Blog

1664: the English take New Amsterdam

How an English fleet turned New Amsterdam into New York in 1664, why sources give two dates for the surrender, and the Dutch return of 1673 to 1674.

The name New York is a political fact before it is a place name. For the first forty years of European settlement the town at the tip of Manhattan was called Nieuw Amsterdam, the capital of a Dutch colony called New Netherland, and the people who lived in it were mostly Dutch speakers governed by a Director-General answerable to a trading company in the Netherlands. In 1664 that ended, almost without a battle. England took the town, renamed it New York, and began a rule that lasted, with one brief interruption, until the American Revolution.

The date of the change is one of those facts that looks simple and is not. The National Park Service gives August 26, 1664 for the surrender. The Municipal Archives of the City of New York gives September 8, 1664. Both agree on the year and on what happened. This piece lays out the story of 1664, the differing dates, the terms of the change, and the Dutch return of 1673 to 1674 that nearly reversed it.

The town the English wanted

By the 1660s New Amsterdam was a modest port. The Dutch West India Company's colonists had settled four locations in New Netherland in 1624, according to a Municipal Archives guide, including Governors Island, and Nieuw Amsterdam became the seat of government in 1625. A year later, in 1626, Peter Minuit, the first Director-General, made the land transaction by which the Dutch said they had purchased Manhattan from Native people; the way the Lenape likely understood that transaction is discussed in The 1626 purchase of Manhattan: what the story leaves out and Before 1609: the Lenape and Lenapehoking. The city's own list of dates puts Fort Amsterdam in 1635, while other sources date it earlier.

What mattered about the place to its rivals was its position. The harbor was deep and sheltered, the Hudson River gave access to the interior and its fur trade, and the island sat between England's New England colonies to the north and its southern colonies to the south. A Dutch town in the middle of that coast was an obstacle to English control of North America's Atlantic seaboard. England and the Netherlands were commercial and naval rivals in this era, and both governments were watching the other's colonies.

The takeover

In 1664, an English force arrived in the harbor and demanded the town's surrender. The expedition was ordered by the Duke of York, the king's brother, who had been granted the territory and meant to claim it. The Dutch Director-General, Peter Stuyvesant, was reluctant to give up the colony, but he had little to defend it with. The town's fort was weak, its garrison was small, and many of the colonists, who were traders and farmers rather than soldiers, saw little reason to fight a larger force over a company's colony. After a short standoff, the Dutch surrendered, and the town changed hands with no major fighting.

That is the reason the takeover is often described as bloodless. The English agreed to terms that let Dutch residents keep their property, their churches and, to a considerable degree, their way of life, and most of them stayed. The population of the town did not turn over; its government did.

The renaming

The English renamed the colony and the town New York, in honor of the Duke of York. The change of name carried a message. A colony that had been a Dutch company's possession became a proprietary colony of an English royal prince, and in time a royal colony of the Crown. The town on Manhattan, the largest settlement in the territory, took the name that the whole province bore. For the Dutch-speaking residents, the new name was a reminder of who held power; for the English, it was a claim that the place had always been theirs to name.

Why two dates

The Park Service's account of New Netherland puts the surrender on August 26, 1664. The Municipal Archives' guide to the Dutch records of New Amsterdam gives September 8, 1664. The Library of Congress catalogs related records of the event as well. Both dates fall in the late summer of the same year, and the sequence of events is not in dispute: an English fleet appeared, the Dutch town yielded, and the colony took a new name.

For a reader, the safe way to write it is the one the sources suggest: the English took New Amsterdam in the late summer of 1664, with the surrender dated August 26 by the National Park Service and September 8 by the Municipal Archives. A careful account names both.

What changed and what did not

The change in flag brought changes in law and government, and the town's institutions were reshaped over the following decades. Under English rule the city got an English-style municipal government, with a mayor and aldermen in place of the Dutch officials, and later a charter that defined the city's rights. This is the root of the arrangement described in How New York City government works: a corporation with a mayor and a council, whose powers have shifted over the centuries but whose structure has an unbroken line back to this period. The modern Council, with its 51 members, is the descendant of those early boards of aldermen, a subject covered in The New York City Council.

Other things stayed. Dutch continued to be spoken in homes, churches and shops for many years, and families of Dutch descent remained prominent in the city's life. Dutch place names, Dutch words and Dutch building habits stayed on the map. The word stoop, which Dictionary.com dates to 1670 to 1680 and traces to Dutch stoep, entered English in just this period; see Stoop: a Dutch word on New York streets. The names Brooklyn, Harlem and the Bowery are Dutch in origin too.

The street plan of the lower island also stayed. The crooked lanes of the Financial District follow property lines and paths from the Dutch town. Wall Street takes its name from a wall of the Dutch period. Financial District describes the part of the city that sits on the original settlement.

The Dutch return, 1673 to 1674

The change of 1664 was not final. England and the Netherlands went to war again in the early 1670s, and in 1673 a Dutch force retook the city. The Dutch renamed it Nieuw Orange, after the House of Orange, and for a short time the town was Dutch again. The recapture was brief. In 1674, under the peace settlement that ended the war, the Netherlands ceded the colony back to England, and the town became New York once more. This time the English held it for the next century.

The episode matters for two reasons. First, it shows how fragile the 1664 takeover was: a naval power with an interest in the harbor could retake it, and an island city with few defenses was always vulnerable to a fleet. That vulnerability was a theme of the city's history through the Revolutionary War and beyond. Second, it fixed the name. A city that had been renamed twice in ten years went on being New York, and the name outlasted the empire that gave it.

Who lived through the change

A colony's population is more than its officials. New Amsterdam in 1664 held Dutch merchants and farmers, other Europeans who had come to trade or settle, Native people from the surrounding region, and enslaved Africans whom the Dutch West India Company had brought to work in the colony. The change of flag did not free anyone. Slavery continued under English rule and grew in the decades after, and it remained legal in New York until the state's gradual abolition began in 1799, a subject taken up in Slavery in New York: the laws of 1799 and 1827. The takeover is usually told as a story between two European powers, and it is worth remembering that for many of the people in the town it changed their master's language and little else.

Walking the Dutch town today

The area that was New Amsterdam is easy to reach, and the street pattern still hints at the settlement. Take the 4 or 5 to Bowling Green or the R or W to Whitehall Street, and you are within a few minutes' walk of the southern tip of Manhattan, where the Staten Island Ferry's Whitehall Terminal sits. Walk north from there and notice how the streets bend and meet at angles, in contrast to the grid that begins above 14th Street; the grid's own story is in The 1811 Commissioners' Plan and the grid. The Financial District's station list includes Fulton St, Wall St, Broad St and Bowling Green, and each one puts you in a different corner of the colonial town.

Dates at a glance

Year Event
1609 Henry Hudson, sailing for the Netherlands, lands a party to explore Manhattan
1624 First Dutch colonists settle at four locations in New Netherland, per a Municipal Archives guide
1625 Nieuw Amsterdam becomes seat of government
1626 Peter Minuit's transaction with Native people
1664 England takes the town and renames it New York (August 26 per the Park Service, September 8 per the Municipal Archives)
1673 Dutch recapture; the city is renamed Nieuw Orange
1674 The Dutch cede the colony to England; the name New York returns

Why it still matters

The English takeover of 1664 is the point at which the city's story turns from a Dutch trading post to an English-speaking province, and it is also the point at which the city's population began to be defined by newcomers who kept arriving under new rulers. The Dutch residents who stayed became part of an English colony, and the city that grew from there went on absorbing people from many places. A century later, in August 1776, the same harbor would be the scene of the Battle of Brooklyn; see The Battle of Brooklyn, August 1776 and New York in the Revolution, 1765 to 1783.

If you want to see the Dutch town's footprint, walk the southern tip of Manhattan: Bowling Green, Whitehall, the line of Wall Street. The street names and angles are the record of that era, and the guide to the boroughs, the five boroughs and their counties, explains how the larger city grew out from there.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic