Blog
What flooding means in New York
A checklist of the ways New York floods, from coastal storm surge to a broken water main, with the city's terms, the $1 billion national loss figure and Sandy.
Ask five New Yorkers what flooding means and you will get five different answers. One will say the basement. One will say the subway steps on a bad night. One will say Sandy, and then not say anything else. One will point at a puddle at the corner that has been there since the spring. One will mention a main break that turned a street into a river for an afternoon.
They are all right, and they are not describing the same thing. New York City's Emergency Management agency lists flooding among its hazards, and it separates the kinds. Knowing which kind you are facing is the first useful step, because the warning, the cause and the right response are different for each.
The checklist: five questions to ask
When water is somewhere it should not be, ask these in order.
- Where is the water coming from? Sky, shore, pipe or drain?
- How fast is it rising?
- Is anyone in danger now? If yes, call 911.
- Is it a coastal storm? Then the city may be issuing evacuation orders by zone.
- Who handles it? The answer depends on the source.
The rest of this piece goes through the sources one at a time.
Source one: rain and flash flooding
Heavy rain can overwhelm streets and sewers in a short time. This is the flooding most New Yorkers meet most often. Central Park's normals from NOAA for 1991-2020 show 49.52 inches of precipitation a year, with every month between 3.19 inches in February and 4.60 inches in July. The wettest months are the summer months, June through August, at 4.54, 4.60 and 4.56 inches, and October runs 4.38.
An average is not a storm. The monthly total is what falls in a typical month; a flash flood is what happens when a month's worth of rain falls in an hour or two. Because the city is mostly paved, water runs off quickly and finds the lowest ground: underpasses, basements, subway entrances and low-lying streets.
The National Weather Service forecast office that covers the city, identified as OKX and called "New York, NY", issues the watches and warnings. A watch means conditions favor flooding; a warning means flooding is occurring or about to occur. The distinction between a flash flood watch and a coastal flood warning is covered in flash flood versus coastal flood: watches and warnings.
Source two: coastal flooding and storm surge
The city has a long shoreline, and coastal storms and hurricanes are the most dangerous flooding the city faces. This is where evacuation zones come in. The city has hurricane evacuation zones numbered 1 through 6, and if a storm approaches the city may order evacuations starting with zone 1, depending on the storm's track, strength and projected surge. You can find your zone at https://maps.nyc.gov/hurricane or by calling 311. Note that FEMA flood zones are not evacuation zones: they are different maps for different purposes. The full explanation is in Know your zone: hurricane evacuation Q&A.
The record case is Hurricane Sandy, which struck on October 29, 2012. The city's After Action Report counts 43 New Yorkers killed, and the National Hurricane Center measured a storm tide at the Battery of 14.06 feet above mean lower low water. The numbers are the numbers; the story is told in Hurricane Sandy, October 2012: the record.
The neighborhoods that most associate with the water are the ones on the open shoreline: the Rockaways, which run from Breezy Point to Far Rockaway, and Coney Island, in south Brooklyn. See The Rockaways and Coney Island. The city's zone map is the way to learn the exposure of a specific address.
Source three: a broken water main
Not all floods come from weather. The city's water system, run by the Department of Environmental Protection, delivers water from protected reservoirs upstate through a network of mains under the streets. When a main breaks, the result is a flood on a clear day.
That is a different problem from a storm. There is no warning from the Weather Service, no zone to check and usually no evacuation order. What you do is call 311 or, if there is danger, 911, and stay clear. The Department handles the repair. The department's role is described in Department of Environmental Protection, and its work on the water system, including the upgrade of more than 600,000 automated meter reading devices, is in What DEP's meter upgrade means.
Source four: sewer backup
The third kind of ordinary flooding is a sewer backup. When the sewers cannot carry the volume, in a storm or because of a blockage, water can come up through basement drains and fixtures. It is a problem mostly for people who live in basements and low floors, and it is a problem that a block can share.
The response is to report it, to 311, and to keep clear of the water, which may be contaminated. The practical advice for property owners, such as checking insurance and protecting valuables, is general, and a person with a specific loss should consult their insurer and the city's agencies.
Why the city floods the way it does
Three facts about the place explain most of it.
First, the city is made of islands and shoreline. Every borough meets the water, and the Bronx's Pelham Bay Park alone has a 13-mile saltwater shoreline. When a coastal storm pushes water against a coast, the places that feel it are the low-lying shore neighborhoods.
Second, the city is dense and paved. The 2020 Census counted 29,303.2 people per square mile on 300.45 square miles of land. Very little of that land absorbs rain, so storm water goes into the sewers or onto the street.
Third, the city is old, and so is its infrastructure. Mains and sewers that serve a modern population were laid in different eras, and the Department of Environmental Protection manages the whole system. When one piece fails, the result can be a flood on a dry day.
Floods and the subway
Anyone who rides the subway knows that water is an enemy of the system. The MTA's alerts page is the place to see whether a line is running normally, and in a heavy rain it is worth checking before you leave. Stay out of flooded stations, and do not step into a flooded stairwell; the city and the MTA ask riders to follow instructions from staff.
The wider point is that a flood can strike transit before it strikes your block. A commuter who knows the alternatives, a bus line or a ferry, is better off. The ferries are covered in Ferries: the Staten Island Ferry and NYC Ferry.
Flooding and the neighbors
A flood is also a community event. In a storm, people check on neighbors, especially older residents and people in basement apartments. The city's emergency guidance encourages residents to know their neighbors and to look out for them. That is not a regulation; it is common sense, and in a city of 3.3 million households it is how a lot of problems get solved before an agency arrives.
The city's resources for hazards, in plain terms, are the Emergency Management site, the 311 portal, the Weather Service office and Notify NYC. Keep those four in mind and you have the main channels covered.
The numbers
A few figures put the problem in context.
- More than $1 billion in property losses in the United States each year come from floods, according to the city's Emergency Management agency.
- 43 New Yorkers were killed in Sandy, per the city's After Action Report.
- 14.06 feet above mean lower low water was the storm tide at the Battery during Sandy, per the National Hurricane Center.
- 49.52 inches is the annual precipitation in Central Park, by the 1991-2020 normals.
- Zones 1 through 6 are the city's hurricane evacuation zones.
What to do before a flood
The city's guidance on preparing is on the Emergency Management site, and a few steps are common sense.
- Sign up for Notify NYC. Text NOTIFYNYC to 692-692, use the free app for iOS and Android, or make an account on the Notify NYC site. Alerts also go out in languages including Spanish, Chinese, Russian and Haitian Creole, and in American Sign Language. See How Notify NYC alerts work.
- Know your zone. Look it up by address.
- Know the difference between a watch and a warning. A watch is a heads-up; a warning is action time.
- Never drive or walk through floodwater. It is deeper and faster than it looks.
- Stay out of flooded subway stations and basements.
For a longer guide, see Emergency preparedness and Notify NYC and hurricane evacuation zones 1 to 6.
What to do during a flood
- If someone is in danger, call 911.
- If the problem is a main break, a backup or a street flood, call 311.
- Listen to alerts. The city sends them by text, app and email.
- Move to higher ground if you are in a flood-prone area and told to.
What to do after
Photograph damage, contact your insurer, and keep the receipts. The city's 311 portal at https://portal.311.nyc.gov can direct you to the right agency, and the number is (212) 639-9675 from outside the city.
The point
Flooding in New York is not one thing. It is a storm surge on the Rockaway shore, a downpour on a low street, a main break on a quiet block, a backup in a basement. The first job in any of them is the same: figure out which one it is. The city has terms and tools for each, and a resident who knows the terms is a step ahead when the water comes.