Blog

Yankee Stadium: two ballparks compared

The original Yankee Stadium served the team from 1923 to 2008; the new one opened in April 2009 beside the 161 St station and Metro-North's Yankees stop.

There have been two Yankee Stadiums, and the Bronx has been the home of both. The first served the team from 1923 through the 2008 season. The second opened in April 2009, and it has stood in the same borough, beside the same subway stop, ever since. That is a short sentence for a long run: eighty-six seasons in the old building, and, counting 2026, eighteen in the new one.

This piece puts the two side by side, using the dates the team and the league publish, and sets them in the neighborhood and the transit system that serve them.

The numbers on the calendar

Start with the dates.

Original Yankee Stadium New Yankee Stadium
Years in use 1923 to 2008 2009 on
Seasons through 2026 86 18
Opening 1923 Workout day April 2, 2009; first regular-season game April 16, 2009
Borough The Bronx The Bronx

The seasons count is simple arithmetic. From 1923 through 2008, inclusive, is 86 seasons. From 2009 through 2026, inclusive, is 18. The old stadium therefore accounted for the great majority of the club's time in the Bronx, and the new one is already in its second decade. The dates come from the team's ballpark page at mlb.com/yankees/ballpark and from MLB's own stadium guide.

The 2009 opening has a small structure worth noting. The workout day, April 2, came two weeks before the first regular-season game on April 16. That is how a new ballpark is usually introduced: the team and the staff get a day to try the place before the games count.

The ground

Yankee Stadium sits in the south Bronx, along the Grand Concourse. The Bronx is a borough with its own history. It became its own county on January 1, 1914, and it is Bronx County in New York State, which makes it a county as well as a borough. The Census Bureau counted 1,472,654 people there in 2020 and estimates 1,406,332 as of July 2025. the five boroughs and their counties covers the five boroughs.

The Grand Concourse is the borough's main avenue, and the stadium area is described in the Department of City Planning's neighborhood geography as the Concourse and Yankee Stadium area, with ZIP codes 10451, 10452 and 10456. The Concourse and Yankee Stadium area is the profile, and The Grand Concourse and Yankee Stadium walks the avenue and the ballpark together.

The original and the new stadium stood close to each other. That is the main continuity between them. The Mets made a parallel move in the same two seasons, moving from Shea Stadium to Citi Field in 2009, with the new park built beside the old one. Two New York baseball teams opened new ballparks in the same April, and each stayed in its own borough and its own neighborhood. Citi Field and Shea Stadium covers the Queens half.

The 1923 stadium

The original opened in 1923 and served the Yankees for 86 seasons, which is a long life for a stadium in a city that tears down and rebuilds its large buildings on a short cycle.

What can be said safely about it is what the dates say. It was there from 1923, it was in use through 2008, and then the team moved to a new building next to it. The team's own history, on its site, tells the story of the years in between, and the details belong to the team's records. For a view of how the era fits into the larger story of the city, The Harlem Renaissance covers the Harlem of the 1920s, across the river from the stadium, and The Empire State Building opens, 1931 covers the skyline that grew up while the stadium was in use.

The 2009 stadium

The new stadium opened for play in April 2009. The team's guide covers its capacity, seating chart and parking, and those are details that change; the ballpark guide on mlb.com is the place to check.

What a visitor notices first is that it is a modern ballpark in an old neighborhood. It stands beside the 161 St-Yankee Stadium station and across a few blocks from the Grand Concourse, which is how the stadium is placed in the Bronx's street pattern. The stadium's setting is part of its identity, and the borough's fans are part of it too.

Getting there

The transit is the great advantage of the site. The MTA's station data lists:

  • 161 St-Yankee Stadium, served by the B, D and 4. The station sits beside the stadium.
  • Metro-North's Yankees-E 153rd St station, a commuter-rail stop built for the ballpark.

The subway lines are the usual way. The 4 runs along the Lexington Avenue line through Manhattan and up into the Bronx, and the B and D run on the west side. Those lines also connect to the rest of the borough: Fordham Rd is served by the B, D and 4, and Kingsbridge Rd by the B, D and 4, which puts the stadium on the same lines as the Fordham and Bedford Park area. Fordham and Bedford Park covers that neighborhood.

The Metro-North station is the less common route, and it matters for people coming from the suburbs, since the commuter railroad's trains run to and from Grand Central Terminal. All Metro-North trains start or end at Grand Central. Metro-North's Hudson Line in the Bronx covers the railroad's stops in the Bronx. Day trips by Metro-North and the LIRR covers how the commuter lines work.

The subway fare is $3 as of 2026, paid by tapping in. There is no tap out, and the weekly cap is $35 on subway and local bus rides, counted per card or device from the first tap. A home game involves a ride to the Bronx and a ride back, and a few of them fit well inside the cap. Tap and ride: how OMNY works explains the payment, and Riding the subway and buses: fares, OMNY and the weekly cap covers the system.

The arithmetic of a century

Put the two buildings on one line and the proportions stand out. From 1923 through 2026 is 104 seasons. The original stadium covers 86 of them, or about 83 percent, and the new one covers 18, or about 17 percent. If the pattern of a long-lived ballpark holds, the new stadium has most of its life ahead of it.

The borough's own dates frame the story. The Bronx became its own county on January 1, 1914, nine years before the original stadium opened, and the city's five-borough consolidation, on January 1, 1898, came 25 years before that. 1898: the five boroughs consolidate tells the consolidation story. So the ballpark's whole history sits inside the modern borough: the Bronx existed as a county before the first game was played there.

The neighborhood by transit

A reader who wants the map in a sentence can have it: the Concourse and Yankee Stadium area runs along the Grand Concourse in the south Bronx, with the 161 St-Yankee Stadium station on the B, D and 4 beside the ballpark and the Metro-North Yankees-E 153rd St station on the commuter railroad. That pairing of a subway stop and a rail stop is rare among American stadiums, and it is why the ballpark can draw from Manhattan, the rest of the Bronx and the northern suburbs without anyone driving. The Department of Transportation and the MTA publish the current routes and service changes, and the team's ballpark page lists the entrances.

What changed between the two

The difference between the two stadiums is partly about the era and partly about the business. A stadium built in 1923 was designed for a different crowd and a different economy of the game. The 2009 stadium was built when ballparks had become year-round commercial enterprises, with restaurants, shops and corporate spaces. That is a general feature of the period, and it applies to Citi Field and to the other ballparks built around the same time.

What did not change is the location. The team stayed in the Bronx, close to the old site, and the neighborhood stayed its neighborhood. That continuity is the reason fans think of the two buildings as one place, and it is a theme in the other New York stadium stories: the Knicks and Rangers at Madison Square Garden, which opened in its current form on February 11, 1968 as the fourth building to carry the name (Madison Square Garden: the fourth building), and the Nets at Barclays Center, which opened on September 28, 2012 (Barclays Center and Brooklyn basketball).

The borough's other green

A day in the Bronx need not be limited to the ballpark. The borough has the city's largest park, Pelham Bay Park, at 2,771.75 acres, and Van Cortlandt Park at 1,146.43 acres. The Bronx's only beach, Orchard Beach, is in Pelham Bay Park. Pelham Bay Park and Orchard Beach, Van Cortlandt Park and the Bronx's green edge and A day in the Bronx: Yankee Stadium, Wave Hill and Orchard Beach cover them. Wave Hill, a 28-acre public garden in Riverdale, is reached by the Metro-North Riverdale station. Wave Hill and Riverdale covers it.

For a visitor, a baseball game and a park are two different Bronx days, and the transit map keeps them separate: the stadium is on the B, D and 4, and Pelham Bay Park is at the end of the 6.

If you are going

A few practical points hold for any ballpark day.

  1. Check the schedule on the team's site. Baseball runs a long season.
  2. Choose your route. The B, D and 4 stop beside the ballpark. The Metro-North Yankees station is an alternative from the suburbs.
  3. Check the MTA's alerts for the day. Weekend work is common.
  4. Leave time. Crowds leave all at once, and the station will be busy.
  5. Know the neighbors. The Concourse is an avenue with its own life, and the area around the stadium is worth a walk.

The ballpark guide at mlb.com/yankees/ballpark has the current details on seating and entry. The Yankees topic page on 4NYCity collects the team's other pieces, and The sports road trip: New Jersey and Long Island venues covers the region's other stadiums.

Two buildings, one address

The best summary of the comparison is that it is a story of staying put. In a city where teams and arenas move, the Yankees built a second stadium beside the first. The first served 86 seasons and the second has served 18. Both belong to the Bronx, and both are reached by the same lines.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic