Blog

Museum founding years, 1869 to 2015

New York's big museums in order, from the American Museum of Natural History in 1869 to the Whitney's move downtown in 2015, with what each date marks.

Museums in New York have a way of lying about their ages. A building says 1902 over the door, the institution says 1870 on its letterhead, and the collection began in somebody's rented rooms years before either. Founding years in this city are slippery because the thing being founded keeps changing address. A museum is chartered, then it rents, then it builds, then it builds again, and at each step somebody prints a new date.

So here is the timeline, in order, with the plain dates each institution gives for itself and a note on what each date actually marks. The span runs from 1869, when the Natural History Museum was created by the state legislature, to 2015, when the Whitney opened its building at the foot of the High Line. That is a century and a half of founding, rebuilding and moving.

1869: the American Museum of Natural History

The American Museum of Natural History was founded in 1869 by a special act of the New York State Legislature. That detail is the thing to notice. The museum did not begin as a private club's rooms; it began as a public charter from Albany, which is the way many nineteenth-century New York institutions got their legitimacy. Today the museum describes itself with more than forty permanent exhibition halls and more than thirty million specimens and objects.

It sits on the Upper West Side, facing Central Park West, and the subway names its own station for it: 81 St-Museum of Natural History, served by the B and C. The neighborhood and the museum grew up together, and the story is told in The Upper West Side from Lincoln Center to the Museum of Natural History and more fully in The American Museum of Natural History.

1870: the Metropolitan Museum of Art

The Met was incorporated on April 13, 1870. It opened to the public in the Dodworth Building at 681 Fifth Avenue, a rented commercial building, not the marble palace people picture now. The move to its current place came a decade later: it opened at Fifth Avenue and 82nd Street on March 30, 1880. The Beaux-Arts Fifth Avenue facade and Great Hall opened in December 1902.

That gives the Met three dates people use interchangeably and should not:

  • 1870, the incorporation and first public opening, in rented space;
  • 1880, the opening at the current site on the edge of Central Park;
  • 1902, the grand front and entrance hall that most visitors think of as "the Met."

The full story of that first third-of-a-century is in The Metropolitan Museum from 1870 to 1902. The Cloisters, the Met's medieval branch in Fort Tryon Park in Washington Heights, opened in 1938, and its own profile is in Fort Tryon Park and The Met Cloisters.

1929: the Museum of Modern Art

MoMA was created in 1929 by Lillie P. Bliss, Mary Quinn Sullivan, Abby Aldrich Rockefeller and other original trustees, with Alfred H. Barr, Jr. as its founding director. It is a different kind of founding from the first two. Where the Natural History Museum and the Met were chartered in the post-Civil War years as civic monuments, MoMA was started by a handful of collectors who wanted a place for art the existing museums were not collecting. The date is the date of the idea, and the story of the founding is in MoMA and its 1929 founding.

The year is also the year of the stock-market crash, a fact worth remembering when reading the date: the founders began an institution devoted to the new in the same autumn that the old economy was breaking.

1930 and 1931: the Whitney begins

The Whitney Museum of American Art was founded in 1930 and opened in 1931 on West Eighth Street, in Greenwich Village. That one-year gap, founded in 1930, opened in 1931, is typical: the date on the charter and the date of the first visitors are rarely the same.

The Whitney then moved more than once, which is why its history needs its own piece: The Whitney's three homes. The Marcel Breuer building on Madison Avenue opened in 1966 and housed the museum through October 20, 2014. The current building at 99 Gansevoort Street, in the Meatpacking District at the south end of the High Line, opened May 1, 2015.

1937 and 1959: the Guggenheim, in two dates

The Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation dates to 1937. Frank Lloyd Wright received the commission for the museum building in 1943. The museum opened on October 21, 1959, on Fifth Avenue. The distance between the commission and the opening, sixteen years, is one of the longest in New York museum history. A museum with a founding year of 1937 did not have a building of its own until 1959, and the building that opened then is the spiral still on the avenue. The design and its reception are covered in The Guggenheim and Frank Lloyd Wright.

A reader who sees "1937" at one source and "1959" at another is not looking at a contradiction. One is the foundation's birth and the other is the museum's opening.

2015: the Whitney downtown

The last date in the timeline is the Whitney's May 1, 2015 opening on Gansevoort Street. That is the most recent move by a major museum in the group, and it changed the geography: the Whitney went from the Upper East Side to the far west of the Village, to a site next to the High Line. The High Line itself is a walk worth taking in the same trip, as described in Walking the High Line and West Chelsea's galleries.

One list, in order

Year Institution What the date marks
1869 American Museum of Natural History Founded by act of the state legislature
1870 Metropolitan Museum of Art Incorporated April 13; opens in the Dodworth Building on Fifth Avenue
1880 Metropolitan Museum of Art Opens at Fifth Avenue and 82nd Street on March 30
1902 Metropolitan Museum of Art Beaux-Arts facade and Great Hall open in December
1929 Museum of Modern Art Created by its founding trustees
1930 Whitney Museum of American Art Founded
1931 Whitney Museum of American Art Opens on West Eighth Street
1937 Guggenheim Foundation founded
1938 The Met Cloisters Opens in Fort Tryon Park
1943 Guggenheim Frank Lloyd Wright commissioned
1959 Guggenheim Museum opens October 21
1966 Whitney Museum Breuer building on Madison Avenue opens
2015 Whitney Museum Opens at 99 Gansevoort Street on May 1

The Brooklyn Museum belongs in any list of this kind, but its founding year is not given on its own about page, which describes it as holding more than 140,000 objects across over 6,000 years and calls itself one of the oldest and largest art museums in the country. The museum's own profile is in The Brooklyn Museum.

What the pattern shows

Read down the list and a pattern appears. The two oldest institutions, the Natural History Museum and the Met, were born within a year of each other, in the late 1860s and 1870, when New York was consolidating its position as the country's largest city and wanted institutions to match. They were also arranged around Central Park, whose creation is the subject of How Central Park was made, 1853 to 1858. A park on the island, museums on its edges, and a city that had resolved to be taken seriously.

The twentieth-century foundings come in a different mood. MoMA, the Whitney and the Guggenheim all start in the space of about eight years, 1929 to 1937, and all start as the work of a few people who collected modern art and wanted it shown. They are a generation of private founders where the nineteenth-century pair were civic projects.

Then there is the habit of moving. The Met moved in 1880. The Whitney moved in 1966 and again in 2015. The Guggenheim waited until 1959. When you ask "how old is this museum?", the honest answer is "which date?" The question to ask is whether the date marks a charter, a first opening, the building you are standing in, or the facade you walked through.

Visiting in order

A practical way to use the timeline is to turn it into a route, and the subway makes it easy. The Natural History Museum is the 81st Street stop on the B and C. The Met and the Guggenheim are both on Fifth Avenue on the Upper East Side, a short walk from each other along the park. MoMA is in Midtown. The Whitney is far downtown by the High Line. A combined map of the stops is in museums by subway stop, and for rainy afternoons see a rainy day in the museums. For a comparison of how art museums and science museums differ in what they hold and show, see art museums and science museums compared. Admission prices and hours change, and each museum's own site is the place to check them; Free things to do in New York City lists the city's free options.

The buildings are also part of the story, since several of them are protected under the city's landmarks law, administered by the Landmarks Preservation Commission. The statute under which the commission works dates to 1965, in the wake of the loss of Pennsylvania Station, a history covered in The Landmarks Law and the loss of Penn Station.

Hold on to the years, but hold them loosely. Each one is a record of one decision on one day: a legislature acting in 1869, a board meeting in 1870, a handful of trustees in 1929, a ribbon cutting in 1959, a crowd on a spring morning in 2015. The museums are the places where those decisions turned into rooms.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic