Blog

1898: the five boroughs consolidate

The 1897 charter took effect on January 1, 1898, joining five boroughs into one city; the Bronx became its own county in 1914.

On the first day of 1898, the map of New York changed overnight. The city that had been the island of Manhattan and a piece of the Bronx absorbed the then-separate city of Brooklyn, much of Queens County and all of Staten Island, and became a single municipality of five boroughs. The government that stood up that morning is the one still in place today, with changes, and the five-borough shape is the shape of the city every New Yorker knows.

The date is straightforward: the City of Greater New York began on January 1, 1898. The law that made it was passed earlier, and the Bronx's status as a county of its own came later. This piece lays out the sequence, what each piece of the city was before the merger and how the arrangement of boroughs and counties works now.

Five places that were not one

To see what consolidation did, start with what existed before. The old City of New York was essentially Manhattan, together with the parts of the Bronx that had been annexed from Westchester County in stages in the 1870s and 1890s. Across the East River lay Brooklyn, which was a separate city, a large one, with its own mayor, its own police and its own government. Brooklyn had grown rapidly in the nineteenth century as a home for people who worked in Manhattan and in the harbor, and by the 1890s it was one of the largest cities in the country.

To the east, Queens County was a large rural county that included the villages and farms of what are now the western neighborhoods and the towns of what is now Nassau County. To the south, across the harbor, Staten Island formed Richmond County. Each had its own local governments, its own taxes and its own ideas about whether to join the big city across the water.

The Brooklyn Bridge, which opened in 1883, made the question urgent. Once people could walk, ride and later take trains across the river, the two cities were joined in daily life, and the legal separation looked more and more like an obstacle. The same was true of the new subway, which opened on October 27, 1904, with a five-cent fare, after the five boroughs were one city. See The Brooklyn Bridge opens, 1883 and The subway's opening day, October 27, 1904.

The charter

The legal instrument was the charter of Greater New York. The state legislature, which controlled the legal status of cities in New York, passed it, and it became law in 1897. The city's own history pages say the charter became law on May 4, 1897, with the new city to begin on January 1, 1898. That gap of more than seven months gave the five governments time to prepare to merge their offices, courts, police forces and debts.

The charter did not simply extend the old city's rules over the new territory. It created a new structure for the combined city. The mayor was the head of the whole, with citywide bodies above the old local governments. Each of the five boroughs was to have a borough president, who would speak for the borough, and the city's government was to be a mix of centralized authority and borough-level offices. The relationship between the central city and its boroughs has been rewritten many times since 1898, and one of the biggest rewrites came in 1989, when the Board of Estimate was abolished and the City Council was enlarged to 51 members; the story is told in 1989: the year the Board of Estimate ended.

Why it passed

The reasons for consolidation were commercial and practical as much as political. Supporters argued that a single city could plan harbor development, water supply, transit and public works across the whole region instead of five separate pieces. They pointed to the economics of scale and the advantages of a large tax base. Opponents, especially in Brooklyn, worried that their city would lose its identity and be taxed to pay for the needs of Manhattan, and some feared the loss of local control. The question went to voters in the affected places, and the outcome was close in Brooklyn, where the merger was approved by a narrow margin.

The arguments are familiar to anyone who has heard a modern debate about regional government: a bigger government offers coordination, and a smaller one offers closeness. In 1898 the first side won, and the five-borough city has lasted for more than a century and a quarter.

Boroughs and counties

The way the five boroughs fit with New York State's counties is a feature of the city that surprises newcomers. Each borough is coextensive with a county, so the boundaries are the same, but the names are different.

Borough County 2020 Census population
Bronx Bronx County 1,472,654
Brooklyn Kings County 2,736,074
Manhattan New York County 1,694,251
Queens Queens County 2,405,464
Staten Island Richmond County 495,747

Those numbers sum to 8,804,190, the city's 2020 total. The Bronx's county status is the late piece of the arrangement. When the city consolidated in 1898, the Bronx was part of New York County, the same county as Manhattan. It became a county of its own on January 1, 1914, according to the city's history pages, completing the pattern of five boroughs and five counties. District attorneys prosecute in each county, which is why a city of eight and a half million people has five of them; see five boroughs, five counties, five district attorneys and The five boroughs and their counties.

An important wrinkle: when Queens joined the city, only part of Queens County did. The eastern portion of the old county chose not to join, and it later became a county of its own, Nassau County. That is why Queens today is a county of the city and not the large rural county it was before 1898. The part of the county that stayed out is the reason the border between Queens and Nassau, at the city's eastern edge, is a county line.

What a resident sees today

The consolidation is not just history. It explains several features of daily life.

  • One fare, one government. A single mayor, comptroller, Council and set of agencies serve all five boroughs. A parking ticket in Staten Island and one in the Bronx are handled by the same Department of Finance; the same Sanitation Department collects trash in each borough. The services are described in How New York City government works.
  • Borough identity. People still identify by borough first: "I'm from Brooklyn" or "I live in Queens." The boroughs were separate cities or counties, and their local pride predates consolidation. the five boroughs and their counties covers the five.
  • Borough names on forms. Official forms often ask for a borough, and the answer determines the county, the district attorney, the court and several other things.
  • Community districts. Beneath the boroughs, the city is divided into 59 community districts, each with a community board that advises on local issues. They are the official unit of neighborhood geography, as the city's planners note.
  • Transit. The subway, the buses and the ferries that connect the boroughs were built after consolidation, and they bind the five together. The Staten Island Ferry, free every day between St. George and Lower Manhattan, is the direct link between the borough and the center; see St. George.

Seeing it on the ground

You can trace the edges of the old arrangement in several places.

  1. The Brooklyn Bridge. Walk across it from Manhattan to Brooklyn, and you cross the line that once separated two cities. The bridge predates the merger by fifteen years.
  2. The Staten Island Ferry. Take the ferry from Whitehall Terminal to St. George and you cross the harbor to a borough that was a separate county with its own towns.
  3. Yankee Stadium. At 161 St-Yankee Stadium, the Bronx's identity as a distinct borough is on display, and the story of the borough's place in the county system is a reminder that it was part of New York County until 1914; see The Grand Concourse and Yankee Stadium.
  4. The Queens-Nassau line. Ride the LIRR out of Queens and watch the stations change from city to suburb. The county line is the old boundary of a county that was split in 1898.

Why 1898 is still argued about

Consolidation has always had critics, and the argument has not gone away. Some people in Staten Island have periodically asked whether the borough would be better off on its own. Some argue that Brooklyn, with a population of 2,736,074 in 2020, would be among the largest cities in the nation if it were independent. Others say that the single city has been a success, a way to run a transit system, a water system and a harbor as one. The point is not to settle the debate but to see that it is a living one: the five-borough structure is a deliberate choice made at a particular time, and a choice that can be reconsidered.

The most important thing to understand is that the city is a product of a law. The charter of 1897, which took effect on January 1, 1898, is why a resident of Tottenville and a resident of the Bronx share a mayor. Without it, the five places might have gone on as separate cities and counties, with their own governments and their own histories. With it, they became New York City, and the city's later history, from the subway to the Council to the budgets that run to $125.84 billion, grew out of that one decision.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic