Blog

How the Council reviews land use

Who decides what can be built in New York: the Council's land use role, City Planning's zoning work, the Landmarks Commission and the 2026 charter changes.

Every building in New York City exists because several city bodies agreed it could. A tower on Midtown's avenues, a row of brownstones in Fort Greene, a food hall in an old warehouse in DUMBO and a sidewalk cafe in the Village have all passed through some combination of zoning rules, landmark review, building permits and, in many cases, a vote of the City Council. The system looks tangled from the outside, but its logic is consistent: different bodies answer different questions, and the Council sits at a point where the questions that touch neighborhoods and politics come to a vote.

This is a guide to who decides what. It covers the Council's role in reviewing land use, the Department of City Planning's work on zoning, the Landmarks Preservation Commission's protection of historic buildings, the Department of Buildings' permits, and the places where the 2026 Charter amendments touch each.

Four questions, four bodies

Think of any project as a series of questions.

Question Who answers it
What does the zoning allow on this lot? The zoning resolution, which the Department of City Planning writes and maintains
Can the zoning be changed, or an exception granted? A public review that ends in a vote of the City Council
Is the building or district a landmark? The Landmarks Preservation Commission
May construction begin? The Department of Buildings, through permits

The Council appears in the second row. It is the elected body that decides whether a proposed change to the map or a significant exception goes ahead. The other rows belong to agencies, which run on rules. That division, between the rules in the first, third and fourth rows and the political decision in the second, is the key to the whole system.

City Planning and the zoning resolution

The Department of City Planning, known as DCP, handles land use, zoning and population data for the city. It is also the source of the population estimates cited across city sources. Its most basic product is the zoning resolution, the rulebook that divides the city into districts and says what may be built in each: how tall, how bulky, what uses.

New York was the first American city to adopt a comprehensive zoning resolution. The Board of Estimate and Apportionment adopted it on July 25, 1916. That original document, which is archived by DCP, set the pattern for the rest of the country, and the story is told in the 1916 zoning resolution. Zoning has been amended thousands of times since, but the idea has been constant: general rules, set in advance, rather than a decision on each building.

DCP also supports the City Planning Commission, which reviews applications that would change the zoning map or grant exceptions, and whose decisions on them go on to the Council. For the department's profile, see Planning, zoning and permits.

The Council's role

The City Council is the 51-member body that legislates, negotiates and approves the budget with the mayor, monitors agencies and decides land use. The last item in that list is the subject here.

The Council gained its land-use authority in 1989, when the Board of Estimate was disbanded and its functions were divided between the Council and the Procurement Policy Board. Before that, the board held much of the power to approve changes to land use. After, the Council did. The change is the subject of 1989: the year the Board of Estimate ended.

The mechanism is the Uniform Land Use Review Procedure, known as ULURP, which Charter section 197-c requires for certain actions reviewed by the City Planning Commission. The procedure sets mandated time frames for each step. The participants, according to the city's own descriptions, are the Department of City Planning, the City Planning Commission, the community boards, the borough presidents, the borough boards, the mayor and the City Council. The sequence runs in this order:

  1. Filing and certification. An applicant files with the Department of City Planning, which certifies the application as complete so the clock can start.
  2. Community board review. The community board for the area, one of 59 community districts, considers the application and holds a public hearing. Boards must be consulted on applications to change or vary the zoning resolution, and their position is considered in the final determination.
  3. Borough president review. The borough president reviews and makes a recommendation.
  4. City Planning Commission review. The commission holds its own hearing and votes.
  5. City Council review. The Council's land use committees hold hearings and report to the full Council, which votes.
  6. Mayoral review. The mayor reviews the Council's decision.

The community board and borough president steps are advisory: they give the neighborhood and the borough a formal voice, but the binding decisions come later. Because each step has a time frame set by the Charter, an application cannot sit forever. The Department of City Planning's pages publish the current time frames, and the Council's legislative calendar lists the land-use items before its committees.

A hypothetical walk through

Say a property owner wants to change the zoning on a lot so that a taller residential building can be built. This is a labeled hypothetical, not a real application. The owner files with DCP. The application is certified, and then the local community board hears it. The borough president weighs in. The City Planning Commission holds its hearing and votes. The Council's committees hear it, and the full Council votes at a Stated Meeting. The mayor then reviews the decision. At several of these steps the proposal can be modified. A condition can be added, a height can be reduced, an affordable-housing commitment can be attached. The Council's vote is the one that decides whether the map change is adopted in the form that survived the process.

The practical lesson is that a land use decision is a conversation through a sequence of public bodies. The same project can look different at the end than at the start.

The Landmarks Preservation Commission

Landmark designation answers a different question: should this building or district be protected? The Landmarks Preservation Commission was created in 1965, after the loss of the original Pennsylvania Station, when Mayor Wagner signed the Landmarks Law on April 19, 1965. It is the largest municipal preservation agency in the country. Its portfolio, according to the commission, covers more than 38,000 landmark properties, including 157 historic districts and extensions, 1,470 individual landmarks, 125 interior landmarks and 12 scenic landmarks.

Owners of landmarks and buildings in historic districts generally need the commission's approval before changing the exterior. That is a separate layer from zoning. A lot might allow a tall building under the zoning resolution, and still be protected by landmark rules. The story of how the loss of Penn Station led to the law is in The Landmarks Law and the loss of Penn Station, and the commission's profile is in Landmarks Preservation Commission. Greenwich Village, with its streets of older buildings, is a place where landmark protection shapes what a visitor sees; see Greenwich Village.

The Department of Buildings

The last gate is the Department of Buildings, which handles permits, inspections and codes. Its online system, DOB NOW, is the route for filing. In 2026 the department requires the 2025 Electrical Code for electrical filings, and Local Law 10 of 2026, effective May 3, 2026, changes site safety training. Borough offices hold small-owner pop-up sessions on the first and third Tuesday of the month from 4 to 7 p.m.

The department checks the plans against the zoning and the building code. If the zoning has been changed or an exception granted through the process above, the permit reflects it. If a landmark is involved, the commission's approval is needed first. For the step-by-step process of getting a permit, see How to get a building permit in New York City, and for the department's profile, Department of Buildings.

Four everyday cases

The four bodies show up in different combinations depending on what someone wants to do. These are generic illustrations, not rulings on any real property.

What someone wants to do Where it goes
Add a bathroom inside an apartment A building permit from the Department of Buildings, filed through DOB NOW
Replace the front facade of a building in a historic district The Landmarks Preservation Commission, then permits
Build taller than the zoning allows A zoning change through the public review that ends in a Council vote, then permits
Open a sidewalk cafe A revocable consent for the use of public space, a subject of one of the 2026 Charter proposals

The table shows why the Council hears relatively few projects compared with the number of buildings in the city. Most work happens within the rules and needs only a permit. The Council's vote is reserved for the cases where someone asks the city to change the rules for a particular place. That makes each vote a public decision about a particular neighborhood, and it is the reason community boards, borough presidents and neighbors pay attention to the earlier steps.

What the Council does not decide

It helps to know the limits. The Council does not issue building permits, which belong to the Department of Buildings. It does not designate landmarks, which is the Landmarks Preservation Commission's job. It does not write the day-to-day zoning text for every lot; the zoning resolution already does that, and changes to it follow the review procedure above. And the Council cannot change state law, which is why some questions require a home rule request to Albany, a mechanism described in How a bill becomes a local law in New York City.

What the Council does control is the point where the city's general rules meet a specific place: the vote that changes the map, grants the special permission or approves the disposition of city property. That is the narrow, powerful position it inherited in 1989.

The 2026 charter amendments

On November 3, 2026, voters decided five Charter amendments proposed by the Commission on Government Efficiency. Several touch the world of land use and permitting:

  • Revocable consents for public space and sidewalk cafes. A revocable consent is a city permission to use public space, such as the sidewalk, for a private purpose. According to NYC Votes, the revocable-consent change would take effect March 1, 2027.
  • Street-safety projects.
  • City-owned property and building permits.
  • Contractor paperwork and Procurement Policy Board meetings.
  • The rainy-day reserve.

Press reports say voters approved all five in unofficial results, and certification was not confirmed on an official page, so the outcome should be treated as provisional. The proposals are explained in Five charter questions on the November 2026 ballot, and the sidewalk cafe piece in particular in revocable consents: how the city lets you use the sidewalk.

Following a case yourself

Residents who want to follow a land use application can watch several places. The Council's legislative calendar at legistar.council.nyc.gov lists land-use items and hearings. Community boards post their agendas, and a board's land use committee is where most neighbors first hear about a project. The Department of City Planning's site shows applications under review, and the Landmarks Preservation Commission posts its calendar of public hearings. The structure of the Council itself is in The New York City Council, and the way bills move is in How a bill becomes a local law in New York City.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic