Blog

College sports: St. John's and Columbia

St. John's as a Big East founding member at Carnesecca Arena and the Garden, Columbia in the Ivy League, and where the city's other college teams fit.

New York is a pro-sports town, and everybody knows it. The Yankees and Mets, the Knicks and Nets, the Rangers and Islanders, the Giants and Jets across the river, and now a city that has watched the Knicks win a championship in 2026 for the first time since 1973. Against that noise, college sports in the five boroughs are a quieter thing, a set of teams you find through a campus, a friend or a subway ride. But two programs, one in Queens and one in upper Manhattan, show how different college athletics can look in the same city: St. John's, a founding member of the Big East, and Columbia, an Ivy League school.

St. John's and the Big East

The Red Storm is the athletic name of St. John's University, and its public identity in sports rests on two facts. St. John's is a founding member of the Big East conference. And its men's basketball team plays its home games at two places: Carnesecca Arena, on the school's Queens campus, and Madison Square Garden in Manhattan. Both appear in the university's own athletics coverage, including its note on the men's basketball team opening the 2025 Big East Tournament at the Garden.

The Big East connection matters in New York for a reason that has nothing to do with any one season. Conference tournaments in basketball are major events, and the Big East has long played its postseason tournament at Madison Square Garden. For a St. John's fan, that means the biggest games of the winter happen in the building the city calls the Garden, a short subway ride from the neighborhood where the university's own gym sits. The current Garden, the fourth to carry the name, opened on February 11, 1968, and the whole story of the building is in Madison Square Garden: the fourth building.

Carnesecca Arena is the campus-scale half of the equation. It is the school's home gym, the place where students and neighborhood fans see the team without a Midtown crowd. That two-venue arrangement, one on campus and one in the world's most famous arena, is unusual. It is how a mid-sized campus program in Queens uses the city's biggest stage.

The university sits in the part of Queens that the borough's neighborhood guide describes as central and eastern, served by subway and bus lines that run to Jamaica and beyond. For the borough's transit hub, see Jamaica, Queens: the borough's transit hub and Jamaica, and for Queens generally, The LIRR's Port Washington Branch in Queens explains the commuter rail on the north side of the borough.

Columbia in the Ivy League

Columbia's athletic teams are the Lions, and Columbia is a member of the Ivy League, which the Lions' own site highlights. The Ivy League is an athletic conference of eight universities in the Northeast known for its academic reputation and for a rule that its teams do not offer athletic scholarships. That last point, a matter of league policy, is the thing that most separates an Ivy program from a Big East one in how it recruits and what its games feel like. For the facts of the university itself, Columbia and Morningside Heights is the guide.

Columbia sits in Morningside Heights, between the Upper West Side and Harlem, and the 1 train stops at 116 St-Columbia University. The neighborhood guide lists the station and the surrounding stops, and the area's ZIP codes, 10025 and 10027. The campus is a place of its own on the map of upper Manhattan, and Columbia athletics are part of the neighborhood's weekend rhythm. For more, see Upper West Side, Harlem and A walk along 116th Street in Harlem, which covers the street that runs along the campus.

Two ways to be a college team in New York

Put the two programs side by side and the differences are instructive.

St. John's Red Storm Columbia Lions
Borough Queens Manhattan
Conference Big East (founding member) Ivy League
Men's basketball home Carnesecca Arena and Madison Square Garden See the Lions' own site
Neighborhood feel Outer-borough campus, with the Garden for big nights Upper Manhattan, Morningside Heights

A table like this is a simplification. It leaves out sports other than basketball, and it leaves out the many other colleges in the city. But it reveals a pattern: in New York, a college team's identity is usually tied to a neighborhood and a subway line more than to a stadium in a college town. A fan does not drive to a campus, park in a lot and tailgate. A fan takes the 1 or a bus, and the team is part of the city's ordinary flow.

The other teams on the map

New York's college sports map is wider than two schools.

  • Fordham. The Fordham Rams have an official athletics site, and Fordham is covered in the colleges listings alongside St. John's and Yeshiva. The Rams play in the Bronx, in the Fordham and Bedford Park area of Fordham and Bedford Park.
  • Wagner. The Wagner Seahawks, on Staten Island, also have an official athletics site.
  • CUNY. The City University of New York has 26 campuses and over 250,000 degree-seeking students, and each campus fields its own teams. CUNY was founded in 1847 as the nation's first free public institution of higher education. City University of New York has the profile, CUNY: the first free public college, 1847 tells the founding story, and CUNY campuses by subway stop lists campuses by their stations.
  • NYU. New York University, in Greenwich Village, is also part of the city's collegiate scene; see NYU and Greenwich Village.

Seton Hall, which people sometimes count as a New York team because of its name in the Big East, is in South Orange, New Jersey, and not in the city.

How to actually go to a game

For a fan who has never been, a few practical steps make the difference.

  1. Find the team's own site. The athletics pages list schedules, tickets and promotions, and they are the final word on dates. Schedules change every season, so no printed list is reliable.
  2. Plan the trip by subway. For Columbia, the 1 train to 116 St-Columbia University is the obvious route. For St. John's, check the university's directions for a subway-and-bus trip to its campus. For the Garden, Penn Station, with the 1, 2, 3, A, C and E trains at 34 St-Penn Station, is at the building's doorstep. Riding the subway and buses: fares, OMNY and the weekly cap explains how to pay, and as of 2026 the base fare is $3 with a tap of a contactless card or phone.
  3. Mind the calendar. College basketball runs through winter and into March; football on the Ivy League schedule runs in the fall. Weather in January and February can be harsh, so When New York freezes: the coldest months is worth a look before you commit to an outdoor event.
  4. Expect a smaller crowd and a closer view. One of the pleasures of college sports in a big city is the scale. You can often get a good seat on short notice.

Why college sports matter in a pro town

The best reason to care is that college teams give a neighborhood something of its own. A Knicks game is a citywide event, and a Yankees game is a pilgrimage. A Columbia game is a Saturday on Morningside Heights. A St. John's game at Carnesecca Arena is a night in Queens with the neighbors. The two dates that matter most to the rest of the sports calendar, the Big East Tournament in March at the Garden and the Ivy League's fall football season, are reminders that the college game has its own calendar, running parallel to the pros.

The pros get the headlines. The colleges get the students, the alumni and the neighbors, and in a city of 8.5 million people, that is plenty. For the pro side of the map, Madison Square Garden: the fourth building, The Knicks win the 2026 championship and Barclays Center and Brooklyn basketball pick up where this one leaves off.

A season-by-season view

College sports follow a calendar that is different from the pros', and in New York the weather makes the difference matter.

  • Fall. Football season on the Ivy League schedule belongs to autumn, and Morningside Heights in October is a pleasant place to be. Daytime highs in Central Park average 64.5 degrees in October and 54.0 in November, according to the 1991-2020 normals.
  • Winter. Basketball season runs through the coldest months. January's average high is 39.5 degrees and the average snowfall is 8.8 inches, so a ticket to an indoor game is a reasonable winter plan. The subway keeps running when the weather turns, which is part of the case for a city team over a suburban one.
  • Late winter and March. Conference tournament time. For St. John's and the rest of the Big East, the Garden is the center of the calendar.
  • Spring. Baseball, softball, lacrosse and track fill the weekends. The weather improves, and the campus lawns fill up.

What a student-athlete's city looks like

Playing for a college in New York is different from playing in a college town. The team travels by subway or bus, not by a long drive across a campus. Practice may be a train ride from the dorm. The city's sheer scale means an athlete is rarely the biggest name in town on any given night, but a good game can still fill a gym.

CUNY's campuses, spread across all five boroughs, offer the broadest version of the story. They are public institutions with large, commuter-heavy student bodies, and their teams give neighborhoods a local program that costs little to attend. The system's free-college founding in 1847 is part of the identity; the history is in CUNY: the first free public college, 1847. If you are looking for an event that feels like a neighborhood gathering, a CUNY game or an independent college's home date is a good bet.

Where the pros fit

It is worth saying what college sports are not: they are not a replacement for the pro teams, and no one in the city pretends otherwise. The Knicks' title in June 2026, the first since 1973, filled the streets in a way no college game does. But the two kinds of sport coexist easily, and many New Yorkers follow both. For the city's pro landscape, see The Liberty from 1997 to the 2024 title, The Islanders at UBS Arena and Yankee Stadium: two ballparks compared.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic