Blog
Before 1609: the Lenape and Lenapehoking
The Munsee-speaking Lenape homeland of Lenapehoking, the meaning of Manahatta as hilly island, and the Manhattan, Canarsee, Hackensack and Rockaway peoples.
Every history of New York City that begins in 1609 begins late. When Henry Hudson, sailing for the Netherlands, put a party ashore to explore Manhattan that year, he was arriving in a place that already had people, names, roads and a way of life that had gone on for a very long time. The people were the Lenape, the land was part of a homeland they called Lenapehoking, and much of what New Yorkers take for granted about the geography of their city, from the name Manhattan to the line of Broadway, grows out of that earlier world.
This piece looks at what the city's own records and the National Park Service say about those first inhabitants, and at what is still visible on the map.
A homeland with a name
The National Park Service's timeline of the region opens before the arrival of Europeans, with Lenape people living in Lenapehoking, a homeland that included Manhattan. The Lenape who lived around the lower Hudson River spoke Munsee, one of the languages of the Algonquian family; Munsee is the northern dialect of the Lenape language, and the people who spoke it were Munsee-speaking Lenape. The word Lenapehoking can be read as the Lenape's own name for their land, a region that covers what is now New York City, much of New Jersey and parts of the surrounding states.
The NPS gives the name of Manhattan as a Lenape word, Manahatta, and glosses it as "hilly island." That description fits the island's original shape. Manhattan today looks flat to many visitors because two centuries of building and leveling have smoothed it, but the island was once a landscape of rocky ridges, valleys and streams. The hills are still there in places: Washington Heights, at the island's northern end, retains some of the steepest ground, and its subway stations, the 190th Street station on the A and the 191st Street station on the 1, are the deepest in the system, far below the hilltop streets; see The deepest stations: 190th and 191st Streets.
Other readings of the name exist, and scholars have debated its origins for a long time. The meaning the Park Service gives is the one this page uses, because it is the one tied to the geography.
The peoples named in the city's own list
New York City's own list of important dates, kept by the Department of Citywide Administrative Services in its Green Book, opens by naming the Native peoples who occupied the land before the Dutch. It lists the Manhattan, Canarsee, Hackensack and Rockaway Indians. Those four names correspond to places that still exist.
- The Manhattan people lived on the island that bears the name. The island's name is the clearest surviving trace of them.
- The Canarsee lived in the area that is now southern Brooklyn. The name survives as Canarsie, a neighborhood and a stretch of waterfront on Jamaica Bay.
- The Hackensack lived in the area across the Hudson in what is now New Jersey. The name survives in the Hackensack River and in the city of Hackensack.
- The Rockaway lived on the peninsula now called the Rockaways, in Queens. The name is the same one the peninsula carries today; see Rockaway Beach from Beach 3rd to Beach 153rd and The Rockaways.
These were not separate nations in the way modern states are; they were related communities of Lenape speakers, each tied to a stretch of land and water, who traded, intermarried and shared a language. The Dutch and English who followed often named each group by the place it lived, and those names are how the groups appear in the record.
Living on the land
The Lenape lived in a rhythm set by the seasons, and the geography of the region made it a rich place to live. The estuary where the Hudson meets the Atlantic is full of fish and shellfish, and oysters were so abundant in the harbor that they remained a staple of the city's food for centuries after. The woods held deer, turkeys and other game. The Lenape also farmed; corn, beans and squash were the main crops in the region, planted in the warm months. A community might move between fishing places on the shore in the warmer part of the year and more sheltered inland sites in winter, using what each season offered.
The island's freshwater was a resource too. A large pond in the area that is now lower Manhattan, later called the Collect Pond, served as a water source in the colonial period, and the stream system of the island ran from its hills into the rivers on both sides. Almost all of this water has since been filled, piped or built over, but it left its mark on the street plan and the property lines.
The Lenape also made paths. One trail that ran the length of Manhattan is commonly traced to the line of Broadway, the long diagonal that cuts across the street grid. The story is a standard part of the city's lore, and it explains something visitors notice: Broadway does not obey the grid because it did not begin as part of the grid. It began as a path. How the grid was imposed on top of older features is told in The 1811 Commissioners' Plan and the grid.
1609 and what came after
The Dutch records and the city's list begin the colonial story with Hudson's 1609 landing. Fifteen years later, in 1624 by the Municipal Archives' account, the first Dutch colonists settled at four locations in New Netherland, including Governors Island. By 1625 Nieuw Amsterdam had become the seat of government, and the city's list gives 1626 as the year Peter Minuit, the first Director-General, purchased Manhattan from Native people.
The word "purchased" needs care. The city's own school materials on Native American Heritage Month note that the Lenape likely understood the 1626 transaction differently from the Dutch. The Dutch saw a sale of land; the Lenape, who did not hold land as property in the European sense, may have understood an agreement to share the use of it, with gifts exchanged as part of a relationship. Two parties can sit at the same table, exchange goods and leave with entirely different ideas of what has been agreed. The longer account of this episode is in The 1626 purchase of Manhattan: what the story leaves out.
What followed over the next decades was contact, conflict and displacement. Disease, warfare and the pressure of colonial settlement reduced the Lenape presence on the island, and Lenape communities were forced to move west and north over the following centuries. The city's history is not told in full without that part, and it is part of the school curriculum as well; the Department of Education's social studies materials include it, a subject for NYC Public Schools.
What remains
The Lenape did not disappear, though their homeland was taken. Descendants of the Lenape and related Munsee-speaking people live today in several communities in the United States and Canada, in Oklahoma, Wisconsin and Ontario, among other places. Within the region, people of Lenape descent and their organizations have worked to keep the language and culture alive and to make their history visible in the city.
You can see the older world in the names. Manhattan and Canarsie are Lenape names. So are Rockaway and Hackensack. The island's contours, in the hills of Upper Manhattan and in the bend of Broadway, are older than the city's street plan. The Hudson, the harbor and the East River were routes before they were property.
A short list of places to look
If you want to look for traces of the early history on a day out, a few places make sense.
- Lower Manhattan. The Financial District sits on the southern tip of the island, where the Dutch built their first fort and where the colonial city began. It is also the area where, in the Park Service's and the city's timelines, European settlement started. The National Museum of the American Indian has a New York location at the foot of Broadway, near Bowling Green, in the U.S. Custom House; check the museum's own site for hours. See Financial District.
- Broadway. Walk a stretch of it and notice the angle. The path under the pavement is older than the grid.
- Upper Manhattan. In Washington Heights, the steep streets show the island's original rock and hills. See Washington Heights.
- The Rockaways. The peninsula carries a Lenape name, and its beaches are reached by the A train; see The Rockaways.
- Canarsie. The southern Brooklyn waterfront on Jamaica Bay keeps the name of the people the city's list calls the Canarsee.
Reading the city differently
The five boroughs are usually explained by their counties, their neighborhoods and their transit lines, and the guide to the boroughs on this site, the five boroughs and their counties, does the same. It helps to remember, while reading, that the borough names and the underlying names of places are not all from Europe. Staten Island's Dutch-derived name, Brooklyn's and the Bronx's Dutch roots and Manhattan's Lenape root all sit on the same map.
Henry Hudson's party in 1609 did not find an empty place. It found a landscape that had been lived in and named, and the first page of the city's history, in the National Park Service's account and in the city's own list, is a Lenape one.