Blog

Art museums and science museums compared

The Met and MoMA against the American Museum of Natural History and the New York Hall of Science: founding dates, scale, and the way to each by transit.

The city's museums do not sort themselves neatly. A child dragged to an art museum on a Saturday and a child dragged to a natural history museum on the same Saturday will both complain about their feet. But the institutions behind them are different in how they began, what they collect and how they ask visitors to spend a day, and the differences are worth setting out.

Four institutions make a useful comparison: two of art, the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the Museum of Modern Art, and two of science, the American Museum of Natural History and the New York Hall of Science in Queens.

When each began

The founding dates are the first thing the museums' own sites give, and they run in an order that most people do not expect.

Museum Founding fact Source
American Museum of Natural History Founded 1869 by a special act of the New York State Legislature The museum's site
Metropolitan Museum of Art Incorporated April 13, 1870 The museum's history page
Museum of Modern Art Created in 1929 by Lillie P. Bliss, Mary Quinn Sullivan, Abby Aldrich Rockefeller and other original trustees The museum's site
New York Hall of Science Sits in Flushing Meadows Corona Park The MTA's neighborhood guide

The first surprise is that the natural history museum is a year older than the Met. The American Museum of Natural History was founded in 1869 by a special act of the state legislature, and the Metropolitan Museum was incorporated on April 13, 1870. In the years after the Civil War, New York was building the cultural institutions of a great city all at once, and the science museum and the art museum were part of the same wave. The Metropolitan Museum from 1870 to 1902 covers the Met's early years, and museum founding years, 1869 to 2015 sets all the city's museums in order.

The second surprise is that the Museum of Modern Art is far younger. It was created in 1929, nearly sixty years after the Met, with Alfred H. Barr, Jr. as founding director. A museum devoted to the art of its own era was a later idea, and the 1929 date places it in the year the stock market crashed. MoMA and its 1929 founding tells the story.

How each reached its building

A museum's founding and its building are two different dates, and the gaps are instructive.

The Met opened to the public in the Dodworth Building at 681 Fifth Avenue before moving to its current site at Fifth Avenue and 82nd Street, which it opened on March 30, 1880. The Beaux-Arts Fifth Avenue facade and Great Hall opened in December 1902. In other words, the museum has been on the same site for nearly 150 years, and the entrance most visitors use is more than a century old. The Met's own history page has the full account.

The natural history museum is on the Upper West Side, beside Central Park, and is served by the 81 St-Museum of Natural History station on the B and C. Its address is part of its identity: the station is named for the museum.

MoMA is in Midtown. The museum's own site gives its history and its current visitor information.

The New York Hall of Science is a different kind of case. It sits in Flushing Meadows Corona Park in Queens, a park whose land reverted to the City in 1967 and which hosted the 1939-40 and 1964-65 World's Fairs. A science museum in a former fairground is a fitting arrangement, because world's fairs were always partly about showing the public what science and technology could do. Flushing Meadows-Corona Park and its two World's Fairs tells the park's story.

Scale: what each holds

Scale is hard to compare across kinds of collections, but the museums offer their own counts.

  • The American Museum of Natural History reports more than 40 permanent exhibition halls and more than 30 million specimens and objects. The American Museum of Natural History covers it in detail.
  • The Brooklyn Museum, which belongs in any comparison of the city's big museums, holds more than 140,000 objects covering over 6,000 years. The Brooklyn Museum covers it.

Divide the natural history museum's 30 million specimens by its 40 halls and you get an average of 750,000 objects per hall, a figure that is a reminder that most of a museum like this is not on display. A museum of science and natural history is a research collection first, and the exhibition halls are the public part. An art museum has a different relationship. The Brooklyn Museum's 140,000 objects over 6,000 years is more than two hundred times smaller than 30 million in raw count, though the two are not measuring the same thing.

This is the deepest difference between the two kinds. A natural history collection is built from specimens: a count of things that may number in the millions because each one is evidence. An art collection is built from works, each chosen individually, and a collection of 140,000 is a large one.

Getting to each

The transit map does a lot of the planning. From the MTA's station data:

  • The Met is on the Upper East Side, on Fifth Avenue at 82nd Street. The nearest subway lines are on Lexington Avenue, where the 6 stops at 77 St and 86 St. Walking across to Fifth Avenue is part of the visit. Upper East Side covers the neighborhood.
  • The American Museum of Natural History is on the Upper West Side, at the 81 St-Museum of Natural History station, served by the B and C. Along Central Park West the B and C run the length of the neighborhood. Upper West Side covers it, and The Upper West Side from Lincoln Center to the Museum of Natural History walks it.
  • MoMA is in Midtown, which the MTA describes as running from 34th to 59th Street and from Third to Eighth Avenue. A great many lines serve it; the nearest station depends on where you start. Midtown covers the area.
  • The New York Hall of Science is in Flushing Meadows Corona Park. The Metropolitan Transportation Authority's trip planner shows the best route from your starting point.

For the Upper East Side side, the Met's Fifth Avenue stretch is covered in The Upper East Side from Hunter College to The Met. The subway fare is $3 as of 2026, with a seven-day cap of $35 on subway and local bus rides. museums by subway stop lists the city's museums by station.

Which is better for whom

The question parents ask is where to take children, and the honest answer depends on the child.

For small children, a museum of science and natural history has an obvious advantage. The objects are big and legible: a skeleton needs no explanation. A museum built around halls of animals and dinosaurs gives a restless child something to look at in every direction. A science center built for hands-on exhibits is the kind of place children are invited to touch things. Visiting New York with kids covers visits with children, and the family museums topic page collects the city's options.

For older children and adults, an art museum offers a different pace. A person can spend an hour in a single gallery and not be bored. The Met's collections are vast, and so is the building, and the usual advice is to choose two or three galleries and leave.

For a rainy day, all four are good. Central Park's normals put annual precipitation at 49.52 inches, and a rainy day is a common day. a rainy day in the museums covers how to use museums on one.

For free, admission policies change, and each museum's site lists current prices and any free hours. Free things to do in New York City collects the city's free options.

The Guggenheim and the Whitney, briefly

Two other art museums complete the picture. The Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum's foundation was founded in 1937, Frank Lloyd Wright received the commission in 1943, and the museum opened on October 21, 1959. The Whitney Museum of American Art was founded in 1930, opened in 1931 on West Eighth Street, moved into a Marcel Breuer building on Madison Avenue in 1966, and has been at 99 Gansevoort Street since May 1, 2015. The Guggenheim and Frank Lloyd Wright and The Whitney's three homes cover them.

Those dates make a useful point about the art museums as a group. Most of them moved, and most of them waited decades for a building. The science museums, by contrast, tend to have a single home. The Met has been on Fifth Avenue since 1880, and the Natural History Museum has been on its Central Park West site for generations. An art museum's building is often an argument about what art is, and a science museum's building is often a place to put things.

A plan for a two-museum day

If you want to see one of each in a day, the pairing that works best on the map is the Met and the Museum of Natural History, because they face each other across Central Park, on the park's east and west sides. A visitor can cross the park on foot, in good weather, between visits. From the Met on Fifth Avenue to Central Park West is a walk across the park's width of about half a mile. Each museum is large enough that doing both in a single day means seeing a slice of each, so pick your galleries first.

The Hall of Science, in Queens, is a trip of its own, and it pairs naturally with the rest of Flushing Meadows Corona Park.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic