Blog

What the Comptroller does, from audits to the waste hotline

The elected citywide office at One Centre Street: audits, contract registration, claims, pensions, budget reports and the (212) NO-WASTE line.

Most city offices serve you directly: a department collects your trash, a clerk issues a marriage license, a bus takes you to work. The Comptroller's office does something less visible and in some ways more basic. It checks. It audits agencies, registers contracts, settles claims against the city, invests and oversees pension money, and publishes the independent numbers that the public and the press use to judge the mayor's budget. As of 2026 the office is held by Mark Levine, and it is located at One Centre Street in Manhattan.

The Comptroller is one of three officials elected citywide, along with the mayor and the public advocate. That election gives the office something unusual in a government where most agency heads are appointed: an independent political base. The mayor appoints the commissioners of the departments the Comptroller audits, and the Comptroller answers to the voters, not to the mayor. That separation is the point.

The main jobs

The Comptroller's own website sorts its work into a set of services. The main ones are these.

Audit and investigations. The office audits city agencies and investigates suspected wasteful spending. Audits examine whether an agency is spending money as intended and following its own rules, and the findings are published. Residents who suspect wasteful spending can report it through the office's waste line, (212) NO-WASTE, which spells out the phone number as the word.

Contract registration. City agencies buy goods and services through contracts, and the Comptroller's office registers them. The office issues directives and memoranda that agencies must follow, keeps a late-contracts dashboard and publishes guidance for businesses that want to sell to the city, including notices of requests for proposals and solicitations. For vendors it is part of how a contract becomes official, and for the public it is a check on how the city commits money.

Claims. Residents can file claims against the city, for example for property damage or injury. The Comptroller's office handles the filing, judgments and settlements, publishes a claims filed and settled dashboard and provides a way to ask about the payment of a judgment or settlement.

Pensions and investments. The office has a pension and investment management function and provides services for city retirees. The size of the system, $329 billion according to the Department of Finance, is explained in the city's $329 billion pension system.

Budget and fiscal oversight. The office publishes budget reports, statements on the mayor's financial plan and the city's Annual Comprehensive Financial Report, and runs Checkbook NYC, a public tool for looking at how the city spends money. It also deals with city bonds, workers' compensation and wage schedules.

Other services. The office also handles Freedom of Information Law requests directed to it and issues the Certificate of Residence. The general process for public records requests across the city is covered in Requesting public records with FOIL.

The budget reports

The public sees the Comptroller most clearly in its budget analysis, because it is the one major independent assessment of the budget and the one that reads it as a skeptic. Two kinds of report show how.

The adopted budget comments. For fiscal year 2027, the Comptroller published comments on the adopted budget on August 12, 2026. They report the budget at $125.84 billion, which is $1.14 billion above the May executive budget, with a capital budget of $29.10 billion. They record that the Office of Management and Budget forecasts $88.67 billion in tax revenue for the year, of which property tax is $37.30 billion, about 42 percent, and personal income tax plus the pass-through entity tax is $20.76 billion. They point out that $6.07 billion of temporary and one-shot measures closed the budget gaps over fiscal years 2026 and 2027, and that the general reserve for 2027 is $450 million, about $1.0 billion below the usual in-year level. The comments set out the city's own projected gaps for the next three years, $6.44 billion, $8.21 billion and $8.52 billion, and give the Comptroller's restated version, which is $7.25 billion, $7.87 billion and $6.84 billion.

That last point shows the office's role. The mayor's budget office and the Comptroller can look at the same numbers and reach different totals, and the difference is information. When the Comptroller says a plan relies on savings that have not been identified, the public learns where the risk lies. A longer look at those comments is in The first Mamdani budget as the Comptroller read it, and the plain-number version of the budget is in The FY2027 city budget in plain numbers.

The monthly outlook. The office also publishes a monthly economic and fiscal outlook titled "New York by the Numbers." The July 2026 issue, number 115, reported the city's unemployment rate at 5.4 percent in May, a ten-month low, with labor force participation at 62.6 percent and an employment-population ratio of 59.2 percent, a record. It also reported that NYSE member firms posted $21.1 billion in first-quarter profits, up 37.1 percent. How to read those jobs figures is explained in The job market in May 2026, and the link between profits and the budget in Wall Street profits and the city budget.

Reading the two sets of gaps

The comparison in the adopted budget comments rewards a close look. The city's own plan shows the current year, fiscal year 2027, as balanced. The Comptroller's restated figure for that year is a gap of $743 million, and the Comptroller adds that if unsubstantiated savings are counted as risk, the 2027 gap rises to about $1.41 billion. For the outyears the two sets of numbers diverge in both directions:

Fiscal year City's gap Comptroller's restated gap Difference
2028 $6.44 billion $7.25 billion Comptroller higher by $0.81 billion
2029 $8.21 billion $7.87 billion Comptroller lower by $0.34 billion
2030 $8.52 billion $6.84 billion Comptroller lower by $1.68 billion

The pattern shows what independent analysis adds. The Comptroller is not simply more pessimistic: for 2028 it sees a larger gap than the administration, and for 2029 and 2030 a smaller one. That reflects different assumptions about revenue and spending, and it is exactly the kind of difference the public cannot see without a second set of books.

What the economic outlook tracks

The monthly outlook is a compact dashboard. The July 2026 issue gives total nonfarm employment in the city at 4,853,890 in May, up 15,800 in the month and 49,100 over twelve months, and reports preliminary tax revenue for fiscal year 2026, through June, of $85.4 billion, up 7.3 percent. Personal income tax and the pass-through entity tax were $20.8 billion, up 13.4 percent; sales tax $10.9 billion, up 6.4 percent; and property tax $35.4 billion, up 2.2 percent. The sales tax is explained in Sales tax in New York City: the 8.875 percent rate. The outlook also notes that estimated payments of personal income tax and the pass-through entity tax in June were about $900 million, up 25 percent from a year earlier.

An example: following a contract

A hypothetical shows the pieces fitting together. Say a city agency needs a new software system and issues a request for proposals. Vendors respond, and the agency selects one. The contract goes to the Comptroller for registration. If the contract is late or the paperwork is incomplete, it appears on the late-contracts dashboard. Once registered, the contract is on the books. Later, the Comptroller's audit staff might examine whether the system was delivered on time and as promised, and an audit report would say so. A resident can search Checkbook NYC to see what the city paid. And if the vendor were suspected of overbilling, the Department of Investigation, described in Tweed and the birth of the Department of Investigation, could look into it.

The steps are illustrative, not the legal sequence for any one contract. They show how the Comptroller's functions work together: a gatekeeper at the start, an auditor after the fact and a public ledger throughout.

How the office fits among the other oversight bodies

The Comptroller is one of several offices that check city government. The Public Advocate, also elected citywide, is a non-voting member of the Council who acts as an ombudsman for city services; see The Public Advocate: New York's ombudsman. The Department of Investigation is the city's inspector general. The Conflicts of Interest Board administers ethics laws, and the Civilian Complaint Review Board handles complaints against police officers. The Independent Budget Office provides separate analysis of the budget. Who watches city officials: DOI, COIB and the CCRB compares three of these bodies.

What distinguishes the Comptroller is the combination of an elected mandate and control over money. Agency heads are appointed by the mayor, while the Comptroller is chosen by voters, and the office's registration of contracts and handling of claims touch every agency.

How the office is chosen

The three citywide offices, mayor, comptroller and public advocate, are elected by voters across all five boroughs. The Comptroller is elected at the same time as the others, and the voting process, including ranked-choice voting in primaries, is explained in How voting works in New York City: poll sites, ranked choice and ballot measures and Ranked choice voting in New York City. The charter changes of 1989, which left the Comptroller as an elected citywide official while ending the Board of Estimate, are covered in 1989: the year the Board of Estimate ended.

Using the office as a resident

Several of the office's tools are open to anyone.

  1. Read the reports. The budget comments and the monthly outlook are on the Comptroller's website and are written for a general reader.
  2. Look up spending. Checkbook NYC shows what the city paid, to whom and for what.
  3. File a claim. If the city damaged your property or injured you, the office handles claims. The website explains how to file.
  4. Report waste. The office runs an investigation process for suspected wasteful spending, and the (212) NO-WASTE line is the way in.
  5. Ask for records. FOIL requests to the office follow the process in the city's guidance.

For the office's profile and the other money-related offices, see The City Comptroller and Budget and finance.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic