker St and Union Square on the original route.
  3. Switch to the 1 for Broadway. From Times Sq-42 St, the 1 runs north along the original Broadway route through 50th St, 59th St-Columbus Circle, 66th St, 72nd St, 86th St and 96th St. It continues to 137th St-City College and 145th St.

The ride takes more than 15 minutes today, because the train makes many more stops and the line is part of a much larger system. But the shape of the route is the shape of 1904.

For the agency that runs the system today, see Metropolitan Transportation Authority.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic