Blog

The draft riots of July 1863

The four days of July 13 to 16, 1863, when anger over the Civil War draft turned to mob violence, and why the death toll is given as 105 and as 100 to 120.

New York has had many bad days, and the worst of its civil disorders lasted four. From Monday, July 13, to Thursday, July 16, 1863, crowds in Manhattan attacked draft offices, the homes of officials, Black New Yorkers and the property of people they blamed for the war. By the time it was over, roughly a hundred people were dead and much of a city's confidence was gone.

This is a plain account of what happened, what is known and why even the death toll has two numbers.

The setting: a war and a draft

The city in the summer of 1863 was a Northern port with a large immigrant population and a deep economic stake in the war. The Union Army needed soldiers, and in 1863 Congress passed a law authorizing a draft, the first national conscription in the country. Names were drawn by lottery. A man whose name was drawn could serve, hire a substitute, or, under a provision that infuriated many working families, pay a fee of $300 to be excused.

The fee is the key to the anger. For a laborer, $300 was far beyond reach, and for a wealthy man it was affordable. The draft therefore fell most heavily on those who could least avoid it, and in the working-class neighborhoods of the city that fact was not lost on anyone. Resentment of the war, of the draft, and of the people blamed for both, including abolitionists and Black New Yorkers, was already present.

What matters for the city is that the draft was about to be applied in New York and that it was greeted with fury.

July 13: the lottery and the riot

The drawing of names began in the city in the summer, and on Monday, July 13, 1863, the crowd turned violent. The city's Municipal Archives and the Library of Congress both place the riots on July 13 to 16, and the dates are not in dispute. What began as an attack on the draft office became something much larger. Crowds spread through the city, burning buildings, attacking police and targeting Black residents.

The violence was not confined to one place. It moved across Manhattan over four days, and it overwhelmed the police. The scale of the disorder was such that federal troops, some of them newly returned from the war's other fronts, were brought into the city to restore order. The riots ended after the troops arrived and the crowds were dispersed.

The targets

The riots were not only an attack on the draft. The mob's targets included Black New Yorkers, who were beaten, killed and driven from their homes and workplaces, and institutions associated with them. The destruction of the Colored Orphan Asylum on Fifth Avenue is one of the best-remembered episodes. The riots drove many Black residents out of parts of the city, and the memory of the violence shaped the community's history for years.

This is the part of the story that most needs to be told plainly. The draft riots are sometimes described as a protest that got out of hand. The record shows something more specific: a mob that turned its anger on a minority population, and a city that had to be rescued by soldiers.

The toll: 105 or 100 to 120

Now to the number. The Library of Congress says 105 people were killed. The New York City Department of Records, which holds the Municipal Archives, gives a commonly cited death toll of 100 to 120. They are not contradicting each other so much as describing a count that cannot be fixed to the digit.

Why would a toll like this be hard to fix? The nature of the event suggests several reasons.

  • The disorder lasted four days across a large city. Casualties were recorded in many places and by many hands.
  • Victims were not always identified at once. In the chaos of a four-day riot, the dead were not always named.
  • Records of the period were not uniform. Lists compiled afterward can draw on police, hospital, press and family accounts, and such sources do not always agree.
  • Some injuries lead to later deaths. A person wounded on July 14 who died a week later may or may not appear in a count made on July 16.

So the honest way to state the toll is a range, with the commonly cited figure and the Library of Congress's number side by side. A historian who writes 105 and one who writes "100 to 120" are reading the same record. The lesson for a reader is that a precise-looking number is often an estimate, and that the difference between 105 and a range is not a disagreement about whether the riots were deadly.

What the riots did to the city

The immediate aftermath was a reckoning with the damage and the dead. The violence left lasting marks on the city's neighborhoods and on its Black community, and it changed how the city thought about order. The scale of the disorder, and the need for federal soldiers, made it a defining event of the war years in New York.

The long-term story belongs to a larger study of the city in the Civil War. What can be said here is that the riots became a reference point, a day the city measured later disorders against. They are part of the record that anyone who wants to understand the city's history should read, alongside its better-known episodes such as the building of Central Park in the same decade, which began in 1858 and took years. See How Central Park was made, 1853 to 1858.

How the city remembers it

Remembrance of the riots is a matter of public history. The Municipal Archives hold collection guides for the period, and the Library of Congress hosts materials on the Civil War. The city's institutions and historians have kept the subject alive, and the anniversary in July is an occasion for lectures and articles.

The riots belong with the city's other anniversaries and memorials. Other days of memory include the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire of March 25, 1911, which killed 146 garment workers, and September 11, 2001. See The Triangle Shirtwaist fire, 1911 and september 11, 2001 and the memorial. Each marks a day when the city was tested and its people had to respond.

Slavery in the city

The riots took place in a city that had a long, direct history with slavery. In the state, a law of 1799 began the gradual abolition of slavery, and a law of 1817 set July 4, 1827 as the date on which people born before July 4, 1799 became free. That history, which stretches into the decades before the Civil War, is told in Slavery in New York: the laws of 1799 and 1827. It is part of the background to 1863: the city's Black population had lived under that law and its aftermath for generations, and the riots fell on communities with deep roots.

The politics, fairly told

It would be wrong to flatten the story into one cause. People joined the crowds for different reasons: anger at the draft, fear of competition for work, resentment of the war and, as the record shows, outright racial hatred. Others in the city, including many working-class New Yorkers, did not take part, and some risked themselves to help victims. The disorder was not the whole city's act.

At the same time, the war was a cause that many New Yorkers supported, and the draft was a national policy, not a local one. The city's leaders, the police and the federal government each had roles, and each handled the crisis in ways historians still discuss. The responsible way to describe it is to give the facts that the record supports, name the range of motives and avoid assigning to the whole city a character that belonged to a part of it.

How to learn more

A reader who wants to go further has good places to start.

  1. The Municipal Archives hold collection guides and records from the period. The Department of Records and Information Services runs them.
  2. The Library of Congress has materials on the Civil War, including the date range of the riots and the death toll it cites.
  3. The city's own history pages, including the Department of Citywide Administrative Services' list of important dates, put the event in the sweep of New York history.
  4. The local history topic on this site gathers pieces on the city's past; start with New York in the Revolution, 1765 to 1783 and 1898: the five boroughs consolidate.

Why a number matters

A last word on the toll, since it is the part of the story most often misquoted. Writing "105" and writing "100 to 120" are both correct, and a careful reader should know both exist. The Library of Congress gives 105; the Municipal Archives describe a commonly cited 100 to 120. A reader who sees one figure should not assume the other is wrong. And a writer who gives a single exact number as if it were settled is claiming more than the record allows.

The dead were not numbers. They were New Yorkers, many of them Black, killed in their own city in four days in the summer of 1863. The right way to remember them is to state what we know, say how we know it and not claim a precision the record cannot give.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic