Blog

The 1916 zoning resolution

New York adopted the nation's first comprehensive zoning rules on July 25, 1916; how they shaped Midtown's stepped skyscrapers and what replaced them.

Look at the Empire State Building and you are looking at a legal document. The tower rises in steps, wide at the base and narrowing as it climbs, until a slim shaft carries the mooring mast into the sky. The shape was not purely a matter of taste. It is what the law allowed. On July 25, 1916, the Board of Estimate and Apportionment adopted New York City's first comprehensive zoning resolution, the first set of rules of its kind in the United States, and for the next forty-five years it determined how high buildings could go, how much of a lot they could cover and what they could be used for.

The Department of City Planning keeps the 1916 text online as a historical document, and describes it as the first comprehensive zoning resolution in the country. This explainer covers why the city wrote it, what it did and how it shaped the skyline.

Why the city wrote rules

Before 1916, a New York landowner could build what he liked, as high as he liked, subject to the building code's rules about fire safety and structure. The consequences were becoming clear. As steel-frame construction made tall buildings possible, towers rose on narrow lots and blocked light and air from the streets and from their neighbors. Manufacturing lofts crowded into districts where shops and homes were. Property owners and merchants complained that the arrival of a factory could ruin a block overnight.

One building is often given as the reason. The Equitable Building, an enormous office block completed in 1915 in Lower Manhattan, rose straight up from the street and cast a long shadow over its neighbors. Commonly told accounts say that it provoked the zoning rules. Historians have debated that story, and the better-supported view is that a broader movement for regulation was already under way and would have produced rules without the building. Either way, the Equitable stands as a symbol of what the rules were meant to prevent.

The people pushing for regulation included civic reformers and property owners, notably merchants on Fifth Avenue who feared that garment factories moving north from lower Manhattan would drive away their customers. A commission set up by the Board of Estimate and Apportionment studied the problem and drafted the rules, and the Board adopted them in 1916.

What the resolution did

The 1916 resolution regulated three things at once: use, height and area. That combination is what made it comprehensive.

Use

The resolution divided the city into use districts. Residential districts kept out most business and industry; business districts allowed shops and offices; unrestricted districts allowed anything. The rules did not freeze the city, since districts could be changed, but they gave owners of homes and shops some assurance about what could be built next door.

Height and setbacks

The most visible innovation was the control of height by setback. A building's walls could rise straight up from the street only to a height tied to the width of the street. Above that height, the building had to step back from the street line at a prescribed angle, so that the upper floors receded and light could reach the street. A tower was allowed above the setbacks, but only if it covered a limited share of the lot, about a quarter in the commonly stated rule.

The result was the stepped, layered profile that defined New York skyscrapers for decades. Architects learned to design to the envelope, sculpting masses that fit inside the allowed shape, and in the 1920s and 1930s the setback tower became a style in itself.

Area

The third element was area. The resolution limited how much of a lot a building could cover, and required open space for light and air, particularly in residential districts. It was a first step toward controlling density, an idea that would grow in later versions of the rules.

A worked example, with hypothetical numbers

Say a lot faces a street that is 100 feet wide, in a district where the rules allowed walls to rise to twice the street width before setting back. The street wall could go up to 200 feet. Above that, the building would have to step back along a sloping line; any tower would have to be limited to a fraction of the lot's area. A builder who wanted more rentable space could stack setbacks, narrowing floor by floor, rather than make a plain box. The arithmetic is illustrative, and the actual multipliers depended on the district assigned to each block, but the principle holds: street width set the base, and the setback rules shaped what rose above it.

The Empire State Building as an example

The Empire State Building, which opened on May 1, 1931, is the best-known building to emerge from this system. Its owners' own figures give its height as 1,454 feet with the antenna. The base rises with a broad footprint along Fifth Avenue; above it the building steps back, and the tower narrows to the mast. The form reflects the setback rules and the economics of the time: a developer wanted as much floor space as the law allowed while keeping the upper floors usable and well lit. See The Empire State Building opens, 1931.

The same logic shaped the Art Deco towers that line Midtown. Walk along Fifth Avenue or around Rockefeller Center and look up at the setbacks in the facades; they are the 1916 rules written in stone and steel. The area's overall layout is described in Midtown from 34th Street to 59th and Midtown.

What replaced it

The 1916 resolution lasted until the early 1960s. A new Zoning Resolution took effect in December 1961, replacing the setback rules with a system based on floor area ratio, which limits the total floor area a building may have in relation to its lot, and with incentives such as plazas. The change reshaped the skyline again: the slab and the plaza replaced the stepped tower as the typical form of new construction in the following decades.

The zoning rules have been amended many times since 1961. The Department of City Planning, which writes and proposes changes to the Zoning Resolution, and the City Council, which approves them, are the main actors. How the Council handles zoning and land use is a subject for How the Council reviews land use, and the department's role is summarized in Planning, zoning and permits. Building permits and inspections, which enforce the rules at the level of an individual building, are the work of the Department of Buildings; see Department of Buildings and the step-by-step guide at How to get a building permit in New York City.

Four terms worth knowing

Zoning has its own vocabulary, and a few words from 1916 and after cover most of what a resident needs.

Term What it means
Use district The zone that says whether a block may hold homes, shops, offices or factories
Setback The distance a building's upper floors must step back from the street line
Floor area ratio The 1961 measure of total floor area compared with lot size, which replaced the setback envelope as the main limit
Special district A zone with its own rules layered over the basic ones, used for areas with unusual needs

The first two are the legacy of 1916. The third is the legacy of 1961. The fourth grew out of later decades, when planners found that a single citywide formula could not fit every neighborhood.

Looking up a lot

Anyone who wants to know what the rules say about a particular address can start with the Department of City Planning's website, which publishes the Zoning Resolution and a map that shows the district for each lot. The Department of Buildings' pages show permits and violations for a building, and the permit guide on this site walks through the process. For a house or an apartment, the rules in force when the building went up may differ from today's, so a long-standing building can be larger than the current rules would allow. That is a normal feature of zoning, and it is why a block can have a mix of heights that look unplanned: each building followed the law of its day.

Zoning and landmarks

The 1916 resolution came before another major tool for shaping the city, the Landmarks Law. The Landmarks Preservation Commission was created in 1965 after the loss of the original Pennsylvania Station, and it protects individual buildings and historic districts by a separate process from zoning. Zoning says what may be built on a lot; landmarking says what may be altered or demolished. Together they decide a great deal about the look of a block. The Commission's page lists its work, with more than 38,000 landmark properties in the city, and Landmarks Preservation Commission describes it. The story of the Pennsylvania Station loss is in The Landmarks Law and the loss of Penn Station.

Why it still matters

New Yorkers argue about zoning constantly: whether to allow taller buildings, how much housing to permit, what to do with neighborhoods that want to stay the same and neighborhoods that want to change. The argument is a descendant of the one that produced the 1916 resolution. Supporters of tighter limits say they protect light, air and neighborhood character; supporters of looser ones say they allow the city to grow and house more people. The record shows that the city has switched approaches before, from the setback envelope of 1916 to the floor-area system of 1961, and that each system produced a recognizable kind of building.

If you want to see the 1916 rules at work, take the subway to Midtown, walk Fifth Avenue between 34th and 59th Streets, and look at the upper floors. Or read the original: the Department of City Planning makes the 1916 resolution available as a PDF on its website, a short document that changed the shape of the city. For a buyer or owner, the zoning of a particular lot is the first thing to look up, and the guide to buying property, Buying property in New York City: taxes, records and who to check, explains where to start.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic