Blog

The Whitney's three homes

Founded in 1930, the Whitney opened on West Eighth Street in 1931, moved to Breuer's Madison Avenue building in 1966, and reopened at 99 Gansevoort in 2015.

A museum that moves is a museum making an argument about where it belongs. The Whitney Museum of American Art has made that argument three times in its public life, in three neighborhoods that could hardly be more different from one another, and each address says something about what New York thought American art was for at the moment it moved. Follow the museum's own history from the beginning and you cover a good deal of the city's cultural geography, from the Village to the Upper East Side to the edge of the Hudson.

The dates are specific, and they come from the museum's own account of its history.

The timeline

Year What happened
1930 The museum is founded
1931 It opens on West Eighth Street
1966 The Madison Avenue building designed by Marcel Breuer opens
October 20, 2014 The museum closes its doors in the Breuer building after its tenancy there
May 1, 2015 The museum opens at 99 Gansevoort Street

Count the intervals. From 1966 to October 2014 is 48 years in the Breuer building, nearly half a century. From the closing on October 20, 2014 to the opening on May 1, 2015 is 193 days, a little over six months in which the museum had one building shut and the other not yet open. And from May 1, 2015 to the end of 2026 is more than eleven years at the current address, which means the Gansevoort Street building has already outlasted any single decade of the earlier ones.

The first home: West Eighth Street, 1931

The museum was founded in 1930 and opened the following year on West Eighth Street, in Greenwich Village. The neighborhood was the natural place for American art in those years. The Village was where painters, writers and musicians lived, and the streets around Washington Square were a working district for artists as much as a residential one. The museum was founded and opened in the first years of the Depression, at a time when the city was building its tallest towers: the Empire State Building opened on May 1, 1931, the same year the museum opened its doors.

The Village is still there, and still reachable by the subway lines that serve it. The W 4 St-Wash Sq station has the A, B, C, D, E, F and M, and the 8 St-NYU station has the R and W, both a short walk from West Eighth Street. Greenwich Village and Washington Square and the Villages describe the neighborhood, and NYU and Greenwich Village covers the university that now fills many of its blocks.

An early home on a street of rowhouses suggests a museum that thought of itself as part of a neighborhood, a place to which a person could walk from a studio. The Village also had its own politics and its own history: Stonewall, on June 28, 1969, began in Greenwich Village and is now a national monument, and the neighborhood's identity has been bound up with both art and freedom for most of a century. Stonewall, June 1969 tells that part of the story.

The second home: Breuer's building, 1966

The Whitney's second great address was on Madison Avenue on the Upper East Side, in a building designed by Marcel Breuer that opened in 1966. The move uptown put the museum in a very different part of the city. The Upper East Side, east of Central Park, is where the Metropolitan Museum of Art stands at Fifth Avenue and 82nd Street, and where the Guggenheim, which opened its Frank Lloyd Wright building on October 21, 1959, stands in the same museum district. A museum that moved to Madison Avenue in 1966 was joining a cluster, in the way that a business moves to a street where its competitors and its customers already are.

The subway stops that serve the area are the 6 train's stations at 59th, 68th (the Hunter College station), 77th and 86th Streets, and the Second Avenue line's Q at 72nd, 86th and 96th. Upper East Side and The Upper East Side from Hunter College to The Met describe the district.

What a modernist building meant in 1966 is a story of its own. The year before, Mayor Wagner had signed the Landmarks Law, which created the Landmarks Preservation Commission and changed how the city thought about old buildings. The Whitney's move to a new, severe, stone-and-concrete design arrived in the same breath as the argument over what the city should keep. The Landmarks Law and the loss of Penn Station covers that argument. The Whitney was in the Breuer building for nearly half a century, through the fiscal crisis of 1975 and the blackout of 1977 and the long recovery that followed. It was there when the city enlarged its Council in 1989 and when it passed through the events of 2001.

The third home: 99 Gansevoort Street, 2015

On May 1, 2015, the Whitney opened its building at 99 Gansevoort Street, on the western edge of downtown Manhattan, between the Village and Chelsea. After nearly half a century on Madison Avenue, the museum came back downtown, to within reach of the Hudson.

Chelsea, the neighborhood just north, is described in the city's neighborhood record as the home of West Chelsea's gallery district, with more than 300 contemporary-art galleries in about ten blocks, and of the High Line. The station options near the Chelsea side are the 14 St stops, where the A, C and E meet the F and M and the 1, 2 and 3, and the 8 Av stop on the L. Chelsea, Walking the High Line and West Chelsea's galleries and West Chelsea's gallery district cover the neighborhood in detail.

The move put the Whitney next to the district where living artists show, the opposite of the Madison Avenue museum row. It is a different bet about where American art lives: not in the old-money blocks of the Upper East Side, but among galleries, studios and the open waterfront.

What the three addresses say

Lined up, the three homes make a small history of the city's cultural geography.

  1. West Eighth Street, 1931. The artists' Village, a neighborhood scale, a museum you could walk to from a studio.
  2. Madison Avenue, 1966. The museum row, a purpose-built building by a celebrated architect, a statement of institutional permanence.
  3. Gansevoort Street, 2015. The waterfront and gallery district, a building opened in the era of the High Line and the revived western edge of Manhattan.

Each move traded something. The Village gave intimacy; Madison Avenue gave authority; Gansevoort Street gave proximity to the living scene. The museum's founding year, 1930, and its current address are separated by 85 years, and in that time it has gone from a neighborhood of Village streets to a design statement and back to a downtown destination.

What else was happening on each date

Set the museum's moves against the city's calendar and the dates start to talk to each other.

  • 1930 to 1931. The Empire State Building opens on May 1, 1931, at 1,454 feet with its antenna. The Harlem Renaissance, which ran from about 1918 to the mid-1930s, is in its last years. The city is a place of enormous ambition and thin money.
  • 1966. The Landmarks Law is a year old. The 1964 World's Fair at Flushing Meadows has just closed its second season, the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge has been open since November 21, 1964, and the Guggenheim has been open for seven years.
  • 2014 to 2015. The city is two years past Hurricane Sandy, whose storm tide at the Battery reached 14.06 feet above mean lower low water. The High Line and the West Chelsea galleries are established, and the waterfront is being rebuilt as a place to walk.

None of this explains the Whitney's decisions. It is simply the setting in which each one was made, and it is a reminder that a museum is a building, a collection and a bet on a neighborhood, all at once. The Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge opens in 1964 and Hurricane Sandy, October 2012: the record cover two of those dates in full.

Where it fits among the museums

A museum timeline helps to place the Whitney in the city's order of founding. The American Museum of Natural History was founded in 1869 by a special act of the state legislature. The Metropolitan Museum of Art was incorporated on April 13, 1870. The Museum of Modern Art was created in 1929 by Lillie P. Bliss, Mary Quinn Sullivan, Abby Aldrich Rockefeller and other original trustees, with Alfred H. Barr, Jr. as founding director. The Guggenheim's foundation dates to 1937, with Frank Lloyd Wright commissioned in 1943 and the museum opening in 1959. The Whitney, founded in 1930, is a year younger than MoMA and seven years older than the Guggenheim Foundation. museum founding years, 1869 to 2015 places all of them side by side, and art museums and science museums compared sorts them by what they hold.

The four modern-art institutions of the early twentieth century, MoMA, the Whitney and the Guggenheim among them, were all products of the interwar years, and each chose its own neighborhood. For a visitor, the museums by subway stop is the easiest way to plan: museums by subway stop works through it.

Visiting

The museum's own site gives hours, admission and current exhibitions, and it is the place to check. The subway fare as of 2026 is $3, and the stations named above are the ones in the neighborhood records. If you visit the Gansevoort Street building, it is worth planning the day around the High Line and West Chelsea's galleries, which are within walking distance. If you want to see the older addresses, West Eighth Street is a short walk through the Village, and the Madison Avenue building stands on the Upper East Side, a reminder that a city's institutions move more often than its buildings do.

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic