Blog
MoMA and its 1929 founding
How three women and a group of original trustees created the Museum of Modern Art in 1929, and why a 27-year-old Alfred H. Barr, Jr. became its first director.
Start with the date, because it is the kind of detail New Yorkers repeat with a little relish. The Museum of Modern Art was created in 1929, the year the stock market fell off its ledge in October. Somebody had the nerve to open a museum for living artists in the same autumn that half of Wall Street was learning what a margin call felt like. That is either the most New York thing in the history of the city's culture or a coincidence, and the museum itself has never been shy about which one it prefers.
The founding story is short, and it has names in it. According to the museum's own account, MoMA was created in 1929 by Lillie P. Bliss, Mary Quinn Sullivan and Abby Aldrich Rockefeller, together with a small group of other original trustees. Alfred H. Barr, Jr. was its founding director. Everything the museum became, from the painting-and-sculpture galleries on West 53rd Street to the film archive to the design collection that put a chair and a helicopter in the same building, grew out of what those people decided in the first months.
Three founders and a job to do
It helps to remember what the city's art world looked like in the late 1920s. The Metropolitan Museum of Art had been on Fifth Avenue since 1880 and had made its name on antiquities, old masters and the gifts of the Gilded Age. If you wanted to see a Cézanne or a Van Gogh in New York, you caught one on loan or you visited a dealer or a private home. There was not a single place in the city whose whole job was to collect and show the art of the last few decades and the art being made that year. The three founders saw the gap and decided to fill it.
Bliss, Sullivan and Rockefeller each brought something different to the table. Bliss was a collector with a serious eye for the French moderns. Sullivan was an art patron and teacher who knew how to get things done in committee. Abby Aldrich Rockefeller, the wife of John D. Rockefeller, Jr., brought the Rockefeller name and a family that would, over the following decades, give the museum land, money and a good deal of its character. The phrase "other original trustees" in the museum's history reminds you that a museum is never founded by three people alone; it is founded by whoever agrees to sign, show up and pay the bills.
The result was a private nonprofit museum, which matters for how it works today. MoMA is not a city agency. The City Council does not vote on its budget the way it votes on the Department of Parks. It is a trustee-run institution, which is why its ticket prices, hours and exhibition decisions are set by the museum, and why a reader who wants to know what it costs to get in on a given Friday should look at the museum's own site.
The man who ran it
The founders did something that sounds obvious now and was a bet then: they hired a very young scholar and let him build a museum. Alfred H. Barr, Jr. was the founding director. Barr was in his twenties, a former Wellesley College art historian who had been teaching one of the first college courses on modern art in the country. He was 27 when the museum opened its doors.
What Barr understood was that a modern museum could not simply be a gallery of paintings hung in a row. He wanted it to work like a university in the field of the new: departments for painting and sculpture, but also architecture, photography, design and film. That sprawling ambition is the reason you can walk into MoMA today and find a chair, a typeface, a movie poster and a Picasso under one roof. The museum's own history leans on Barr's name for exactly that reason, and the idea that modern art was a whole way of seeing, not just a style of painting, is the original MoMA argument.
Where the doors first opened
The first home was not a palace. The museum opened in November 1929 in rented rooms on an upper floor of a commercial office building on Fifth Avenue, at 730 Fifth, a few blocks north of where it stands now. The opening show was devoted to four painters, Cézanne, Gauguin, Seurat and Van Gogh, a deliberate choice to start with the artists who had broken the rules a generation earlier. Rented rooms were enough to prove the idea. It was not enough to hold what the museum was about to become.
The museum then moved more than once in its first decade. In 1939 it opened in the building on West 53rd Street that has been its address ever since, a glass-fronted modern structure designed to look like the thing the museum was collecting. The site has been expanded and rebuilt more than once since then, and the museum has continued to grow in the same neighborhood, in the middle of the band of Manhattan that the neighborhood guide calls Midtown: generally 34th to 59th Street, Third to Eighth Avenue. See Midtown for what else is in the area, and Midtown from 34th Street to 59th for a walk through the grid around it.
The museum in its year
Put the founding in the calendar and you can see how odd the timing was. The museum's story begins in 1929, a date that also sits near the start of the Great Depression. The city's money was about to shrink, and its appetite for new buildings and new institutions along with it. Yet the museum survived and grew through those years, in part because its founders had both money and the kind of civic patience that a trustee board needs when the news is bad. It is also a good reminder that New York's cultural institutions have often been founded by private citizens who decided that the city needed something, not by a department or an act of government.
Compare that with the other great museums in the city's lineup. The American Museum of Natural History was founded in 1869 by a special act of the New York State Legislature. The Metropolitan Museum of Art was incorporated on April 13, 1870. The Guggenheim began as a foundation in 1937 and opened its famous spiral on October 21, 1959; the story of how it got there is in The Guggenheim and Frank Lloyd Wright. The Whitney was founded in 1930. MoMA's founding year of 1929 puts it first in the modern-art sequence, ahead of the Whitney by a year and ahead of the Guggenheim by eight. For the full ladder of dates, museum founding years, 1869 to 2015 lays the institutions out in order.
What the founding still explains
The founding story is not just trivia. It explains three things a visitor notices.
First, the breadth. A museum organized by a scholar who thought of modern art as an entire visual culture ends up with departments that other museums bolted on later. That is why architecture, design and film are as central here as painting.
Second, the neighborhood. A museum that began on Fifth Avenue and settled on West 53rd Street is part of the Midtown cultural belt, a short walk from Rockefeller Center and a few subway stops from Times Square. Transit is plentiful: the Midtown listing in the neighborhood records mentions Times Sq-42 St and Grand Central-42 St among the area's major stations, and for the museum's own block the nearest subway entrances are on the museum's website.
Third, the private character. Because the founders were private citizens, the museum is run by trustees and a director, with a public mission written into its charter. If you are curious who is in charge today or what a ticket costs this month, the museum's own pages are the place to check. The date that does not change is 1929.
A short reading list for a visit
If you want to see the founding idea at work, here are three ways in.
- Start with the old argument. The 1929 opening show was devoted to Cézanne, Gauguin, Seurat and Van Gogh. When you walk through the painting galleries, look at how the museum still treats those artists as the hinge between the nineteenth century and the twentieth.
- Walk the design rooms. The department's presence is a direct line back to Barr's idea that a chair and a canvas belong in the same conversation.
- Use the neighborhood. MoMA sits within a short walk of the Midtown art-and-music cluster; Carnegie Hall's 1891 opening is a separate story in Carnegie Hall since 1891, and the New York museum comparison in art museums and science museums compared shows how the institutions differ in age, size and purpose.
For a rainy afternoon plan, a rainy day in the museums has a route through several of the big names, and museums by subway stop maps them to the trains.
The detail that stays with you
What the history of MoMA gives you, more than any single date, is a pattern. A few people decide the city needs a thing. They find a director young enough to take the risk. They rent a floor, open in the worst possible season, put up a show that makes an argument, and then spend the next ninety years building the rest. New York has done that with museums, with libraries, with parks and with subways. The Museum of Modern Art is the clearest example the arts have: three founders, a set of original trustees, a 27-year-old director and an opening in the autumn of 1929.
That is a better story than "a museum was established," and it is true.