Blog
The "first pizzeria" claim and New York-style pizza
Lombardi's calls itself America's first pizzeria, est. 1905. A myth-versus-fact look at what a restaurant's own history can and cannot prove.
Few arguments in New York are as durable, or as cheerfully unwinnable, as the one about who made the first pizza. The city has a view on this, as it has a view on everything, and the view is usually delivered by someone holding a paper plate. The honest version is a little duller and a good deal more useful. A downtown restaurant calls itself America's first pizzeria and gives the year as 1905. That is a sentence in the restaurant's own voice. It is not a ruling. Learning to hear the difference is the whole skill of eating your way through this city's origin stories, and pizza is the best place to practice.
What follows takes the claim apart, myth by myth, and then lines it up with the other foundation stories the city's old food institutions tell about themselves.
What the restaurant says
Lombardi's, on its own website, calls itself "America's First Pizzeria," says it was established in 1905 in New York City, and says Gennaro Lombardi is credited with developing New York-style pizza. Three separate statements are packed into that line, and they do not all stand on the same ground.
The first is the restaurant's description of itself. The second is a date, 1905, which the restaurant gives. The third is a credit to a named founder, and the wording the restaurant uses is that he "is credited with" the development of the style. That is a passive construction, and it is careful. It tells you somebody gives him the credit; it does not tell you who, or on what record.
All of this is the restaurant's account of itself. There is nothing wrong with that, and every old business tells its own story. The thing to note is that the claim is the restaurant's own.
Myth: "It's the first pizzeria in America, full stop"
The sentence as people repeat it at the bar has lost the quotation marks. The restaurant says it is the first. The person repeating it says it is the first. In between, a self-description has become a fact.
The fix is to put the quotation marks back. "Lombardi's calls itself America's first pizzeria" is true and checkable on the restaurant's website. "Lombardi's was America's first pizzeria" is a claim about the entire history of every pizza oven in the country, and it would need evidence about places that may not have left records. A fair reader can say that the restaurant's 1905 date is well known, that it is a long-established New York institution, and that its claim is part of how the city understands its own food history, without asserting a superlative nobody can prove.
Myth: "New York pizza is the way it is because of the water"
You will hear this one at any counter in the five boroughs, usually from someone who has never read a water report. It belongs to the family of explanations that sound right and cannot be tested at a lunch counter. What can be said is what the city's own water agency says about the supply. The Department of Environmental Protection describes New York's drinking water as coming from protected reservoirs upstate and delivered lead-free, with the caveat that some older one-to-four family homes may have private lead plumbing. That is a statement about the water's source and its delivery. It makes no claim about crust, and the claim that tap water explains the pie is a theory without a record behind it.
Treat the water story the way you would treat any food folklore: enjoy it, do not cite it. Lead in NYC water: what DEP says covers what the agency actually says about the supply.
Myth: "There is one New York slice"
The phrase "New York-style" does a lot of work, and what it covers varies from counter to counter. The word the restaurant uses, "development," implies a style that evolved, not a recipe that was invented one afternoon in 1905. Styles evolve in neighborhoods, one customer base at a time. The city has had Italian-American communities for well over a century: the Feast of San Gennaro has been held in Little Italy since 1926, and the Most Precious Blood Church on Baxter Street keeps the saint's statue. The Feast of San Gennaro since 1926 tells that part. A food that grows up in a community of that kind changes as the community does, and what a New Yorker means by a slice today is the product of generations of changes that no single founder fixed.
Fact: the claim is part of a pattern
Lombardi's is not alone in telling a foundation story. Set the city's old food institutions side by side and the same grammar turns up every time:
| Institution | What it says about itself | Where the claim comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Lombardi's | "America's First Pizzeria," est. 1905; Gennaro Lombardi credited with developing New York-style pizza | Its own website |
| Katz's Delicatessen | "NYC's oldest deli," on the Lower East Side since 1888, serving house-cured, hand-carved pastrami and corned beef | Its own website |
| Junior's | "A Brooklyn Original Since 1950" | Its own website |
| The Halal Guys | Three Egyptian founders started a hot dog cart in 1990, then pivoted to halal food for Muslim taxi drivers; "NYC's first Halal food cart" | Its own website |
| Nathan's | "Born and bunned in Coney Island" | Its own website |
Each of those is a statement a business makes about itself. Each is useful, and none is an independent ruling. The cheesecake that Junior's calls a Brooklyn original is a date, 1950, and a place, Brooklyn, with no superlative attached; the deli that calls itself "NYC's oldest" is making the kind of claim that can be tested against other delis' records. The date and the place are the safer parts of any such statement. The superlative, "first" or "oldest," is the part that needs a reader's care.
You can read more about the delis and the cheesecake in Katz's Delicatessen and the Lower East Side deli and Junior's and the Brooklyn cheesecake, about the carts in the halal cart story, and about the hot dog in Nathan's and Coney Island's hot dog. The shared lesson is the same one this entry started with.
Fact: the city's other origin stories are just as slippery
The pizza argument has company in the city's lexicon. The egg cream, a cold drink made with milk, flavoring syrup and soda water, is a good example of a New York original whose origin nobody can pin down; Dictionary.com says the term dates probably from earlier than 1950 to 1955, and notes no source settles who invented it. what is an egg cream? goes through the drink. The word "stoop" is an Americanism that dates to 1670 to 1680, from the Dutch "stoep." And "bodega," in the American sense, is a small independent or family-owned grocery in a dense urban setting, traditionally serving a Hispanic clientele. These are easier to document, because words leave a paper trail that sandwiches do not. Stoop: a Dutch word on New York streets and bodega: the word and the corner store cover the two words.
Reading an origin claim like a reporter
The newsroom habit worth borrowing is the three-question test. Who is saying it? What would they gain from it? And what document would prove or disprove it? Apply it to the pizza claim. The speaker is the restaurant, which gains the standing of being first. The document that would settle it would be an independent record of every pizzeria operating in 1905, anywhere in the country, and nothing like that is on the table. So the claim stays what it is: the restaurant's account, put in the restaurant's words, repeated by a city that likes a good story.
Compare that with a claim that does have documents behind it. The Landmarks Preservation Commission was created in 1965, after the loss of the original Pennsylvania Station, and its own page says so. The Metropolitan Museum of Art was incorporated on April 13, 1870, a date from the museum's history page, and the Museum of Modern Art was created in 1929 by named founders. Those are institutional records with dates that can be checked against charters and press of the time. The difference between those and a pizzeria's slogan is not that one is true and the other false. It is that one kind of claim comes with a paper trail you can follow and the other comes with a tagline. The Landmarks Law and the loss of Penn Station and museum founding years, 1869 to 2015 show what the first kind looks like.
For the visitor, the practical upshot is relaxing. You do not have to settle who was first to enjoy the pizza, and you do not have to be a skeptic to see where a sentence comes from. You only have to notice the verb.
How to talk about pizza and stay out of trouble
A short guide for the dinner table, drawn from everything above:
- Attribute the claim. Say "calls itself" or "says it is." The restaurant's own words are the safe quotation.
- Keep the date and the credit apart. 1905 is the date the restaurant gives; the credit to Gennaro Lombardi is the restaurant's account of who developed the style.
- Do not say "invented." The restaurant's wording is "developing," and that is the more defensible verb.
- Treat superlatives as marketing until proven. "First," "oldest" and "best" are all the same genre.
- Enjoy the slice anyway. None of this affects the quality of what is on the plate.
Why it matters, a little
It is tempting to think a piece about a pizza claim is a trivial thing, but the principle carries. New York runs on claims, and the strongest of them are repeated until they harden into facts: the first, the oldest, the original, the real one. A city that is also the capital of publishing, advertising and the press has more practice than most at turning a self-description into a headline. A reader who can separate "the restaurant says" from "the record shows" is better armed for the rest of it, including the stories about buildings, bridges and neighborhoods in the rest of the blog.
The slice itself is a different matter. It is a civic institution. Whoever got there first, the thin, foldable New York slice is something the city has made its own, and the best way to settle the argument is to buy one at a corner counter and eat it standing up. The restaurant's own site, firstpizza.com, tells the story of the place in its own words, and that is where the claim should be read.