Blog

The 1626 purchase of Manhattan: what the story leaves out

The Dutch account of Peter Minuit buying Manhattan in 1626, why the Lenape likely understood the exchange differently, and why the dates vary from 1624 to 1626.

Every New York schoolchild gets the same story, usually with the same punch line. In 1626, a Dutchman named Peter Minuit bought the island of Manhattan from the local Indians for trinkets worth twenty-four dollars. It is a tidy tale, it has a price tag and a villain-or-hero depending on the teller, and it has been repeated so often that it feels like a fact of nature. Almost every clause in it needs a second look.

The city itself has started to give that second look. The Department of Education's own social studies materials for Native American Heritage Month say that the Lenape people likely understood the 1626 transaction differently from the Dutch. That is a plain sentence from a public school system, and it is the right place to start, because it names the problem with the word "purchase." The rest of this piece takes the story apart in order: the date, the buyer, the price, and what the people on the other side of the table would have thought they were agreeing to.

What the Dutch record says

The Dutch West India Company settled the lower Hudson in the 1620s as a trading colony called New Netherland, with its center on the southern tip of Manhattan, which became Nieuw Amsterdam. The city's own list of important dates puts the Dutch landing party under Henry Hudson in 1609, the colony's seat of government in 1625, and Peter Minuit's purchase in 1626. Peter Minuit is described there as the first Director-General of the colony.

The claim that a purchase happened rests, as far as the standard history goes, on a short passage in a letter written in Amsterdam in the autumn of 1626 by a Dutch official reporting the arrival of a ship from the colony. The letter reports that the colonists had bought the island of Manhattes from the native people for goods valued at sixty guilders. That one line is the foundation. There is no deed from the seventeenth century. There is no treaty, no signed page, no map with a boundary drawn on it. If you wanted to prove the sale in a court, the Dutch letter is the evidence, and it is evidence of what the Dutch thought they had done.

The twenty-four dollars comes later. In the 1840s a New York historian converted the sixty guilders into dollars at the exchange rate he used, got a figure around twenty-four, and the number stuck. It was a nineteenth-century calculation about a seventeenth-century coin, and it says nothing about what sixty guilders bought in 1626, when the same sum was a decent amount for a household. The Dutch figure was in guilders. The tale that the island went for "beads and trinkets" is also a later embellishment: the letter speaks of value, not of a pile of glass.

The date is softer than it looks

If you look up when New York was founded, you can find 1624, 1625 and 1626, sometimes in the same book. The reason is not carelessness. It is that the founding of a colony is a process, and the sources describe different stages of it.

  • 1624. The Municipal Archives' guide to the Dutch records places the first colonists in New Netherland in 1624, at four locations including Governors Island.
  • 1625. The city's list of important dates describes Nieuw Amsterdam becoming the seat of government.
  • 1626. The same list dates the purchase to that year.
  • Fort Amsterdam. The city list dates the fort to 1635, while other sources place it earlier. Published accounts of the early years differ by a year or two, anywhere from 1623 to 1626.

None of these is wrong exactly. They are different events. A company ships colonists, sets up a government, builds a defensive work, and records a land transaction, and each of those has its own year. If a plaque or a school poster gives a single date for "the founding," it has picked one.

The man at the center

Minuit was the colony's first Director-General, appointed by the Dutch West India Company. He appears in the record as an administrator, not a legend. In a few years he was recalled, and he went on to lead a Swedish expedition to the Delaware River, which is a footnote that surprises people who know him only as the man who bought Manhattan. What is known about him comes from company records and a handful of letters. His portrait in the popular imagination, the shrewd trader taking advantage of naive natives, is a creation of later retellings, not something the records show.

The people he dealt with were Lenape, specifically Munsee-speaking Lenape groups living in the region the Lenape call Lenapehoking. The Municipal Archives and the National Park Service both note that "Manahatta" is a Lenape word, which the park service glosses as "hilly island." The city's own list names the Manhattan, Canarsee, Hackensack and Rockaway Indians as the peoples on the land when Europeans arrived. For a broader look at them, see Before 1609: the Lenape and Lenapehoking.

What the Lenape likely understood

Here is the heart of the matter, and the reason the school materials phrase the sentence the way they do. In the Dutch legal tradition, a payment for land transfers ownership: the buyer holds the land, the seller does not, and the seller leaves. That is what "purchase" means to a European merchant in 1626.

Lenape practice was built on a different idea. Land was not an object held by one party and handed to another. Groups had the right to use particular places for farming, fishing, hunting and travel, and those rights could be shared. Gifts exchanged at an agreement signaled a relationship, an acknowledgment that two groups would share the ground and respect each other's use of it. On that reading, a payment is not the price of ownership. It is the opening of a relationship, and the people who accepted it would not have thought they were giving up their home. They would have thought they were letting newcomers in.

That is why the city's school materials say "likely understood." The Lenape did not leave a written account of the 1626 meeting. What historians do is work from the record of how Lenape groups treated agreements with Europeans elsewhere, and from the actions afterward, which look like the behavior of people who believed they still had rights on the land. A further complication is that the sellers in the Dutch account may not have been the group that actually lived on the southern tip of the island. A payment to one party is not a sale by every party who used the place.

The sentence that survives the scrutiny, then, is a modest one: the Dutch recorded a payment in 1626, and the Dutch believed it gave them the island. Everything beyond that is interpretation.

How the story got its shape

Every popular version of this tale was shaped by who was telling it and why. In the nineteenth century, when a growing New York was producing its own origin story, the sixty guilders became twenty-four dollars, a number small enough to be funny and large enough to be remembered. A city that had become the financial capital of the country had an obvious reason to enjoy the idea that its original deal was a bargain. Real-estate jokes followed: the story is told in every period of rising prices to show how much the island has gained in value.

The joke obscures what happened next. Dutch rule lasted until 1664, when England took over Nieuw Amsterdam and renamed it New York; the Dutch retook the city briefly in 1673 and ceded it back in 1674. The English later claimed the territory under their own legal theory, and the Lenape were pushed off most of the land they had used over the following decades. The story of the sale makes a clean beginning, but the real history of land in the city is a long sequence of transfers, pressures, wars and disputes, and the sixty guilders is only its first documented entry. For the English side of the story see 1664: the English take New Amsterdam.

Reading the date on a plaque

A practical test for the next time you meet this story, whether on a plaque, in a museum, or in a classroom:

  1. Check what is being claimed. "Bought Manhattan" and "made a payment the Dutch recorded as a purchase" are different statements. Good local histories use the second form.
  2. Check the year. If the text says 1626, it is following the Dutch letter and the city's list of dates. If it says 1624, it is counting the first settlers. If it says 1625, it means the seat of government. All three are defensible.
  3. Check the price. Sixty guilders is the figure in the Dutch record. Twenty-four dollars is a later conversion, and "beads and trinkets" is a later addition.
  4. Check who is speaking. Whether the Lenape voice appears in the account is the best sign of how carefully it was written. Today the city's own education department says the Lenape likely understood the transaction differently, which is an invitation to ask them.

Where to see it today

The place where all this happened is the Financial District, where Nieuw Amsterdam stood and where the streets still bend to the old shoreline. The neighborhood's modern profile is in Financial District, and the story of the district as the city's first landing point is told in The Financial District, where New York began. Walk down Whitehall Street toward the water, past the ferry terminal, and you are standing roughly where the colony's first buildings were. The ferry itself, the free Staten Island run, ends at the same spot, a subject covered in The Staten Island Ferry: a free commute.

The city's school system publishes materials on Lenape history and heritage, and the Municipal Archives hold the Dutch-era records in translation. Those are the places to go if the 1626 story is the start of a longer project. They are more useful than the old punch line, because they let a reader do what the twenty-four-dollar version never does: ask who was on the other side of the table, and what they thought was going on.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic