Blog

The Guggenheim and Frank Lloyd Wright

The foundation's 1937 start, Frank Lloyd Wright's 1943 commission and the opening of the Fifth Avenue museum on October 21, 1959.

Three dates tell most of the story of the building on Fifth Avenue that looks like a stack of white drums. In 1937 a foundation was started. In 1943 an architect received a commission. On October 21, 1959 the museum opened. Between the second date and the third lay sixteen years, which is long enough for a war, a death, a change of directors and a great deal of argument. The delay is part of what makes the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum one of the most distinctive buildings in New York, and one of the few museums in the city that people visit as much for the room as for what hangs in it.

1937: a foundation first

The museum's official history begins with the Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation, which was founded in 1937. The order matters. The institution began as a foundation devoted to collecting and showing art, and the building came later. That is the reverse of the usual pattern, in which a museum is conceived around a site. Here the collection and the mission came first and the home had to be invented to suit them.

That sequence sets the Guggenheim apart from the museums that grew out of a civic act. The American Museum of Natural History was founded in 1869 by a special act of the State Legislature. The Metropolitan Museum of Art was incorporated on April 13, 1870, and opened at its current Fifth Avenue site on March 30, 1880. The Museum of Modern Art was created in 1929; see MoMA and its 1929 founding. The Guggenheim belongs to the group of New York museums that began as the project of a private founder and a founding idea, and it spent its first decades finding a permanent address. For all of these dates side by side, museum founding years, 1869 to 2015 is the list to keep handy.

1943: the commission

The museum's history gives the next date plainly: Frank Lloyd Wright received the commission in 1943. Wright was by then one of the most famous architects in the country, known for houses that spread across the landscape and for a habit of ignoring conventional advice. The idea of giving him a museum to build in the middle of Manhattan, a city of right angles, is the kind of decision that looks obvious in hindsight and bold at the time.

What Wright designed was a spiral. Instead of a series of rooms off a corridor, the museum's main gallery is one continuous ramp that winds upward around an open central space under a skylight. A visitor can ride to the top and walk down, following the ramp, with the art on the wall at each turn. It is a design that makes the building itself the first thing you remember, and that makes some artists and curators nervous, because the curved walls and sloping floor are an unusual place to hang a painting. The debate about whether the building competes with the art has run as long as the museum has.

The site is on Fifth Avenue, along the edge of Central Park, in the part of Manhattan the neighborhood guide treats as the Upper East Side, east of the park and north of East Midtown. Central Park from 59th Street to 110th describes the park the building faces, and The Upper East Side from Hunter College to The Met walks through the neighborhood. The Upper East Side is served by the 6 train at 59 St, 68 St, 77 St and 86 St, and by the Second Avenue Q at 72, 86 and 96 St, and the museum is within walking distance of those stations. For the neighborhood profile, see Upper East Side.

Sixteen years

The interval between the commission and the opening is long enough to deserve its own treatment. From 1943 to 1959 the building was designed, redesigned, argued over, financed and built. A museum is a complicated project at any time, and one with a continuous spiral ramp and a skylight was more complicated than most. Large civic buildings in New York have often taken years to finish, because they involve zoning, building codes, money and people with strong opinions. The city has had a formal process for land use for a very long time; see the 1916 zoning resolution for the origin of the zoning rules the building had to live under.

The delay also meant that the founding patron did not live to see it. Solomon Guggenheim died in 1949, and Wright died in April 1959, a few months before the opening. The result is that the building that opened in the autumn of 1959 was completed by others, to a design its architect did not see in use. That fact, widely noted in the architecture world, adds a note of sadness to a story that otherwise ends in a triumph.

October 21, 1959

The museum's own history states the opening date: October 21, 1959. A crowd came, the reviews arrived, and the building became a New York landmark in the everyday sense long before any formal designation. The Landmarks Preservation Commission, created by the Landmarks Law in 1965 after the loss of the original Pennsylvania Station, protects individual landmarks across the five boroughs; the commission's own count is 1,470 individual landmarks and 157 historic districts and extensions. Landmarks Preservation Commission has the agency profile, and The Landmarks Law and the loss of Penn Station explains the law's origin. The Guggenheim is among the buildings that give the landmark idea its meaning: a work of design that people would not want to see lost.

What a visit is like

A visit to the Guggenheim has a rhythm of its own. Most people take the elevator to the top and walk down the ramp, so the building unrolls in a single long descent. The permanent collection and the changing exhibitions share the space, and the museum's own website lists what is on, with hours and ticket information that vary by day. Because the building is so unusual, it is worth giving it time even if you are not a regular museumgoer. Look up when you enter. The skylight and the rotunda are the reason the architect is famous.

A few suggestions for a first visit:

  1. Check the museum's site first. Hours, tickets and special exhibitions change, and the museum's own pages are authoritative.
  2. Start at the top and walk down. That is the direction the design invites.
  3. Look at the building, not just the walls. The ramp, the rotunda and the skylight are the whole point.
  4. Pair it with the park. Central Park is across the street, and a walk afterward is one of the best uses of an afternoon.

For a wider plan, art museums and science museums compared sets the Guggenheim beside the other major institutions, a rainy day in the museums sketches a wet-weather itinerary, and museums by subway stop connects them to the trains. For a family, Visiting New York with kids suggests ways to pace a day.

Why the building matters

The Guggenheim is a reminder that a city's museums are also its buildings. The Metropolitan's Beaux-Arts facade and Great Hall opened in December 1902. The Whitney has had three homes, the latest at 99 Gansevoort Street, which opened on May 1, 2015; The Whitney's three homes tells that story. The Guggenheim has one home, and it is the one Wright drew.

So the three dates stand for three things. The foundation of 1937 is the idea. The commission of 1943 is the decision. The opening on October 21, 1959 is the building. Everything else, the exhibitions, the crowds, the arguments over whether a spiral is a good place for a painting, has been happening on Fifth Avenue ever since.

Reading the building from the street

You do not need to be an architecture student to see what the design is doing. Stand across Fifth Avenue and look at three things.

First, the form. Most buildings on the avenue are boxes rising straight up from the sidewalk. This one widens as it climbs, so the top is broader than the bottom. That inversion is deliberate, and it is the opposite of a classic tower.

Second, the material and the color. The surface is smooth and curved, with a continuous band of windows at the top, instead of the stone and punched windows of its neighbors. It reads as one continuous gesture, not a stack of floors.

Third, the relationship to the park. The building sits on the park side of the avenue, and its curves answer the trees and the open sky behind it. Wright was known for insisting that a building belongs to its setting, and on Fifth Avenue he made the setting a foil: a rounded form against a wall of rectangles.

The artists and the argument

From the day it opened, the building has prompted a debate that never fully ends. Some artists and critics hold that the ramp and curved walls compete with the art. Others hold that the building is itself the greatest work in the collection and that the art gains from being seen in it. Both views are reasonable, and a visit lets you decide. A painting that hangs on a gently curved wall, seen from a slope, is a different experience from the same painting in a flat, white room, and some works are well suited to the shape while others are not.

The museum has handled the question over the decades through the way it stages exhibitions: using the ramp for one kind of display and adjacent galleries for another. Check the museum's site for how the current show is arranged.

How the date fits the city's story

October 21, 1959 sits in the middle of the period when the city was remaking itself. The United Nations had risen in Turtle Bay a few years earlier; The United Nations comes to Turtle Bay tells that story. The Empire State Building had stood since May 1, 1931, covered in The Empire State Building opens, 1931. A few years after the Guggenheim opened, in 1964, the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge and the second World's Fair arrived, and in 1965 the Landmarks Law followed. The museum's opening belongs to that wave of ambition, and its sixteen-year path from commission to ribbon is a good picture of how long big projects take.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic