Blog
Flash flood versus coastal flood: watches and warnings
Seven myths about New York flood alerts, answered from NYC Emergency Management: watches versus warnings, flash versus coastal floods, flood zones.
The phone buzzes in the middle of a thunderstorm and the screen says "Flash Flood Warning." A day earlier, on a calm morning, it said "Coastal Flood Watch." Two alerts, two words each, and most people could not say which one is worse. New York gets both, in different weather and for different reasons, and the difference between them is the kind of thing worth knowing before the phone goes off.
NYC Emergency Management keeps a "Plan for Hazards" page on flooding, and it is unusually clear about the vocabulary. What follows takes the common misunderstandings one at a time, the way a good Metro desk would run a correction box: here is what people say, here is what the city says.
Myth 1: A watch means flooding has started
What the city says. A watch means flooding is possible, not underway. The city's definitions are precise.
- A Flash Flood Watch is issued to indicate current or developing hydrologic conditions that are favorable for flash flooding in and close to the watch area, but the occurrence is neither certain nor imminent.
- A Flash Flood Warning is issued to inform the public, emergency management and other agencies that flash flooding is in progress, imminent or highly likely.
- A Coastal Flood Watch is issued by the National Weather Service when coastal flooding is possible within 12 to 36 hours.
- A Coastal Flood Warning is issued by the National Weather Service when coastal flooding is occurring, imminent, or expected within 12 hours.
The pattern is the same for both kinds. A watch is the earlier, looser message: conditions are right, so pay attention. A warning is the later, firmer one: it is happening or about to. The practical rule is to use a watch to prepare and a warning to act. The coastal version comes with clocks attached, 12 to 36 hours for a watch and 12 hours or less for a warning, which gives a household a window to move a car, pack a bag or relocate belongings from a ground floor.
Myth 2: Flash floods and coastal floods are the same thing with different names
What the city says. They have different causes, and that is why the alerts differ.
Flash flooding, the city explains, is caused by thunderstorms and other intense rainstorms. It is the number one cause of deaths associated with thunderstorms, claiming more than 140 lives each year in the United States. The water comes from above, fast, and it can be a problem anywhere rain falls faster than the drains can take it.
Coastal flooding is a different animal. It occurs when intense, offshore low-pressure systems drive ocean water inland. The water pushed ashore is called storm surge. This is a harbor and shoreline problem, and it is the one the evacuation zones exist for. The Hurricane Sandy record, in which the National Hurricane Center measured a storm tide of 14.06 feet at the Battery on October 29, 2012, is the extreme example; see Hurricane Sandy, October 2012: the record.
The shorthand that helps: flash floods come from the sky, coastal floods come from the sea. A downpour over Midtown is a flash flood concern. A surge pushed into the harbor is a coastal one.
Myth 3: Minor coastal flooding is a big deal
What the city says. The scale runs from minor to major, and it is tied to how far the water rises above the normal tide.
- Minor flooding is nuisance coastal flooding of locations adjacent to the shore, with minor beach erosion. It is not expected to close roads or cause any major structural damage to homes and other buildings.
- Moderate flooding is more substantial, threatening life and property. Some roads may become impassable, with moderate beach erosion and damage to some homes, businesses and other facilities.
- Major flooding is a serious threat to both life and property. Numerous roads will likely flood and many homes and businesses along the coast will receive major damage. People should review safety precautions and prepare to evacuate if necessary.
The categories are calculated from the amount the water rises above the normal tide in a particular area. That is worth emphasizing: a given number of feet means different things in different places. The scale is about consequences. Minor means a wet curb; major means evacuation.
There is a related category the city lists: tidal flooding, which occurs when the tide's range is at its highest level, also called a spring tide, and which can happen with no storm at all. A sunny day can still bring a flooded street at high tide in a low-lying part of the city.
Myth 4: Flooding only happens near the water
What the city says. Everyone is susceptible. The page states it plainly: floods can come from storms, water main breaks or sewer backups, and flash flooding from a thunderstorm does not care how far you are from the harbor.
The city's own list of causes goes beyond weather. Blocked catch basins, storm drains, water main breaks and sewer lines can also lead to flooding. So can surcharged sewers, also known as sewer backups. The important health point about backups is that sewage is carried in different pipes than those for drinking or washing water, and floodwater from a backup can pose serious health risks.
This is why the Department of Environmental Protection is part of the story. The department says it offers residents and business owners methods to reduce flooding, and it describes a specific one: if your property has a driveway that slopes below street level, the city recommends contacting a contractor to help prevent flooding into the basement. For the department, see Department of Environmental Protection; for its meter work, which is a different project, see What DEP's meter upgrade means.
Myth 5: A flood zone is an evacuation zone
What the city says. This is the one the city says in capital letters. Flood zones are used to determine if you have a federal requirement to carry flood insurance and to inform building regulations. The page then adds, in emphasis: residents should not use flood zones to determine the need to evacuate.
New York has two separate maps that people confuse. The hurricane evacuation zones are numbered one through six, and the city may order evacuations starting with zone 1, depending on a storm's track, strength and projected surge. You find your zone at maps.nyc.gov/hurricane, or by calling 311. The flood zones, by contrast, are the insurance and building-code maps, and the city points to floodhelpny.org for them. Check both, and read each for what it is. A longer explanation is in hurricane evacuation zones 1 to 6 and Know your zone: hurricane evacuation Q&A.
Myth 6: Tap water is unsafe in a flood
What the city says. Unless otherwise notified, it is safe to drink tap water in an area with flooding. The risk is the floodwater itself, especially if it comes from a sewer backup. Those are two different things, and the page keeps them apart: the city's water supply is separate from the sewage in the street.
The practical version is a reassurance with a caveat: the tap is not the problem, but standing floodwater is. Do not wade through it, and treat anything it touches as contaminated.
Myth 7: My renters' or homeowner's insurance covers a flood
What the city says. Protection against loss due to floods is not covered under basic property insurance policies. All homeowners, renters and business owners are eligible for flood insurance, and the city refers people to their property or casualty agent or broker and to the National Flood Insurance Program at floodsmart.gov. The line the page uses is short: where it can rain, it can flood.
For a renter in a ground-floor or basement apartment, the practical parts are simple. The city advises that if you live in a basement apartment, you should be prepared to move to a higher floor during periods of heavy rain. Make an itemized list of personal property, think about where you would go if you had to leave and prepare a go bag. How tenants and landlords divide responsibility is covered in Renting in New York City: rent stabilization and the Rent Guidelines Board. These are general points, not advice for any one household.
Where the alerts come from
The alert itself comes from two directions. The National Weather Service's New York, NY forecast office, identified as OKX, issues the watches and warnings for the area; its page is at weather.gov/okx. The city then passes them on. Notify NYC is the city's official, free emergency communication program, and you can join by texting NOTIFYNYC to 692-692, by downloading the free app, or by calling 311 (video relay at 212-639-9675, TTY at 212-504-4115). Messages go out in many formats and in languages including Spanish, Chinese, Russian and Haitian Creole, with American Sign Language video. See How Notify NYC alerts work and The National Weather Service office for New York.
A short version to keep
- A watch says conditions are right. A warning says it is happening or about to.
- Flash floods come from intense rain; coastal floods come from surge pushed in from the sea.
- Minor, moderate and major describe consequences, not just height.
- Flood zones are for insurance. Evacuation zones are for leaving.
- Tap water is safe unless the city says otherwise; floodwater is not.
- Basic insurance does not cover floods.
The city's own guidance on flooding, including the full list of what to do before, during and after, is on the NYC Emergency Management site at nyc.gov/site/em. It is the place to read the current version before the phone buzzes. See also What flooding means in New York for the broader explainer and Emergency preparedness and Notify NYC for building a household plan.